I get you wanna find something to replicate your fave smokes. But honestly, thats like finding your personal unicorn. With the burning paper taste and burning plant matter its near impossible to get it just right.
I liked menthol's too. At first I vaped minty flavors. Again this is just me. But I was wanting to get away from tobacco so i didn't vape tobacco flavors, one day I might, but I have yet to.
These days I enjoy sweet fruity flavors, sometimes with menthol or varies mint flavors, sometimes not. I keep spearmint, wintergreen, and peppermint on hand to mix with juices. This way I can have it as minty as I want. The ones that come with menthol I generally don't mess with.
It's up to you really. I'm not telling you what to do or vape. Just my two cents worht really. My point is with all the variety of flavors available why only try one? While your searching for your unicorn. Pick up a few you wouldn't normally try. You might find something you'd rather vape.
I've found that vaping not only cured my cigerette habit but my sweet tooth too. Win, win in my book. Grin
Happy Vaping