Well... Have you considered trying a cigarette tobacco liquid that has been extracted from the real thing?
If so, there's Naturally-Extracted-tobacco.com that is a reputable vendor who's owner started out here on ECF as a regular guy who wasn't satisfied with what was available at the time. Clay then began extracting his own tobacco flavors and was a hit on the Natural Tobacco thread.
Cigarette-style e-Liquids
It's pretty hard to replicate the taste of a lit cigarette, but if you like the way a fresh pack of cigs smell when you open them, that's what the extracted tobacco's taste like, and are really good! I love the NS Dark, which is a Nat Sherman Dark cig extraction... Great stuff!
The Speaking Spirit is another that is exceptional! I have a bottle of Speaking Spirit still aging but is smells great!
You should get yourself a sampler and give it a try, you just might have that "Ah-HA!" moment!
If so, there's Naturally-Extracted-tobacco.com that is a reputable vendor who's owner started out here on ECF as a regular guy who wasn't satisfied with what was available at the time. Clay then began extracting his own tobacco flavors and was a hit on the Natural Tobacco thread.
Cigarette-style e-Liquids
It's pretty hard to replicate the taste of a lit cigarette, but if you like the way a fresh pack of cigs smell when you open them, that's what the extracted tobacco's taste like, and are really good! I love the NS Dark, which is a Nat Sherman Dark cig extraction... Great stuff!
The Speaking Spirit is another that is exceptional! I have a bottle of Speaking Spirit still aging but is smells great!
You should get yourself a sampler and give it a try, you just might have that "Ah-HA!" moment!