Here are the panelists:
Jean-Francois Etter, PhD, University of Geneva, Switzerland
Monique Williams, ABD, University of California Riverside
Natalie Walker, PhD, University of Auckland, New Zealand
Prudence Talbot, PhD, University of California Riverside
Discussant: Stanton Glantz, PhD, University of California San Francisco
Moderator: Phillip Gardiner, Dr. P.H., TRDRP
Etter is a French (Swiss?) professor who is reasonable about ecigs. Walker, from NZ? She may be a colleague of Laugesen, so might be objective. Gardiner, TruBot, and Glands we know too well. And Monique Williams? She a graduate student (does that quality her as an "expert researcher"? Inquiring minds want to know...) Her degree is a non-degree. ABD stands for "all but dissertation." She's one of TruBot's drones. ha!