sadie, i think the general jist of your inquiry is whether or not you will be satisfied by a pv when you use it to reduce your desire for analogs. That is a question that could be answered a little different by every user on this forum, so i will just tell you a little about my experiences.
I am 58 year old female who had smoked for over 35 years. A lot !
Being tied to a computer in my home office day in and day out, i was smoking a lot more than usual, prices were rising and my husband and i were going through 3-4 cartons per week.
About 1.5 years ago, i heard about pv's, mostly through an internet ad about gamucci, which as it turned out was not a good deal, but it got me reseaching and i found some mini's for sale on ebay. They were ok i thought, but carts were insufficient and tasta and battery liife was horrible. After even more reseach i found this forum.
At first, like so many, i thought i wanted something that looked and tasted like my analogs.
After many false starts, and much experimenting, i have found what seems to satisfy me. My 510's, kr808-1's, and a few mods i have collected seem to do the trick, but if i was limited to only one or two, it would be the 510 and the kr808....
Yes, there is what some think of as hassle, the batts, the
juice, the refilling, all the little things we learn about on our journey.
But i can honestly say that other than my husband and my daughter,
vaping is the best decision i ever made in my life.
I cannot tolerate the taste of an analog now, however, i can be in the room or vehicle with my husband smoking and it does not offend me or make me crave. That was one of my big excuses for not quitting, not wanting to become one of those exsmokers... The ones that make any smoker around them miserable. Yet, i am free of the chains that bound me for so many years.
Try a good reliable model, some good
juice (maybe a sampler pace to see what you like, as you will probably be surprised). It's well worth the investment. And those who find it's not to their liking are usually able to dispense of their equipment easily through the classifieds here, so there is little is any monetary risk.
No one can guarantee that you will be satisfied, but i can guarantee that if you don't try, you will always wonder....
Good luck to you, and welcome to the forum, lot's of great info here and countless helpful people.