In my opinion, the ashtrays on Ash Wednesday action went as good as it could have been. Fact is that at least 400 vapers (according to forums trace of senders), who had been living in
vaping-la-la-land until the very last weeks, found together and committed to set a very powerful sign. Some media reports had been triggered in preparation. Media attention on that day, however, had been utmost slim (despite active attempts by brave individuals to get the media interested). One reason might have been that Ash Wednesday is one of the most political days in Germany. At this day, the end of carnival, all political parties do convene to push their lines and bash competitors - thus creating quite a lot to report in the national politics sections. Anyway, the addressed minister Steffens carefully opted to dive (her speaker announced she is on holidays and would not comment), perhaps most telling about how our representatives care about concerns of their constituents. However, a ministry and state government is just another village. I have no question that this campaign created inside talk, and we always have the political opposition, so this ashtray campaign will follow her for quite a while.
Meanwhile, two larger e-cig suppliers had been raided by authorities - seizing about 45 000 liquid bottles - according to German news reports (
Bild). Reasoning of the prosecutors: liquid containing nicotine would have to be classified as a medicine by function, therefore illegal. One store in NRW is back and running the full program (I dont know who was the other). The best connected German e-cig information site (
smok-e.de) had announced that legal steps were taken by these suppliers, and sounded all optimistic about the possible legal outcome. Keeping fingers crossed.
A black wednesday: yesterday, all our national media (e.g.
here) reported that the federal government considers e-cigs in terms of a medical product (de-facto-prohibition), in an answer to a parliamentary question (answer not yet published). This is not a law and the federal government has no actual authority for prohibition, which still rests at the states (Länder). However, this certainly sets the stage where things are probably heading to. German suppliers outside the previously critical state (Land) of North Rhine-Westphalia are now open to prosecution. Since politics denied to act here, the future of e-cigs has been moving much closer to be decided in higher legal courts. That's just my understanding,