They are fudging the numbers.

Status
Not open for further replies.

jhiga

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 31, 2013
119
54
Portland
...Something is for sure, we're ALL going to die in the end regardless of whether we never smoked, ate "healthy," or (add latest health fad). I have not met anyone who has fooled the cycle of life and death yet.

Well, I'm going to live forever or die trying. Wish me luck ;D

In all seriousness, though, you're right.
 

noi_max

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 19, 2012
375
188
Portland OR
I've seen and felt the effects of smoking first hand. It's not really about the cause of death for me as it is the quality of life.

I could die by a horrible car accident, but if the years leading up to that did not include coughing my guts out and smelling like an ashtray all the time, would you say that was better quality of life?
 

KerryK

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 11, 2012
782
377
Madtown, WI
I've seen and felt the effects of smoking first hand. It's not really about the cause of death for me as it is the quality of life.

I could die by a horrible car accident, but if the years leading up to that did not include coughing my guts out and smelling like an ashtray all the time, would you say that was better quality of life?

Finally a real truth......
 

KerryK

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 11, 2012
782
377
Madtown, WI
Each year 2.6 million people die within the usa which are caused by heart disease, cancers, lower respiratory disease, stroke, Alzheimer's, diabetes, and finally accidents.


Roughly 1/5 of the population smokes and roughly 1/5 of the 2.6 million people that die are smokers. yet, it is to my surprise that smoking still causes 500,000 deaths each year according to their statistics, which is roughly 1/5 of all deaths.


Do they expect me to believe that smoking has a 100% mortality rate, yet they are dying at roughly the same proportion as none smokers each year? To put it frankly, I am CON-FUS-ED.


What they are doing is saying smoking is related to heart disease, cancers, strokes, lower respiratory disease, diabetes and if you did die of one of these diseases and you do smoke then you must have died from smoking, diseases which coincidentally is exactly how everyone else dies.


As a matter of fact, the life expectancy of a smoker is approximately 7 years less than a none smoker at just under 10%. With my limited mathematical experience I would expect the mortality rate to be closer to 10% for smokers which leads me to the conclusion that only 50,000 people die in the USA from smoking each year.


Don't be at all surprised to find statistics in the future for vaping that border on the absurd. Perhaps vaping will kill more people annually than the entire population of vapers. Who knows.


Its been estimated that 100,000 people each year die related to medical malpractice. The only way to protect yourself is to double check the medical communities science and speak out when it is bad science. Don't let them perscribe you with something when the science indicates that you can skip the harmful effects of smoking and prescription drugs by vaping.


Thanks for reading!


This is the most intellectually irresponsible post I think I have seen on ECF.
 

Ken_A

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 13, 2013
4,876
28,345
Florida
... I mean we all learned about how wooly mammoths walked the icy tundras of North America in history class right? Did they cause the planet to warm up by using hairsprays with chlorofluorocarbons (CFC's)? Did they pollute the air by driving around in gas guzzling Hummers? Of course not. I am wondering why anyone still believes these liars or anything they say...
Well.... they were large animals... they probably changed the climate from excess methane. Isn't that what is going to get us now because we have too many cattle to feed the population with? The last time I tried an all veggie diet, I created quite a lot of methane myself.. I personally would rather some other animal I eat do that for me :D
 

mommyofdoom

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 24, 2013
731
2,369
Orlando, Florida
There is one STD that kills you every-time, and that is life. Smoking just enhances the deadliness of this disease, along with other factors lol.

They've now cured HIV in a few cases, if that's what you're referring to.

One case that was all over the news recently was a newborn baby who was infected via the mother, but cured completely with a combination of treatments.
 

EddardinWinter

The Philosopher Who Rides
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 13, 2012
8,866
28,169
Richmond, Va
This is the most intellectually irresponsible post I think I have seen on ECF.

Which part of it, and on what grounds? I think he is illustrating the ridiculous nature of the politically-driven and absurd statistics with a bit of his own ironic flim-flam statistics...
 

KerryK

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 11, 2012
782
377
Madtown, WI
Which part of it, and on what grounds? I think he is illustrating the ridiculous nature of the politically-driven and absurd statistics with a bit of his own ironic flim-flam statistics...

What I don't see are any sources given, any studies offered, any acknowledgement of the international science, he's reducing it to some boogeyman called "They" ...who's "They?" and where are "They?"
 

clnire

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 15, 2013
7,719
73,217
Florida
These kids now days, with all the sanitary wipes, fast food, chemicals in foods, shots for their shots, how are they going to end up aging? They won't be naturally immune to anything, obese, and what does that do to their health? Heck, when I was a kid we played in the dirt, if you dropped food on a CLEAN floor it was nothing to try to beat the dog to pick it up and eat it. We got our shots, but how many of these new strains of illness is due to all the vaccinations against old ones? And then there are the drugs for the side effects of your prescribed drugs....

Not the same, but I have dogs. The current 2 had puppy shots only, no "yearly" vaccinations except for the 3 year rabies only because it is required. We travel the country to dog shows with our business so they are both exposed to everything that passes through. They eat a good diet (not Walmart Old Roy) and get regular exercise. One is 13 and is in perfect health, never had any health issues. His only "issues" now are age related (me too!). The other is 6 and the same. I expect her to age as well and the older one. OK, these are dogs, but there are similarities.

Off topic? Yes, but to read the stats on health, I can just imagine how my son in the military will age with all the vaccinations they give him. I bet these kids now days in their sterile environment will have problems other that second hand smoke which WE no longer spew.
 

Robino1

Resting in Peace
ECF Veteran
Sep 7, 2012
27,447
110,404
Treasure Coast, Florida
What I don't see are any sources given, any studies offered, any acknowledgement of the international science, he's reducing it to some boogeyman called "They" ...who's "They?" and where are "They?"

He probably got it from the Internet therefore it must be true. ;)

I actually read the OP as a tongue in cheek skewed stat that the OP ran across on his search for statistical data. Data that he tried to make sense out of but mathematically could not get the numbers to crunch correctly.

Some things are not to be taken so seriously. Life is too short to sweat the small stuff. If you want something to take seriously, join CASAA and join in the fight for our right to vape.

I did, will you? If you have....sweeeeet! :). If you haven't already, please join. We need more people on the front lines, so to speak.
 

Ken_A

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 13, 2013
4,876
28,345
Florida
They are everywhere! They hide under your bed and whisper in your ear from around corners...

But in this case, I think the OP is talking in a more general sense. Such as the average person sitting in front of the TV "knows as fact" because they "heard it somewhere", and is actually expressing the same frustration as yourself for the lack do ACTUAL verifiable sources to this "common" knowledge. It is a general habit of people trying to prove a point (news people, politicians, etc) to make a statement without any backup. But because they are looked at as a "trusted" source, the average person just accepts it.
 

EddardinWinter

The Philosopher Who Rides
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 13, 2012
8,866
28,169
Richmond, Va
He probably got it from the Internet therefore it must be true. ;)

I actually read the OP as a tongue in cheek skewed stat that the OP ran across on his search for statistical data. Data that he tried to make sense out of but mathematically could not get the numbers to crunch correctly.

Some things are not to be taken so seriously. Life is too short to sweat the small stuff. If you want something to take seriously, join CASAA and join in the fight for our right to vape.

I did, will you? If you have....sweeeeet! :). If you haven't already, please join. We need more people on the front lines, so to speak.

Well, I can see my "publicist" Robin0 has already answered for me. No offense, KerryK if my post seemed a bit chippy. I simply meant what the gentle Robino said with greater tact than a loud-mouthed lion is capable of.
 

Renolizzie

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Aug 7, 2012
6,933
28,124
66
Northern Nevada, astride the "49er trail
He probably got it from the Internet therefore it must be true. ;)

I actually read the OP as a tongue in cheek skewed stat that the OP ran across on his search for statistical data. Data that he tried to make sense out of but mathematically could not get the numbers to crunch correctly.

Some things are not to be taken so seriously. Life is too short to sweat the small stuff. If you want something to take seriously, join CASAA and join in the fight for our right to vape.

I did, will you? If you have....sweeeeet! :). If you haven't already, please join. We need more people on the front lines, so to speak.

We definitely need people that can quote the statistics commenting on articles in the newspapers and on the internet. Some facts to counteract some of the absurd things that antis and the ignorant spout. I joined CASAA because e cigs are the best thing that ever happened to me health wise and they are a great organization with really smart and dedicated people working for THR. I'm starting to think we need to call it smoking harm reduction.
 

KerryK

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 11, 2012
782
377
Madtown, WI
Yet as our population continues to live longer than previous generations, it can't be that we are dying from old age, now could it? George Burns lived to be just over 100 and he had a cigar ALL the time. Bette Davis smoked heavily and she lived to be 81 and was still a smoker.

People are alive way longer now than ever before but yet there were more smokers in that generation that are living longer. Talk about confusing! The anti smokers are contributing any sickness that a person may get to smoking. Whether it is true or not. So if someone gets heart disease if that person happens so smoke then automatically the heart disease is attributed to the fact that the person smoked. Is it even remotely possible that the person was genetically going to get heart disease regardless of the fact they smoked?

I'm not saying that smoking is not bad for you. I'm just pointing out that there might just be contributing factors, other than smoking, to health issues.

So then this was satire? I was suppose to laugh when I read this? Sorry, I thought you were serious...."The anti smokers are contributing any sickness that a person may get to smoking" I mean no one would arbitrarily make this kind of accusation....but your right, it's just words...no biggie.
 

EddardinWinter

The Philosopher Who Rides
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 13, 2012
8,866
28,169
Richmond, Va

Robino1

Resting in Peace
ECF Veteran
Sep 7, 2012
27,447
110,404
Treasure Coast, Florida
So then this was satire? I was suppose to laugh when I read this? Sorry, I thought you were serious...."The anti smokers are contributing any sickness that a person may get to smoking" I mean no one would arbitrarily make this kind of accusation....but your right, it's just words...no biggie.

That statement that you quoted of mine, was in fact serious. Wow. Since you have joined CASAA (two AA's at the end) you are familiar with Kristin. It was in reading Kristin's many posts on this sort of thing that really made sense to me. I wish I could find that post where she does in fact point out what I have pointed out in the statement of mine that you quoted and made mockery of.

I wish you well and continued success in your vaping journey.

All the above are my opinions and are valid thoughts, just as yours are valid to you. ;)
 

Ravensfan

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 1, 2013
244
322
53
Baltimore, MD
I'm a funeral director and have been in the death care field for 20 years. By my "seat of my pants" research, dealing with thousands of cases, smoking kills very few people at a young age, i.e. 40's, 50's, and 60's. The state of Maryland has had the question, "Did tobacco use contribute to the cause of death?" on our death certificates for about 15 years. I have only seen about five cases where the doctor checked yes. Even in cases where it would seem obvious, most doctors will check the "unknown" box. The fact is that it is very hard to tell if smoking causes certain diseases on an individual basis since many of us are predisposed, genetically, to certain diseases. I applaud these doctors for staying true to science and not caving to political pressure. It was due to doctors complaints that the "unknown" box was added. When the question was first put on death certificates the only choices were, yes, no, and maybe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread