Good menthol snuff with staying power

Status
Not open for further replies.

asidrave

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 21, 2009
1,358
151
New Jersey
im ready to place another snuff order. im looking at these that i havent tried:

Hedges L260
Poschl President
FUBAR Medic
WoS Extra Menthol
WoS Menthol Plus
WoS SM500

i have:

WoS Menthol
McChrystals Highland Ice
Sturco Menthol
Toque Menthol

the toque menthol hits good but fades fast. WoS menthol hits good and stays for a bit but less mentholy than toque.

what do you recommend? is there a better one that i did not list?



 

slybootz

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 18, 2009
750
8
37
Chicago
www.jimmyk.rocks
i typically use non-menthol snuffs all day, but i still have 15-20 menthol snuffs in my collection.

hedges is definitely a great menthol.
anything by poschl is menthol, you should enjoy the president and try the poschl redbull.
I really like the poschl ozona orange, but some people don't care for the ozona fruits.
I like the poschl gawith apricot, and also the cola.
poschl's packard's club is also a great snuff.
Rumney's Export is a good menthol.
Crumbs of Comfort Extra is a wonderful menthol wintergreen snuff(the regular CoC is non-menthol, the extra is menthol)
 

The Wiz

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Feb 14, 2009
10,408
3,854
63
Whiskeyville USA
im ready to place another snuff order. im looking at these that i havent tried:

Hedges L260
Poschl President
FUBAR Medic
WoS Extra Menthol
WoS Menthol Plus
WoS SM500

i have:

WoS Menthol
McChrystals Highland Ice
Sturco Menthol
Toque Menthol

the toque menthol hits good but fades fast. WoS menthol hits good and stays for a bit but less mentholy than toque.

what do you recommend? is there a better one that i did not list?
asidrave.....The Hedges is tops as far as pure menthol goes. I have all the WoS's you listed...and to be quite honest it's hard to tell the difference between them sometimes. The medic is good....but lacks menthol IMO. here's a few more you may wish to consider:

McCrystals Jip(Very simular to the Hedges...Cons: Small tin)
Gawith Hoggarth Camphor Menthol(The camphor is predominant here)
Poschl Redbull(Most Poschls have the same menthol base...this one just seems to kick a bit more!
J.H Wilsons Medicated 99(This one is an enigma with me...Hits the nose hard but fades quick...very inexpensive for a small 5g tin box...I would try it and see for yourself!
Dean Swift Dr. Johnson(Just got this a week or so back and it is growing on me...try the 5g tin)

Unfortunatly none of my menthols are as long lasting as lets say Molens or a Sun snuff.... Again...Hedges would be King of all menthols IMO!

Good Luck!
:)The Wiz!
 

The Wiz

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Feb 14, 2009
10,408
3,854
63
Whiskeyville USA
For me, at least, the FUBAR Medic is pretty potent in the nic. The menthol isn't weak either.
Wow Firechick....I thought the Medic menthol was a tad weak(Might be due to overexposure from Hedges..LOL)I actually took some Toque menthol and mixed it with my Medic to boost the menthol...made a difference for me! I do enjoy my FUBARS!

:)The Wiz!
 

sunset

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 17, 2009
508
0
Did anyone say Magnet Menthol - wow, I just did some and it'll last me a little bit, maybe not as long as Hedges?.:D

Yesterday I was low on energy and did all this searching for Strong Snuff - this is one that came up and so did Red Bull (can't believe I have it and haven't tried it yet - will today)

Anyway, someone did some research and I hope it's OK to quote them, but it's interesting on the Magnet Menthol : In the product description it even has a warning: The Magnet Medicated Menthol Snuff comes from Leonard Dingler, South Africa, and is a very strong and powerful Menthol Snuff. "

You have to love snuffreviews.com - reviews on this are all over the place, but I do like it and think it's strong: SnuffReviews.com [BETA]
 

firechick

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 24, 2009
1,930
1,944
Upstate New York
Wow Firechick....I thought the Medic menthol was a tad weak(Might be due to overexposure from Hedges..LOL)I actually took some Toque menthol and mixed it with my Medic to boost the menthol...made a difference for me! I do enjoy my FUBARS!

:)The Wiz!

You definitely are THE menthol man. I find the FUBAR clears the old sinuses just fine!! But then again, I'm a little girlie. lol
 

dgriego

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 8, 2009
1,112
1
New Mexico
Did anyone say Magnet Menthol - wow, I just did some and it'll last me a little bit, maybe not as long as Hedges?.:D

Yesterday I was low on energy and did all this searching for Strong Snuff - this is one that came up and so did Red Bull (can't believe I have it and haven't tried it yet - will today)

Anyway, someone did some research and I hope it's OK to quote them, but it's interesting on the Magnet Menthol : In the product description it even has a warning: The Magnet Medicated Menthol Snuff comes from Leonard Dingler, South Africa, and is a very strong and powerful Menthol Snuff. "

You have to love snuffreviews.com - reviews on this are all over the place, but I do like it and think it's strong: SnuffReviews.com [BETA]

Magnet is a high nicotine snuff, I have not tried it but I have tried the NTSU which is another South African. They tend to be pretty stinky, but powerful. Since the NTSU was way too much for me and Wiz threw away his Magnet I have decided that for now, the South Africans are not for me.
 

sunset

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 17, 2009
508
0
Magnet is a high nicotine snuff, I have not tried it but I have tried the NTSU which is another South African. They tend to be pretty stinky, but powerful. Since the NTSU was way too much for me and Wiz threw away his Magnet I have decided that for now, the South Africans are not for me.

DG, I've got to laugh. For the 2nd time I really got into my NTSU yesterday, I was looking for some high energy snuff. I didn't have that bad of a time with it or so I thought, but the ammonia literally 'burnt' my nose outside, can you imagine- it turned red where I missed and top of my lip and here I thought I had gotten it off.:D

I gave it another shot today, since it cleared up and I still haven't given up on it 'yet'...just letting it air out and next time I might try mixing it with something.8-o I do remember your experience with it - it's a strange one for sure.

The Magnet - I do like it as is. I didn't know Wiz threw his away.:shock:
 

dgriego

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 8, 2009
1,112
1
New Mexico
DG, I've got to laugh. For the 2nd time I really got into my NTSU yesterday, I was looking for some high energy snuff. I didn't have that bad of a time with it or so I thought, but the ammonia literally 'burnt' my nose outside, can you imagine- it turned red where I missed and top of my lip and here I thought I had gotten it off.:D

I gave it another shot today, since it cleared up and I still haven't given up on it 'yet'...just letting it air out and next time I might try mixing it with something.8-o I do remember your experience with it - it's a strange one for sure.

The Magnet - I do like it as is. I didn't know Wiz threw his away.:shock:

You should try doing a "gob" of NTSU

Someone on the snuff board told me how to do gobs. You take the NTSU in your fingers and you stuff it up your nose, two or three pinches in each nostril, after each stuff you pinch your nose for a second. You then sit back and relax.

I did this and got a pretty hard nicotine rush, too much for me LOL.

I have not tried the Magnet, maybe I will pick up a tin on my next order just to check it out. I do like the Hedges but I really do not use menthol snuffs that often.
 

sunset

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 17, 2009
508
0
Sunset I swear I knocked something loose...The breathing easy and menthol stuck around a good bit. Honestly it hurt for a good long bit, 100% sure I popped free, musta been a blood vessal I didnt need.

Oh my, you are serious! Here I thought you did what I accidentally overdid with Dholakia White one time. Only my experience didn't help me or my eye pain it caused.

I do hope you're doing better, Dredbull.
 
Last edited:

The Wiz

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Feb 14, 2009
10,408
3,854
63
Whiskeyville USA
Sunset I swear I knocked something loose...The breathing easy and menthol stuck around a good bit. Honestly it hurt for a good long bit, 100% sure I popped free, musta been a blood vessal I didnt need.
Dred....Sounds like a sinus to me Pal! Watch those menthol inhales!!

:)The Wiz!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread