Good tasting Menthol E-Liquid with a good Throat Hit

Status
Not open for further replies.

ardelleg

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 3, 2011
574
274
Alaska
This is a great thread. Hope to get more ideas. Especially about the menthol crystals. Are they all alike from the various stores a. The shards you know. And about adding some to a 3 ml vape for and aver hit of menthol. I would want to powderize it and sprinkle some in so as not to dilute flavor or nic. So about how much powder would I start with for medium menthol give or take and then I can adjust to taste. I usually like things strong but of course depends. Thanks every body for asking this q and all the great answers. Also who has the best liquid ice in your opinions


I crushed them and mixed the powder into some Everclear. You can also mix it into some VG or PG.....

I am currently cycling through Halo's 3 menthols and BWB Menthol.... can't seem to settle down to just one.......

I tried the Arctic Wolf.... it will definitely give you the TH..... it was a bit much for me, I wound up mixing it with the others.......

Good luck with your quest.....
 

orangepeeljones

Full Member
Jan 15, 2013
40
29
Florida, US
So many different responses to the menthol question!
That's exactly why I had been holding off on buying any menthol juice...there are just too many options! The first one I tried which was supposed to be like Newport didn't do it for me at all...

So today I was driving home and spotted yet another vape store in my area, and stopped in...and they had a ton of menthol flavors!
I tried a bunch until I found one I dig: Ultimate Vapor Tobacco Menthol. At 18mg it gives a nice TH, it's nice and chilly with just a hint of tobacco flavor. I like it a lot. In fact, I'm vaping it right now.

If you have access to a local vape shop, that's your best bet. Try a bunch of menthol juices until you find one that tastes just right.
It would sure save you a lot of disappointment spending cash on a ton of juice that you don't like!
Then again, you could get lucky and like the first one you try...

Just a thought! I have yet to order any juice online, just because I've been fortunate enough to have three vape shops in my area to visit and sample flavors from.

Good luck with your search! :)

OPJ
 
Thank you so much for posting about the P-38 Juice. Because of your suggestion, I ordered a bottle of it immediately after reading this page. And needless to say, I was not disappointed. The P-38 is by far the best E-liquid that I have tried so far. And I have tried quite a few. It is not only better than any other juice, it is on a whole different level. No other juice that I've tried comes anywhere close to it. I have had other juices that taste really good, but the P-38 is just something special. There is just something about it that sets it apart from the others. It has that crisp clean taste that is unbelievable. Yeah it is a little expensive. And it sucks that you can only order one size bottle. But it is definitely worth it. I'm not exactly sure what the WTA is, but whatever it is, it really makes a difference. As soon as I opened that bottle and tried it for the first time, I immediately got back on the website and ordered 3 more bottles of it. Before getting the P-38, I tried 2 different flavors from Heathers Heavenly Vapes. One was Menthol Ice and the other was Blade Runner. I didn't like the Blade Runner at all. And the Menthol Ice was really disappointing to me. Maybe I ordered it the wrong way or something, because it didn't taste like menthol ice at all to me. From the way I heard other people describe it, I had my expectations pretty high when I first tried it. I was expecting to feel the ice in my throat when I hit it. And it just didn't happen. The P-38 has more of an ice taste than the Menthol Ice had. Sorry to keep rambling. To make a long story long, I am a die hard P-38 fan from now on. Thanks again for the suggestion.
P-38 Menthol from Aroma Ejuice is the one I settled on... Awesome! I ordered three more bottles...
 

BradleyNIN

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
I just ordered a bottle of Arctic Wolf based on recommendations from the thread. Sounds like great stuff. Lots of folks on here posting about it.

Subzero by Halo has got to be the coldest I've tried so far. I can add it to generic menthol juice to kick it up a notch. Its almost too much by itself.
 

seebo

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 31, 2013
221
202
CT,USA
after hearing some rave about the p-38 menthol i ordered a bottle to try. coming from menthol analogs (newport) i find the p-38 a bit too much menthol, throat hit is a little on the light side, some vape smoke but kinda thin. not sure if i'll buy it again yet, got some halo coolmist and menthol ice on the way but i'm more than guessing menthol will be a bit too much with those as well.

what can i do to tone down the menthol a bit? can i add some plain VG or something to the P-38 to make it less like a inhaling a tic tac? it would be perfect with a tad less menthol and more vape. bottle shows Pg/Vg 70/30.
 
Last edited:

TraceyS

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 17, 2012
2,442
7,226
Blacksburg, Virginia
after hearing some rave about the p-38 menthol i ordered a bottle to try. coming from menthol analogs (newport) i find the p-38 a bit too much menthol, throat hit is a little on the light side, some vape smoke but kinda thin. not sure if i'll buy it again yet, got some halo coolmist and menthol ice on the way but i'm more than guessing menthol will be a bit too much with those as well.

what can i do to tone down the menthol a bit? can i add some plain VG or something to the P-38 to make it less like a inhaling a tic tac? it would be perfect with a tad less menthol and more vape. bottle shows Pg/Vg 70/30.

Not sure if you've tried the Mr. Eliquid menthol or their Ice Line. You can choose your menthol levels...light, full etc. I am a full flavor menthol gal, smoked VA Slims Menthol full flavor for 35+ years. I trust no one else with my menthol! :)

Tracey
 

vicflo

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 25, 2009
334
255
Virginia
Hawk Sauce from mtbakervapor with at least 2 extra shots of flavor. 50/50 or higher pg if you are looking for throat hit unless you run your atomizers hot.

+1 for manually adding menthol crystals to an existing flavor you like.

i was a menthol smoker for ~15y. marlboro/camel menthol. most all of the other menthol flavors such as anything ICE taste like a marlboro smooth to me... which was never my cup of tea.
 

Nugget40

Senior Member
Verified Member
Apr 27, 2014
97
408
MA-NH
+1 on the Smokeless Image Ice Menthol.....I read many good things about this menthol blend being the best that many people have tried. It was my first ejuice after smoking Newports for about 16 years....I smoked about 1 1/2 packs a day....I just got all my equipment and juices the other day, and have been vaping on mostly the Ice Menthol since. I have only smoked about a pack of analogs over the past 3 days and they are tasting worse and worse as time goes on. I can see myself analog free very soon, maybe even this week. And I can thank the Ice Menthol for that. So any former menthol smokers, I can highly recommend this juice. Has a doublemint gum flavor going on, with a bit of a tobacco undertone, and just a touch of sweetness.
 
I'm a menthol smoker and I am looking for a good menthol liquid that satisfies in the TH department anyone have a good suggestion as to which to get? I smoke Marlboro menthol now and I am not looking to match the experience exactly I just want something comparable.

Anyone have any suggestions as to what to try?

Hello Fellow vapor;

I to was a menthol smoker for 45 year and when I started vaping I needed a luquid that would satisfy my craving but without the taste for tobacco. So at my local smoke shop here in beaumont, CA I found It, and it is great. It worked for me and I quit smoking in 1 day, not to say you will that quick but all you can do is try it and see if it will work for you. I have tried all kinds, and most of them were either weak or just didn't have the kick that this brand had. As fas as I know he is the only one that sells it. I can't find it anywhere on internet. But the name of it is "intense menthol" I use thee 11mg of nic, it works good for me, not to much sting and a good throat hit. Here is his number, call him and he ship's. 951-845-1709 he's open Monday thru Sat. check it I hope this works for you. Also check out my youtube channel called Vapor Vet and subscribe. It is a novice attemped fo help fellow vapor's out there to learn more in layman's terms. Take Care Happy Vaping

Tedd
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread