@twgbonehead:
Germany cannot decide not to implement an EU regulation. Just as Kasakhstan had to implement any regulation coming from Moscow.
And it is completely irrelevant whether a country is the biggest net payer in that EUSSR or the poorest, smallest member.
As to modifiying: Oh yes, every member state is free to make the regulations even stricter, when they implement them. They can make the e-cigs medicines if they so desire. - Germany cannot make them medicines, unless they are advertised as such. He he. See below.
(Get this: If Germany's trade surplus exceeds the limit set by Moscow.. uhm.. Brussels, then Germany will be fined by the EU. Member states get punished for having a healthy economy. It is like punishing a good soccer team for being better than other teams, during the current soccer world cup. And no, I am not making this up.)
However, the courts in Germany do their job very well. Especially the higher courts. This is our hope.
(The courts in Germany have decided - several times already - that e-cigs are not medicines. In spite of arbitrary decisions taken by some overzealous politicians. The courts in my country work by evidence. Hard evidence. Not ideology, lies and blathering. Thankfully.)
For example, that passage in the TPD that "any contribution to any cross-border activity that promotes e-cigarettes" (such as forums, youtube, blogs, vape meets, vape fairs etc) is strictly forbidden - for private citizens, no less - goes counter to the Constitution of Germany. It goes counter to the freedom of expression and the freedom of assembly. Those rights are laid down in our Constitution. Those rights are sacred and not subject to discussion or abolition. Especially not by a product (!) directive laid down in Brussels.
About "cross-border": There is freedom of movement within the EU. So that guy sitting at the table next to you may be from across the border. I tell an Austrian that I love my Evod - and I go to jail? We'll see about that.
About "contribution": politicians have tried to say that this means only financial contributions.
1. politicians will say anything
2. politicians lie all the time
3. Not one vaper in Europe trusts those people
4. Even if it means "financial contribution" - hey, I am a supporting member in ECF - which is based in the UK - - > cross-border financial contribution. -- So they are going to drag me off to jail? For paying a small amount of money to an international vaping forum? A place where a legal activity is discussed? We'll see about that.
All it needs is one court case. Just one court case. And we can blow this entire crap wide open. An EU product (!) directive that goes directly counter to the Constitution of Germany. Which seeks to invalidate the constitutional rights of citizens of a sovereign country.
Yes. All it needs is one court case.
And until we get that, we do what we can.
Oh, and if you have any kind of doubt about the kinds of "product directives" enacted by the EUSSR Central Committee.. uhm.. the European Commision, if you have any kind of doubt about their motives, take a look at this, please
EU drops olive oil jug ban after public outcry - Telegraph
/edit: And anyone who has time is welcome to look at the comments underneath that article. Those are the voices of the citizens of that EUSSR. They say exactly what the citizens think of the EU. And yes, I think the same. Naturally.