I'd replace the charger. I doubt that overcharging slightly--once-- even if your charger was reading correctly which it may not be, well, the battery is most likely okay although it's not something you want to keep doing routinely.
I have a nitecore intellecharger two bay and I like it. I wouldn't mind a 4 bay at some point, but so far mine has been pretty reliable. The sleds were a bit rough but eased up as I used it. I could've probably lubricated the sleds when I got it, too, that would have solved the problem. Xtar is another brand that gets good reviews.
Best of luck,
Anna