I've been enjoying the conversation collection here so much tonight! Thank You!
With such a wide field of record-breakingly excellent contestants, it wasn't easy, and it took me a minute, but here's my personal fave, which I am confident is a shoo-in to for the coveted Best.Post.Juxtaposition.Ever.Award.
...women are easy to understand...
...I've seen them, but have never blowed one up..
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Topic Change Zone
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
...+1 in Kristin's QSMB post...
Can I + like a googillion?
YES! That says so many things that I've wanted to say, and just couldn't get it to come out making sense, being polite, and under 7000 words!
Props, Miss Kristin!
But this is the part I've been pondering lately:
"we all have the same goal of getting people to quit smoking"
As I read more there, I've wondered if I've been oversimplifying the terrain of that common ground, projecting too much of my own worldview on it.
There's a distinction between making an actual permanent change to a different behavior and simply refraining from a behavior, there's a difference between depriving ourselves of a thing and indulging in something we like better.
Here, the shared goals we have are very cut-and-dried - reduce or cease the consumption of tobacco cigarettes and use e-cigarettes instead.
Our reasons for wanting to do that tend to be mundane and practical - things like a desire to live longer, avoid diseases, save money, or in my case, wanting to be more physically comfortable.
Whatever beliefs and primordial needs we may have as individuals exist independently of, and are even transcended by what we share, namely those very one-dimensional, temporal goals.
We support and encourage each other in every aspect of achieving them, from the basic ascent up the learning curve to the most minute details of the instruments we'll use to do it.
For the Quitistas, smoking, or ceasing to smoke, takes on a role that's almost symbolic of a larger, more spiritual process, or at least spiritual-adjacent.
I don't mean they don't want to stop smoking, I mean
they want to stop smoking in a materially different way, for a whole other layer of reasons.
I'm not sure if it's possible to separate their smoking cessation process from their beliefs or divorce it from those primordial needs.
They don't want to "upgrade" to a behavior or a device that is more pleasurable, they only want to renounce the pleasure of the original one and NOT replace it! That refraining, that renunciation and deprivation, are for them, crucial elements that must exist in order for their process to be in accord with their needs and beliefs.
...this nicodemon thing... works for me so why make fun of it?...
I enjoy the comical aspects of everything, but never with disrespect, certainly not malice, and I haven't perceived those things coming from other people. I probably have some beliefs that would make you smile, and if you did, I wouldn't take offense, I smile at some of them myself - and laugh out loud at others!
...I sincerely doubt new members are signing up in droves. Much of the new member activity lately has been driven by ECF.
That's going to cause some feelings on the part of some of the people there, specifically those who have been there a while and bonded with the place. And yeah, there's a little arpeggio of Galileo and the church, Ed Sullivan era culture and Elvis, lather rinse repeat for the Beatles, on and on, and we could probably have gone back and started with Scott Joplin (and all rejoice that I didn't).
Even with all that, I think there'll always be a place for forums like the Quitistas. For some people, "cold turkey" is simply a better fit - even the only fit - for a particular configuration of beliefs and deep-seated needs, and for some people, the whole process, as well as their
reasons for wanting to stop smoking, is so firmly rooted in those beliefs and needs that it wouldn't even make sense to try and separate it.
As I read the thoughts of people both here and there, my impression is that as is the case with me, for many if not most people here, those more "secular" or temporal goals are the whole ball of wax, the sum and substance of the prize, whereas there, they're almost incidental, just little bonus prizettes, in the context of that larger, more complex journey.
If someone who's just in it for the temporal, quotidian stuff about saving money or living more time on earth asked my advice, I'd tell them to come poke around here, even if they weren't interested in changing to e-cigarettes at all!
Oh, no, I've done it again! Maybe I should have put it on the blog, it's sort of an (extremely abbreviated, believe it or not) version of the Lost Rant cigarbabe Inspired, and now here comes Kristin inspiring so much of the same rantage.
Merciful sum-up: Any dialogue is good dialogue. Whole entire countries and cultures have been carrying on a variation of that same discussion for centuries on end, with results all over the map. There is common ground. Kristin's post has the potential to be a Turning Point. cigarbabe and Kristin are both awesome.