Indiana HB 1432 signed into law and takes effect July 1st, 2015

Status
Not open for further replies.

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
I'm just curious as to how Indiana can force someone from another state to comply with Indiana regulations about shop requirements? I know New Hampshire won a federal lawsuit against Massachusetts when Ma. tried to get NH. retailers to follow Ma. regulations when doing business with Ma residents. Something about federal interstate commerce laws. As long as it was legal in Ma, NH has the right to sell to Ma. customers.

So, how does Indiana stop people from buying e-liquid from another state? Indiana doesn't control the post office, the federal government does. Is Indiana really going to examine every package in the post office to see if it contains juice. All out of state vendors would have to do is not label their packages as vape related then the state would need a warrant or have to show probable cause.
technically they are not regulating per say.
they are requiring licensing and there are requirements attached
to the licensing provisions. its not an outright ban. the same
thing was done to handle tobacco sales. many states require
licensing for many things. out of state contractors for instance.
you meet the requirements and your good to go.not many out of
state vendors can afford it. its not the cost of the license,its
the cost of the requirements to comply with the license.
its very easy to stop internet sales. every package shipped
by UPS,Fedex and, the USPS has the company's 9 digit zip
code on it. those last 4 digits in fact identify the the actual
location the parcel was shipped from.
i am sure there is a list of locations cross referenced to
whom is doing business from that location. the Patriot
Act and all that.
regards
mike
 

motordude

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 1, 2015
1,386
6,264
59
VA, USA
One more reason I'm glad I'm a Texan. Our governor refused to sign a texting/driving ban a lil while back saying the government was already too intrusive in our lives and he didn't want to add to the bureaucracy any further.
OMG!!! It's the end of the world!!!! A sensible act from a politician.:danger::danger::danger:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hans Wermhat

Hans Wermhat

Vaping Master
Jun 9, 2015
3,426
3,413
Texas
As unlikely as it seems, there a a few of them here in Lone Star Land that do that once in a while. That's why so many businesses are moving here. Just this year ere in Dallas we got State Farm, Toyota, & Liberty Mutual's corporate hq's. The company I work for is doing the electrical work for all of them. When big companies like that spend 100's of millions of $'s to relocate, there's always a political reason. (i.e. taxes, regulations, etc.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: motordude

KattMamma

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 10, 2015
1,733
6,442
DFW Area, Texas
Well the governor DID sign a vape bill that pretty much treats vape products like cigarettes. I don't think enough of us hounded them to get them to reconsider, although this bill was a bit easier to swallow than some of the draconian ones being passed in other states (Indiana - wow!)

This bill in TX mostly focused on age requirements and won't have much effect on B&Ms. It remains to be seen how it will affect mail order, which is how I buy most of my stuff. The worst of it that I know about (the bill is kinda hard to understand) is that it requires age verification when you order, and an adult must sign for the delivery. This means that deliveries while I am at work (ALL of my deliveries, unless I'm home sick!) will stop. I will have to go to the post office to pick up my deliveries. That blows... :(

That said, one of the best things I can say about Texas is -- no income tax!!
 

pennysmalls

Squonkmeister
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 26, 2013
3,138
8,472
53
Indiana
So it looks like the online ordering deadline will be this July 2015 but will not be enforced until July 2016. I saw this in the bill but wasn't sure I was reading it correctly, chapter 5 section 1(c). Hoosier verified in an update he posted this morning in the Hoosier Vapers sub forum along with some info on the coming lawsuit. So now we get to see if vendors will go ahead and sell to us for the next year because this is all probably confusing for them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KattMamma

Tmg666

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 5, 2014
397
296
Green bay, Wisconsin
May just be me but that law seems justified.

1. It targets the manufacturing/bottling of eliquids for sale and will result in non unauthorized chemicals (no diacetyl and the like i presume).
2. Doesn't target DIY unless you are selling the liquid for profit.
3. Any distribution of any products has rules and health codes to follow, i see no reason we should be special in this area.

If they had it to where you couldn't buy any flavors besides menthol or tobacco then that would be an issue.

I guess the only thing i dislike about the bill is it lumps eliquid together be it 0mg nicotine or 36mg nicotine by requiring the permit go through the Alcohol and tobacco commission.
 

KattMamma

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 10, 2015
1,733
6,442
DFW Area, Texas
May just be me but that law seems justified.

1. It targets the manufacturing/bottling of eliquids for sale and will result in non unauthorized chemicals (no diacetyl and the like i presume).
2. Doesn't target DIY unless you are selling the liquid for profit.
3. Any distribution of any products has rules and health codes to follow, i see no reason we should be special in this area.

If they had it to where you couldn't buy any flavors besides menthol or tobacco then that would be an issue.

I guess the only thing i dislike about the bill is it lumps eliquid together be it 0mg nicotine or 36mg nicotine by requiring the permit go through the Alcohol and tobacco commission.
Uh, no... unless I missed some major modifications just before this was passed...

It requires VERY expensive video monitoring... certifications... storage of samples (also under video monitoring)... inspections... the list of requirements was shocking - no other industry that I know of is subject to such scrutiny, unless maybe they're making bombs for the military or something...???
 

Tmg666

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 5, 2014
397
296
Green bay, Wisconsin
Uh, no... unless I missed some major modifications just before this was passed...

It requires VERY expensive video monitoring... certifications... storage of samples (also under video monitoring)... inspections... the list of requirements was shocking - no other industry that I know of is subject to such scrutiny, unless maybe they're making bombs for the military or something...???
Where is the other list then? Going off the link posted by op on first page and it had none of those on the page.
edit: nevermind ops pic looked similar to the one who posted link to the bill.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KattMamma

BostonJim

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 6, 2013
326
403
Las Vegas
technically they are not regulating per say.
they are requiring licensing and there are requirements attached
to the licensing provisions. its not an outright ban. the same
thing was done to handle tobacco sales. many states require
licensing for many things. out of state contractors for instance.
you meet the requirements and your good to go.not many out of
state vendors can afford it. its not the cost of the license,its
the cost of the requirements to comply with the license.
its very easy to stop internet sales. every package shipped
by UPS,Fedex and, the USPS has the company's 9 digit zip
code on it. those last 4 digits in fact identify the the actual
location the parcel was shipped from.
i am sure there is a list of locations cross referenced to
whom is doing business from that location. the Patriot
Act and all that.
regards
mike

Still, I don't think Indiana can force a Nevada business to get a license to mail order legal products into Indiana, it violates the interstate commerce law I would think. (i'm not a lawyer, I don't know for sure) What about a mail dump like mailboxes ect. where they do mass mailings? I can think of many ways around this out of state vape mail crap. What I do know from the Ma. thing is that Indiana cannot stop you from driving out of state to purchase any item that is not Illegal in the buyers home state.

Yes Indiana can do what they want to instate vape shops, but can do nothing about vape shops in other states. I know it could be a long drive to an out of state supplier, but its still legal. I know this because Ma gets mad when we drive to NH to save money on sales tax
 

Robert Cromwell

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Feb 16, 2015
14,009
65,472
elsewhere
Have you read the P.A.T.R.I.O.T. Act?

It should have been named patently unconstitutional.

Every section, sub - section and article is purposely vague once you consider the sheer magnitude and that every sentence has to be reconstructed to include what it's referencing.

G.W.s crowning achievement... The "camera on your corner" act.

Tapatyped
Yep any law with a good sounding name means to bend over and get the vaseline.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread