Got to wondering what was up with this so I did a little Googling.
The charger manual in PDF format
is here.
From that, the 'charge status: poor' message means the battery internal resistance is over 250 milliohms. This means the battery should probably be replaced ... if the IR reading is correct. Lots of cheap analyzers/chargers do a bad job of measuring battery IR. I don't know how good yours is. If the IR is really high your battery will not have much run time on a charge compared to when it was new.
FWIW, I trust IMR
batteries.com to sell authentic, good batteries.
Hope this helps a bit