Follow Up Question on Chargers

Status
Not open for further replies.

100%VG

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 12, 2013
8,164
102,903
Starbase 12 near Risa
Hello,

On 6-23-2013, I posted this...

Absolute Best 18650 Charger

Hello Vets,

I'd like your opinions on the Absolute Best 18650 Battery Charger. It's OK if it charges other battery sizes, too, but I really need it for 18650's. I just bought 4 Panasonic IMR 2250's and I don't want them ruined by the Charger. I also have 4 14500's, but I'll deal with that separately if the Best charger doesn't do them.

I've read lots of Charger reviews, and I want something that follows the 18650 Battery Specs to every detail. I want it to totally stop charging at about 4.16V to 4.18V, without a Trickle Charge.

I've seen that the pila IBC is considered the Best by some people, but others say it's very touchy. Bump the table it's on, and it can stop charging.

It can be multi-slot, as long as each slot charges independently.

Some of the reviews I've seen show O-Scope Charge patterns, and some of them look pretty trashy.

I want True CC-CV (or at least True CC, as the Voltage usually rises with the charge), a Clean Charge Pattern (not cut-off the charging, sample, cut-on, charge, repeat), True Charge Termination below 4.2V, and Zero Trickle Charge. It should follow the 18650 Battery Spec for Charging.

I know very well that all of this is hard to find on one Charger, but that's is what I'm looking for.

Whatcha got?

Thanks in advance.

Almost everyone suggested the Nitecore IntelliCharger i4 Charger (or the i2, which I'd find preferable between the two), but this is one of the ones I did not want for the trashy looking O-Scope Charge pattern, among other things. It appears to charge a battery Over 4.2V by a bit, which is one of the things I absolutely did not want. It appears from the Charge patterns that if you leave a battery on the charger after a full charge, the charge is reduced to 4.2V, but it goes Over while charging. You can see this for yourself here...

Review of Charger SysMax/NiteCore i4 V2 ..So I bought the pila IBC.

However, now I am having Battery Longevity and Regulation issues. My batteries don't seem to last as long as they did when they were new. The pila and my 18650's were bought at the same time. I bought four Panasonic 18650 2250 mAh Hybrid IMR's, and have since purchased four AW 18350 700 mAh IMR's for a Vamo V3. My 18350 Batteries don't last as long as when they were new now either, and for both battery types, I also have to keep cranking up the VV or VW for the same Vape and Flavor. As an 18650 Battery discharges, I have to start cranking the VV or VW Up beginning near a 4.0V Battery Charge level. Regulation is supposed to work better than this, especially in a new Vamo.

Also, with a single 18650 in the Vamo V3, I cannot run a battery below a 3.8V charge, where I lose all Flavor. I taste it starting at 3.9V. I still get Vapor, but no Flavor, and adjusting the VV or VW Up does not compensate below a 3.8V Charge, so I have to replace the Battery with a Fully Charged one. That's Longevity on an 18650. With Stacked 18350's, the Batteries will drain down to 6.4V as expected, but I have to constantly adjust the VV or VW Up to maintain the Flavor of my Cinnamon Red Hots. I don't start losing Flavor altogether until about a 6.8V to 6.6V Charge level, so Stacked 18350's are much better, but I still have Regulation issues. The Longevity there isn't as bad, but the batteries are a lot newer, too.

I returned the Vamo V3 to the Vendor within the warranty period for troubleshooting. They said, and I quote, "...it is working as intended and the regulation issues are common or normal of this model and several others that we carry." The Vamo is supposed to be very good at Regulation, so I had trouble believing this from them. They said the Vamo V2 would do exactly the same as my V3. I've asked several Vamo V2 and V3 owners about this, and they all say they don't have this problem. Just so you know, the coils in my AGA-T2's are between 1.7Ω to 2.4Ω with 30g Kanthal on #500 SS Mesh, covered with XS-18 as an insulator under the coil (for no oxidation at all!). At these Ohms, I'm really not "pushing" the Vamo into Regulation problems. I have the same problem with other tanks like the Davide and a Vision Vivi Nova V-Fate.

This makes me think that maybe my Batteries have been damaged by my Charger. Keep in mind that these four 18650's were only purchased in late June of this year, so they aren't old and tired, and I had plenty for rotation. When I wrote the first question, I was using two other 18650's. My new Panasonics came from Orbtronic, and the pila and AW's came from ProVape in two separate orders (if I may say that here). I bought four 18350's for rotation in two sets. I mention where I purchased them in an effort to show that I tried to get the "Real" things. So maybe I got a bad pila, or maybe it's been damaged by electrical Power Fluctuations.

In reply to my original question, Rolygate said...

The truth is, there is no 'really good charger'. In fact there is a gap in the market for a top-quality device that has voltage readout and variable full-charge cutoff voltage. Someone will figure that out sooner or later.

So Roly, if you see this, I'd like to ask what brands of 18650 and 18350 Batteries You use, and which Charger you are using. I know you cannot make "recommendations" which appear to be "endorsements," but others are able to post what they are using, so I'm hoping you can help me, by PM if nothing else. I'm just looking for your advice - not an endorsement. Hopefully, saying "this is what I use" wouldn't be construed as such. I have seen you mention specific brands before, for some items.

In addition, to any of you using the i2 or the i4, I'd like to know if you've experienced any apparent Battery Damage like I suspect I have, or if you've experienced similar Regulation issues that appeared and worsened over time, which may be attributable to battery damage.

Sorry for the length here. I'm trying to be "detailed" as requested.

Thanks
 

tmcase

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 20, 2011
20,862
54,652
In addition, to any of you using the i2 or the i4, I'd like to know if you've experienced any apparent Battery Damage like I suspect I have, or if you've experienced similar Regulation issues that appeared and worsened over time, which may be attributable to battery damage.

Sorry for the length here. I'm trying to be "detailed" as requested.

Thanks

Hey again VG. :) I started out over 2 yrs ago with just the TR001. I used that for about 1 1/2 yrs and the i4 for around 6 months now. I also am using the same batteries I bought 2 yrs ago. Some have not been used for a while but all of my IMR batteries are at least a yr old and none of them show any charging loss or damage of any kind. They all still charge to 4.12 to 4.2v.
 

Katya

ECF Guru
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 23, 2010
34,804
120,147
SoCal
Hi again VG!

I don't have a lot of experience with chargers and batteries to draw any conclusions, other than to report that I have been using my Nitecore I2 (I never charge more than 2 batteries at a time) for over 6 months without any problems. I never leave my batteries on a charger unattended and I remove them from the charger as soon as they are fully charged. My Nitecore charges my (AW IMR) batteries to a little above 4v; I'd say 4.1-4.2v tops...
 

steved5600

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 7, 2012
2,693
1,197
Dallas, Texas
Still using the one that came with my Provari and another think the name is Trition or Triton not sure. FYI there is a way to test your batteries on how good a shape they are in.View attachment LIon battery tester v1.xlsxView attachment LIon battery tester v1.xlsx. The numbers are not good for all Li Ion's but are pretty good. The lower the internal resistance the better. Testing it when you buy it is best so you have a benchmark. My chargers are not very smart but when one dies I will replace it with one of the newer smarter one. Do not know much about that charger. Just seen it before is all. Never used it. OH contrary to what they still say Li Ion batteries do develop a memory. I suspected that all along but had no proof. No the cat is out of the bag. LOL
 
Last edited:

nj1001

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 14, 2009
902
340
Boston-ish
Still using the one that came with my Provari and another think the name is Trition or Triton not sure. FYI there is a way to test your batteries on how good a shape they are in.View attachment 256729View attachment 256729. The numbers are not good for all Li Ion's but are pretty good. The lower the internal resistance the better. Testing it when you buy it is best so you have a benchmark. My chargers are not very smart but when one dies I will replace it with one of the newer smarter one. Do not know much about that charger. Just seen it before is all. Never used it. OH contrary to what they still say Li Ion batteries do develop a memory. I suspected that all along but had no proof. No the cat is out of the bag. LOL

I personally would not recommend using Li-ion batts. Only high drain IMR which uses a safer LiMN chemistry and is optimum for use in vaping mechanical or electronic. I only use AW's but know there's a few other IMR brands that are also ideal for vaping.

Here's a little something I copied off of a battery site that carries AW IMR's. This example was for a 14500 battery so aside from the mAh & maybe cycle life everything should be applicable to 18350 & 18650s too:


These cells can handle high amperage and is safe to use in series / multi-cell applications. Can be charge with any LiIon battery charger with 4.2V output.

Specifications:


Nominal Voltage : 3.7V
Capacity : 600mAH
Lowest Discharge Voltage : 2.50V
Standard Charge : CC/CV ( max. charging rate 1.5A )
Cycle Life : > 500 cycles
Max. continuous discharge rate : 4A

Caution:
- Do not over-discharge/overcharge
- Recharge empty batteries ( resting voltage ~3.6V ) as soon as possible. Leaving LiIon batteries in discharged state will incur irreversible damage ( capacity / cycle loss )
- Do not short circuit ( will release tremendous current )
- Do not dispose of in fire.
Attention : These IMR cells have much lower internal resistance than regular LiIon 3.7V cells and they may end up with a higher ending voltage when charged in certain chargers ( especially older version WF-139 charger ). Please check the voltage of them right out of the charger to see if they are above 4.20V when fully charged with your charger. Overcharging above 4.25V may shorten life/cycles. Above 4.50V may even pop them or making them leak. DO NOT use the charger if it seems to overcharge IMR cells.
 
Last edited:

rolygate

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 24, 2009
8,354
12,405
ECF Towers
Most people get good results from an AW IMR 18650 (the Li-Mn type) and a Trustfire TR-1 charger. But this is assuming they are both from the real factory, not clones.

If you:
a. Pull the cell off the charger before it gets a full charge (which at the most should be 4.21v), so after 1 minute rest it is somewhere around 4.16 or 4.17v;
b. And if you pull it out of the APV before it gets below 3.4v,

...then in theory the cell will last longer. If you can be bothered.

Maybe your Vamo is faulty. Switch to another device and see, any VV unit will run the atties you describe - but it is common that power drops slightly as battery charge reduces, so you may have to run 5 volts at full charge and 5.5 volts at 3.5v batt voltage (or 11 watts and 13.5 watts), for example. The regulation is poor on some of these units.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread