E-Cig Summit 2014 videos now available!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Oliver

ECF Founder, formerly SmokeyJoe
Admin
Verified Member
Very interesting that McFiggans responded so forcefully to the reporter's alarmist overinterpretation of his study. I was rather under the impression that's exactly what their intent was: present some weak, equivocal findings about grossly exaggerated exposures in the hopes somebody (glANTZ?) would run with it and draw sweeping and ridiculous FUD conclusions.

Not quite sure what to make of this public criticism he lashed at the reporting...

I see it slightly differently. I don't think McFiggans was aware of the politics behind all of this. Do note Amanda hauling him up during the panel discussion - she was quite cross that he glossed over the contextual slides, and forced him into answering a couple of questions he'd answered during the pre-summit conversation they'd had.

And also, note his voluntary contextualizing during the panel discussion: The 1-2 nanometers exposure from forest terpenoids: "If it's all about particle size we're all done for".
 

BuGlen

Divergent
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 6, 2012
1,952
3,976
Tampa, Florida
Oops, sorry about that - the Ian Gray and Hazel Cheeseman video has been reuploaded and should work now. Sorry for the oversight.

Regarding the AHA - they were there. Check out panel debate 2 at 17:01

Thanks! I was able to catch up on that presentation just now, and it was (also) very well done.

Regarding the AHA, I knew they were there with their precautionary principal argument. My (poorly worded) comment was a bit tongue-in-cheek in the hopes that their invite for next year would be lost in the mail. Purely accidentally, of course.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread