Advanced Battery Questions: Discharge Curve Graphs / Charts

Status
Not open for further replies.

HecticEnergy

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 24, 2014
2,417
1,638
TX, USA
In Stock genuine high discharge rate rechargeable cylindrical 18650 Li-Ion batteries Sony, LG, Samsung from PowerStream; authentic 18650HE2, US18650VCT4, US18650VCT5, VTC4, VTC5, INR18650-25R with battery data sheet and discharge curves

I have no background in chemistry or advanced electronics, so I have some questions about these charts.
Disclamer: I'm not suggesting we go off the pulse rating when picking batteries as it is not a safe practice. It is possible for your mod to malfunction and continuously fire which would be LESS of a concern when operating within the continous discharge ratings (though over discharge could still be a concern as well as heat build up from your atty causing hot batteries) and also Pulse durations are different for every manufacture.
my observations:
On graphs showing continues discharge curves temperature seems to have an effect on aH rating and when the voltage makes its sharp downward curve.
For example, It seems like a lower amp draw would be a smooth curve, or extend past the others, but the graph shows the .5amp draw stays higher longer but drops off short of every other amp draw (except for the 40 amp draw on a VTC5).
All this is really moot, since the graphs show sharp drop off below 3.5v and I usually swap batteries between 3.5-3.7v.
My question was is it the temperature that causes a smoother curve? and if so, is this applicable for vaping? I mean, we don't actually "Continuously" discharge the batteries - flipping them on for extended periods of time, allowing the heat to build up. We follow more of a "Pulse" curve I think, pressing the button for 2-15 seconds (depending on airflow, hit type, and potentially lung copacity) then having a short rest period before hitting the button again. Unless a chain vaper is being observed, there are generally long breaks between vape sessions (I'd say 5-15 pulls per vape session). Of course as an extra measure of safety we should (again) not use the pulse rating on batteries, as the duration of the pulse seems to very between battery manufactures (I read LG HE2s pulse rating is based on 90second pulses, which is why efest is comfortable rating them as 35amp batteries).
I've seen kidney punchers battery tests which does a .2ohm coil with 2sec on 60sec off or something of that nature, but I don't think that accurately illustrates how we (most of "us" vapers anyway) use batteries. Granted everyones usage is different, it seems like several pulses with longer rest periods every so often would be a more accurate measurement.. I'm sure on a .2 or lower you could chain vape the battery dead that way, but you've got too much time on your hands if thats how you discharge with a >.8ohm coil :) I'm sure those vaping at or below .2 ohms is the sect most interested in this data, but I was wondering which batter performs better/longer with a 15-20amp draw as thats more in lines with what I run with a dual coil, or 8-15amp with a single coil.

If anyone has any thoughts, corrections, or more information on any of this I greatly appreciate your post :)
Thanks! Hectic.
 

Rat2chat2

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 16, 2013
11,842
53,633
North Carolina
I'm not sure if this will help answer some of your concerns or not (so don't get upset with me). Here is a link that has some great information from what I have read. Charts and graphs and everything.

Battery test-review 18650 individual tests
JC_link.gif


I am sure someone will come along that can really help you. I only buy recommended batteries and charge them when then get to 3.7 and that is all I am concerned with. Sorry if this did not help, but at least I tried. :D
 

HecticEnergy

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 24, 2014
2,417
1,638
TX, USA
I'm not sure if this will help answer some of your concerns or not (so don't get upset with me). Here is a link that has some great information from what I have read. Charts and graphs and everything.

Battery test-review 18650 individual tests
JC_link.gif


I am sure someone will come along that can really help you. I only buy recommended batteries and charge them when then get to 3.7 and that is all I am concerned with. Sorry if this did not help, but at least I tried. :D

Worked now :)
I looked at the charts for the VTC5 and didn't see the pulse tests, maybe they are just unpublished for that battery. They did have a chart measuring aH pushing a variety of amps, which was interesting as it seemed to be different than the results posted on powerstream (my link)
I didn't see the LG HE2s listed on the page. These are the batteries I have, so these are the ones I looked for :)
All in all, defiantly lots of charts and numbers! haha
Also, a CRAP ton of batteries I would NEVER run :)
 

HecticEnergy

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 24, 2014
2,417
1,638
TX, USA
Pulse tests are meaningless. Name me one thing that uses a battery that depends on the definition of a "pulse" of current? Besides trying to make that work for vaping by stretching max discharge rates to mean anything someone wants to wish/hope/believe in.

Again, I'm sticking to Continuous discharge rates, as I recommend EVERYONE does for vaping.
My question was more related to the temperature of the battery under load may effect the performance of the battery. The way most vape is several 2-20sec (or so) "pulses" followed by long rest periods where the temperature of the battery is able to fall to the ambient temperature of where it is sitting. I am no battery expert or chemist and was looking for someone to chime if the battery chemistry causes the battery to operate better at certain temperatures and worse at others. A test on the battery i imagine is back to back, IE no long rest periods for the battery temperature to drop. Even the pulse tests are done 1sec on 60sec off or something to that effect, with no real breaks. I don't super sub ohm (never built and fired a coil under .2ohms, and usually vape over .6ohms) and am not looking for a justification to exceed the battery's continuous discharge rating. I am more looking to see if there is any research that has been done that would show that a battery will perform longer under a certain load given the way we use them.
 

Froth

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 1, 2014
1,184
1,592
Chipotle.
Pulse tests are meaningless. Name me one thing that uses a battery that depends on the definition of a "pulse" of current? Besides trying to make that work for vaping by stretching max discharge rates to mean anything someone wants to wish/hope/believe in.
Does a portable Personal Defibrillator count? Hey...You asked!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread