Backwoods Brew without a doubt. Their Cherry Tocacco reminds me of good cherry pipe tobacco, and it's amazing! BWB was the first vendor of many that I have tried that their tobacco blends ACTUALLY taste like tobacco. I feel you shouldn't even bother with anywhere else if thats specifically what you are after, you will find nothing better. Many other vendors tobacco flavors that I have tried have been good, but none have came as close to the real thing as BWB.