Hmm, a lot of good suggestions here. I'm looking them up. I don't know if this could narrow it down a bit, but I was never into the sweet corporate cigs like Marlboro and Camel, which is probably why I didn't like the Marb mix from Cignot or the Camel Desert Ship one. I always used to smoke Natural American Spirit, which is just pure raw tobacco without any flavorings or additives. Very robust. I'm looking for a liquid that reflects true tobacco taste, not the taste of a certain brand or type of cigarette. Does that make sense?