Is the E-Cig gettting stomped by "big tobbacco"

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sophey

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 19, 2011
183
103
Seattle, WA
Ask and ye shall receive...
The New Corporate America Business Model

It's Big Pharma, who funds groups like ALA, AHA, ACS, CTFK, ALF, and all the rest.

Aha! Thank you for the link. I knew there had to be a pot of gold at the end of that rainbow.

This discussion is extremely thought-provoking. Everyone has such good comments. I'm just so glad to have found this forum. Great thread.
 
I think that the cigarette industry does not like ecigs but there probably isn't much they can do to "stomp" it. They may push for legislation to have ecigs taxed and regulated like tobacco products and they may even succeed in some states/provinces/countries, which sucks. But ecigs are an entrepreneurial industry and can't really be shut down. And the cigarette industry is an oligopoly.

I do think that the objection by health ministries and the WHO to ecigs is mostly due to inertia.
 

wv2win

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Feb 10, 2009
11,879
9,045
GA by way of WV
The bottom line is powerful interests stand to lose billions if people really do get healthy. Personally, I don't think this is just a weird conspiracy theory.

What I don't understand is why anti-smoking groups aren't on board with e-cigs. What do they gain by supporting NRTs while pushing propoganda that e-cigs aren't safe? I get the whole "follow the money" idea, but I just don't see where the money leads back to with this one. Anyone?

95% of the operating funds for the anti-smoking groups, such as ASH, comes from the large pharmaceutical companies. One of our members who has been involved in the anti-smoking movement for years, explained that the larger pharmaceutical companies put the word out to these groups that if they didn't come out strong against vaping, their funding would be in jeopardy. Plus, some of the more radical groups, such as ASH, has pointidly stated that if it looks anything like smoking, they will fight against it, period. ASH was the group that got Paypal not to allow any business associated with vaping to use their site for the processing of payments.
 

wv2win

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Feb 10, 2009
11,879
9,045
GA by way of WV
I think that the cigarette industry does not like ecigs but there probably isn't much they can do to "stomp" it. They may push for legislation to have ecigs taxed and regulated like tobacco products and they may even succeed in some states/provinces/countries, which sucks. But ecigs are an entrepreneurial industry and can't really be shut down. And the cigarette industry is an oligopoly.

I do think that the objection by health ministries and the WHO to ecigs is mostly due to inertia.

Big tobacco is NOT THE PROBLEM. Big Pharm is the problem.
 

madison360

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 19, 2011
104
31
62
Emerald Isle, NC
95% of the operating funds for the anti-smoking groups, such as ASH, comes from the large pharmaceutical companies. One of our members who has been involved in the anti-smoking movement for years, explained that the larger pharmaceutical companies put the word out to these groups that if they didn't come out strong against vaping, their funding would be in jeopardy. Plus, some of the more radical groups, such as ASH, has pointidly stated that if it looks anything like smoking, they will fight against it, period. ASH was the group that got Paypal not to allow any business associated with vaping to use their site for the processing of payments.

Wow...wv2win, I had no idea.... Kinda scary.
 

bobsyeruncle

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
  • Sep 5, 2010
    11,120
    74,446
    56
    in a cave, eh?
    Big tobacco is NOT THE PROBLEM. Big Pharm is the problem.

    I dunno. Big Pharm might be the bigger problem, but I'm not so sure Big Tobacco isn't somehow involved. And a nanny government on top of that really doesn't help. In Canada's case, a bureaucratic, lazy and possibly corrupt Health Canada isn't really helping.
     

    wv2win

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Feb 10, 2009
    11,879
    9,045
    GA by way of WV
    I dunno. Big Pharm might be the bigger problem, but I'm not so sure Big Tobacco isn't somehow involved. And a nanny government on top of that really doesn't help. In Canada's case, a bureaucratic, lazy and possibly corrupt Health Canada isn't really helping.

    There is no evidence that big tobacco cares about vaping. There is an abundance of evidence that big pharm is very anti-vaping.
     
    Big tobacco is NOT THE PROBLEM. Big Pharm is the problem.

    Quite possibly. But I don't feel a need to posit a conspiracy unless there is some evidence or at least a clear incentive combined with capability (the means-motive-opportunity thing) and a hypothetical MO.

    It could very well be that the pharma lobby is targeting ecigs to bury the industry. But I don't know that and would have to look into it to have a firm opinion either way about it. I think it best to be at least as skeptical of conspiracy theories as I am of the conventional wisdom. For anything.
     

    wv2win

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Feb 10, 2009
    11,879
    9,045
    GA by way of WV
    Quite possibly. But I don't feel a need to posit a conspiracy unless there is some evidence or at least a clear incentive combined with capability (the means-motive-opportunity thing) and a hypothetical MO.

    It could very well be that the pharma lobby is targeting ecigs to bury the industry. But I don't know that and would have to look into it to have a firm opinion either way about it. I think it best to be at least as skeptical of conspiracy theories as I am of the conventional wisdom. For anything.

    That is exactly what I have done. The facts are clear that Big Pharm is 100% against vaping. Check out CASAA or Smoke Free Pennsylvania. As I stated previously, there are people that have been in the anti-smoking groups for years that has confirmed Big Pharms' direct action to have vaping banned. He has seen the letters to both the FDA and to the ALA and AHA.
     

    DC2

    Tootie Puffer
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Jun 21, 2009
    24,161
    40,974
    San Diego
    Quite possibly. But I don't feel a need to posit a conspiracy unless there is some evidence or at least a clear incentive combined with capability (the means-motive-opportunity thing) and a hypothetical MO.
    Yeah, I didn't believe in conspiracy theories either before I started using electronic cigarettes.

    Now that I've learned what is really going on out there my view of the world has changed quite a bit.
    I liked it a lot better when I didn't know any better.

    Following the money leads straight from Big Pharma to all of the "health" and "anti-smoking" organizations.
    This is well-documented and quite easy to learn about with a bit of research.

    The following link is a very nice summary of what you'll find out...
    The New Corporate America Business Model

    And the "health" and "anti-smoking" organizations work from the same playbook...
    SMOKEFREE OUTDOOR PUBLIC SPACES: A COMMUNITY ADVOCACY TOOLKIT
    Tobacco Control Strategy Planning - Other Resources

    They call it advocacy but I call it conspiracy.
     
    Last edited:

    wv2win

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Feb 10, 2009
    11,879
    9,045
    GA by way of WV
    Yeah, I didn't believe in conspiracy theories either before I started using electronic cigarettes.

    Now that I've learned what is really going on out there my view of the world has changed quite a bit.
    I liked it a lot better when I didn't know any better.

    Following the money leads straight from Big Pharma to all of the "health" and "anti-smoking" organizations.
    This is well-documented and quite easy to learn about with a bit of research.

    The following link is a very nice summary of what you'll find out...
    The New Corporate America Business Model

    And the "health" and "anti-smoking" organizations work from the same playbook...
    SMOKEFREE OUTDOOR PUBLIC SPACES: A COMMUNITY ADVOCACY TOOLKIT
    Tobacco Control Strategy Planning - Other Resources

    They call it advocacy but I call it conspiracy.

    Well, DC, here we are again on the same "side". Maybe we are part of the "conspiracy".:)
     

    gazob

    Full Member
    Jul 28, 2011
    18
    2
    60
    Melbourne Australia
    Its easy to blame "the man" for all the worlds woes, "the man" tends not to care how we kill ourselves and rather than fight e-cigarettes is more likely to embrace them as another consumer item to sell to the sheep, few regulations and taxes, plenty of potential for exploitation, Im surprised "the man" isnt being blamed for pushing them.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Users who are viewing this thread