Korea Ecig Test

[CoffinLess]

Sorry everyone - it was a great ecig test but do not know how to put it on here for all to read

 

[slojas]

대한민국전자담배협회에서 전자담배 기체테스트를 진행하고 있습니다.

기체 테스트: 액상이 아닌 액상이 기화된(연기화 된) 상태의 성분을 검사하여, 인체에 직접
흡입되는 성분을 검사하는 시험

검사 방법: 연초(일반담배) 1개피 평균 흡입량 약 8회를 1개피로 가정하여, 전자담배 8회
16회, 24회사용 했을 때와 연초 8회 사용했을 때의 성분을 비교


An Error Occurred

Sorry, an error occurred. If you are unsure on how to use a feature, or don't know why you got this error message, try looking through the help files for more information.

[#10171] You do not have permission to view this attachment.



Gonna have to request the cliff notes on this one because, as you can see, I can only view what seems gibberish and an error message.

 

[Vanisle]

You need to be a member of vapor talk in order to view it. I got the same error.

 

[CoffinLess]

How do I delete this if no one can read it?

 

[Vanisle]

If you can save it then upload it to photobucket or some place like that then post it here it should be good for all to see.

 

[slojas]

imgPlace.com - Image Hosting - Free Image Hosting - Free Image Uploading
free temporary image host, very easy to use.

 

[Kencalise]

What is this test for??

 

[Sicarius]

Puff Test Comparison - Analogue vs Ecig

 

[Toronto_Mike]

Results sheet - Vapor Test Results by Korea Electronic Cigarette Association

 

[vise]

That's insane! The three things in e-cigs I can say with ease, as opposed to analogs which I need a translator to even pronounce!

 

[northhar]

Interesting test.
I am sure from reading these results that the percentages given are not what was drawn from the cigarette or the e-cig. Those percentages are the contents of each only.

Still an interesting test...

 

[shockabsorber]

Don't get me wrong, I'm all for proving that e-cigarettes are healthier than their analog counterparts (the way I feel now is proof enough for me though). I'm just not jumping up and down at the release of this report. The first and primary reason is that all searches that I do of this report lead me back to a e-cig manufacturer's website in Korea, not a government website or something more credible. The second reason is that it has not been properly translated. This is clear if you look at the notes for item #21 : causes blood. I do hope that this is an authentic test, and that the results will help our cause in the long run. I am skeptical to start yelling "Victory!" from the hilltops though, as I don't want it to turn out to be just some pro-vaping propaganda. That would just make us all look very amateurish.
If someone has more info pertaining to the report though, I would love to see it.

 

[DevilFishPhil]

Repost:

http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/canada-forum/277720-korea-ecig-test.html#post5554490

 

[shockabsorber]

Thanks Phil, I have seen that page as well though. What I would like to see is a detailed description of the entire process; methodology, margin of error, specific material used and so forth.

 

[Toronto_Mike]

There's a translation of it on the Janty website:

Vapor Test Results by Korea Electronic Cigarette Association

Hey Phil - did you not see my 1st post on this thread #9? You're stealing my thunder

 

[DevilFishPhil]

Hahah sorry Mike I hadn't noticed - your thunder has been restored sir

 

[Kams Cats]

I think I have seen very similar results from other studies. Nice to see them confirmed.