Oh and for the record, Kroger imitation Maple Flavor has Water, artificial flavor, carmel color, and propelyne glycol. Thats right it's a PG base. Imitation Butter Flavor: Water, PG, artificial flavor and yellow #5. Not much different than the "Made for e-cig" flavors. In fact, how do you know they make the flavors themselves, I mean besides mixing different bases. I doubt that they are creating artificial flavors themselves, it's not cost effective. Sorry again, I'm just tired of misinformation.