Thanks for all the suggestions. Thus far I tried all the Five Pawns, Charlie Noble, Nicoticket and a bunch of The Steam Co juices.
And drum roll please... my current all day vape is Moment 37 from The Steam Co. An apple pie type juice, kinda similar to 5P gambit.
I also regularly switch in Gentlemen's Reserve, Old English Orchid Reserve and SCDP, all also from The Steam Co. I can't recommend The Steam Co enough. Not outrageously priced like Five Pawns but they carry a lot of similar flavors.
Gentleman's Reserve is similar to Castle Long but not quite as good imo. However the price for CL is 2x and GR is nearly as good. Same goes for Moment 37, its not quite as refined as Gambit but its very close. With Gambit you can clearly taste each note in sequence where Moment 37 kind of gives you all the notes together at the same time.
As for the other vendors/juices:
Five Pawns - potential ADVs were Caste Long and Gambit both excellent but the price is very high. Truth be told if I hadn't found The Steam Co surrogates these would be my ADVs.
Charlie Noble - no real ADVs here, these are dripping juices and I want my ADV to run well on a tank. That said I do like their juices and drip them regularly. Some that I like are Treasure Island a Cereal Killa type juice, Commodore Peary an unsweetened pear type juice.
Nicoticket - Liked em at first but once I lost my sweet tooth and found out they put diketones in almost every juice I really soured on them. All their offerings are either clawingly sweet or have a ton of vanilla + diketones in them. I really wanted to like them since they are so popular on ECF but I just didn't. The one that had the best chance was GCD but it is just too cinnamon forward for me.
Open to more suggestions and thanks again!