Ok, here are the results. I haven't even gotten the Creamy Caramel concentrate yet, but the Tobacco, Burley, Vanilla Swirl and Hickory Smoke all came in yesterday. I had some RY4 Double concentrate lying around which could stand in a little for the missing Caramel flavor and the tobaccos. But......
The recipe from the link is nonsense. First of all I have a bottle of TC right here (most always do) and I can say with 100% certainty that neither of the tobacco concentrates suggested are remotely correct. Perhaps there is some kind of pipe tobacco flavoring used by JC...I don't know, but it's definitely not the two suggested. Frankly I think they give off the aroma of urine...not something I want to vape. And then the question remains: where did this person get the idea for these flavors being in TC? Well, reading from JC's website it states
This rich and smoky tobacco flavor will charm you from the first puff with hints of burnt caramel and vanilla that combine with a smooth, mesquite vapor.
Ok, so smoky tobacco flavor and mesquite. Well hickory doesn't quite do that on it's own

. Actually, I haven't looked to see if I can find a mesquite smoke flavor but it would certainly have a different characteristic than hickory. Mesquite is sweeter, and that's something that stands out in Tennessee Cured...a sweetness that goes beyond that which VG will impart. It's not so much a sweetness in taste as it is in aroma. But the caramel? Well JC says Burnt Caramel and I have to admit that if caramel is a component at all, burnt caramel indeed does sound right. That being said, I've held this juice to my nose dozens of times trying to pull the individual scents so as to identify its parts. Sometimes I think
I smell toffee and other times
I smell something minty. The flavors of coffee, caramel, Jack Daniels, all sorts of things seem to be in there. But just as soon as you
think you've identified a flavor, it vanishes into the complexity this juice is known for. So what does it smell like? Well Tennessee Cured, of course. I will keep trying to crack the code on this one, but in the meantime nothing beats the genuine thing, and I'm about to order some of their low-nic kind to see how it does on my mod. As for the Hickory Smoke...well a tiny bit of this stuff goes a LONG way, but it sure is cool to add it to other things just for a little variety. Like hey man...ever had a grilled banana? It's pretty good.