E-Cigarette Forum Discussion Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

Katmandu

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 28, 2010
544
466
Canada
I was just over reading -lol-'s blog and noticed that she had this to say:

The other day, I was reading a thread in the forums about some "anti-smoking" people who are, incredibly, strongly opposed to e-cigarettes.

For some, this is fixable, a simple matter of education.

For others, it's not about ignorance, but belief. You can't argue with a belief, nor can you educate it away. Maybe the believer can, but that's another topic.

Some may believe that belief and reason may have had a common ancestor back in autotroph days. (I was so young then, I don't remember).

Today, any shared heritage is forgotten, and belief doesn't even recognize the existence of reason, much less respond to it.


What do you think? Is she right? Because of their "belief" will they ever see the good that ecigs are?
 

ShannonA

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 15, 2011
2,346
1,122
Tyler, Tx
I was just over reading -lol-'s blog and noticed that she had this to say:

The other day, I was reading a thread in the forums about some "anti-smoking" people who are, incredibly, strongly opposed to e-cigarettes.

For some, this is fixable, a simple matter of education.

For others, it's not about ignorance, but belief. You can't argue with a belief, nor can you educate it away. Maybe the believer can, but that's another topic.

Some may believe that belief and reason may have had a common ancestor back in autotroph days. (I was so young then, I don't remember).

Today, any shared heritage is forgotten, and belief doesn't even recognize the existence of reason, much less respond to it.


What do you think? Is she right? Because of their "belief" will they ever see the good that ecigs are?

I thik she is but that's not my goal... I just want live and let live at least MOST of the time... some other QSMB members seem to feel the same. Its a select few that just won't give up... and quite frankly I've seen a couple of our own do some pot stirring as well.
 

deuxtrouble

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 3, 2011
106
151
55
Canada
I think she is also right. I have a friend who talks continuously about her religion. It is not my religion nor will it ever be and it is not something I believe in - and don't see myself changing that belief. However, I do listen to her and I am not ignorant when she speaks. I am knowledged about something else now that I was not before.

And that is what bothers me the most right now - you believe what you want - you don't have to believe what someone else is telling you - that is the great thing about free will and I will always fight for people to have the right to their beliefs, whether I agree with them or not.

I agree with no nicotine, but that is me and that is what I wanted. (emphasis on I). I agree that other individuals have had success working on the habit first and then losing the nicotine. I agree that the actual act of inhaling those chemicals in the form of cigarette smoke is killing people and I now agree that if you cannot quit - because they are out there - that using an e-cigarette is better than continuing to smoke.

I like everyone - kumbyah...LOL.
 

ShannonA

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 15, 2011
2,346
1,122
Tyler, Tx
I think she is also right. I have a friend who talks continuously about her religion. It is not my religion nor will it ever be and it is not something I believe in - and don't see myself changing that belief. However, I do listen to her and I am not ignorant when she speaks. I am knowledged about something else now that I was not before.

And that is what bothers me the most right now - you believe what you want - you don't have to believe what someone else is telling you - that is the great thing about free will and I will always fight for people to have the right to their beliefs, whether I agree with them or not.

I agree with no nicotine, but that is me and that is what I wanted. (emphasis on I). I agree that other individuals have had success working on the habit first and then losing the nicotine. I agree that the actual act of inhaling those chemicals in the form of cigarette smoke is killing people and I now agree that if you cannot quit - because they are out there - that using an e-cigarette is better than continuing to smoke.

I like everyone - kumbyah...LOL.

*SIGH* great there's another song stuck in my head... actually maybe we should post that song.... then again some members might be Atheist...NM
 

John Phoenix

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 12, 2011
1,527
880
New Orleans
I don't want to change their minds about the method they choose to use to quit. never. I do respect and understand that if that's what you need, if that is what works for you that's fine. They do not show me, perhaps us the same respect. They hate that I can give an opinion that may cause them to to have a harder time making converts to their method of choice. I believe this law of addiction stuff may be what some folks need. I also see it become an addiction and a religion in itself. They cannot see it they are too close to it.

As with anything that gains cult status, I think logic and reason can over come and change belief. But that's a very long hard road. Belief right or wrong is deep seated and is a culmination of experiences over a lifetime. Something led them to that point where they choose and accepted a belief. You'd not only have to undo the knowledge from that belief but cause the person to change their perception about their experiences that led them to that belief.
 

MustangSallie

Mistress Blabber Mouth
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 20, 2011
11,600
37,360
USA
I was just over reading -lol-'s blog and noticed that she had this to say:

The other day, I was reading a thread in the forums about some "anti-smoking" people who are, incredibly, strongly opposed to e-cigarettes.

For some, this is fixable, a simple matter of education.

For others, it's not about ignorance, but belief. You can't argue with a belief, nor can you educate it away. Maybe the believer can, but that's another topic.

Some may believe that belief and reason may have had a common ancestor back in autotroph days. (I was so young then, I don't remember).

Today, any shared heritage is forgotten, and belief doesn't even recognize the existence of reason, much less respond to it.


What do you think? Is she right? Because of their "belief" will they ever see the good that ecigs are?

Read that Kat, and I have to say that I largely agree with her. No I don't think we're going to change most minds over there, at least not the ones posting the hatred. But we might change a few minds that are still undecided. Isn't that what it's all about anyway? Just sharing what you know, and the listener can choose to do what they want with what they've heard. You can lead a horse to water.... Well you know the rest.
 

MustangSallie

Mistress Blabber Mouth
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 20, 2011
11,600
37,360
USA
I don't want to change their minds about the method they choose to use to quit. never. I do respect and understand that if that's what you need, if that is what works for you that's fine. They do not show me, perhaps us the same respect. They hate that I can give an opinion that may cause them to to have a harder time making converts to their method of choice. I believe this law of addiction stuff may be what some folks need. I also see it become an addiction and a religion in itself. They cannot see it they are too close to it.

As with anything that gains cult status, I think logic and reason can over come and change belief. But that's a very long hard road. Belief right or wrong is deep seated and is a culmination of experiences over a lifetime. Something led them to that point where they choose and accepted a belief. You'd not only have to undo the knowledge from that belief but cause the person to change their perception about their experiences that led them to that belief.

The problem is you're convinced you're right, and they're convinced they're right. It's a Mexican standoff.
 

ShannonA

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 15, 2011
2,346
1,122
Tyler, Tx
The problem is you're convinced you're right, and they're convinced they're right. It's a Mexican standoff.

XACTLY.... the only way the .......and yes that's precisely what it is...is if we let them believe what they believe...and who's to say they're not at least aprtially right....

However they need to allow us ours as well provided we don't shove it down their throats.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread