'Vape' bans have little do do with public health

Status
Not open for further replies.

stevegmu

Moved On
ECF Veteran
May 10, 2013
11,630
12,348
6992 kilometers from home...
Can we agree that vaping isn't smoking?

Given that it isn't there is no way on earth that we should expect vapers to be bound by the same regulations as smokers.

Banning vaping seems very foolish. Why drive people back to tobacco if you genuinely wish people to give up tobacco?

There are many reasons why people would wish to ban vaping, ranging from priggishness through to revenue generation. Imho those views do not bear scrutiny.

If I read one more post that says that vapers should go to the places where smokers go and not vape in the places where smokers can't smoke...I shall be saddened.

How does not being able to vape where one can not smoke drive people back to smoking, if they couldn't smoke there to begin with?
 

spartanstew

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 29, 2013
11,496
18,348
Wylie, Texas
Can we agree that vaping isn't smoking?

Yes.

Given that it isn't there is no way on earth that we should expect vapers to be bound by the same regulations as smokers.

Same? No. Similar? Yes.

Banning vaping seems very foolish. Why drive people back to tobacco if you genuinely wish people to give up tobacco?

I didn't know we were talking about banning vaping altogether. I thought it was about banning vaping in certain locations.

There are many reasons why people would wish to ban vaping, ranging from priggishness through to revenue generation. Imho those views do not bear scrutiny.

Also because some people might be bothered by it.

If I read one more post that says that vapers should go to the places where smokers go and not vape in the places where smokers can't smoke...I shall be saddened.

They could also go to places where people that use a lot of perfume go. Or other places where it's OK to cast potentially unwanted odors on others. Or rooms with fog machines. But those places aren't as plentiful.

IMO, allowing vaping in smoking areas doesn't equate vaping with smoking. It's just an area where typcially people don't care what others are doing (smells, clouds, etc.).
 

e-pipeman

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 16, 2008
5,430
5,594
Brown Edge, England
How does not being able to vape where one can not smoke drive people back to smoking, if they couldn't smoke there to begin with?

Banning vaping will drive people back to tobacco, as I said You are "confusing" the final statement I made with an earlier statement in the same post.
 

e-pipeman

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 16, 2008
5,430
5,594
Brown Edge, England
Yes.



Same? No. Similar? Yes.



I didn't know we were talking about banning vaping altogether. I thought it was about banning vaping in certain locations.



Also because some people might be bothered by it.



They could also go to places where people that use a lot of perfume go. Or other places where it's OK to cast potentially unwanted odors on others. Or rooms with fog machines. But those places aren't as plentiful.

IMO, allowing vaping in smoking areas doesn't equate vaping with smoking. It's just an area where typcially people don't care what others are doing (smells, clouds, etc.).

We will agree to differ,
 

stevegmu

Moved On
ECF Veteran
May 10, 2013
11,630
12,348
6992 kilometers from home...
Banning vaping will drive people back to tobacco, as I said You are "confusing" the final statement I made with an earlier statement in the same post.

You actually think e-cigarettes will be banned? That's never going to happen, at least not in the US, but I see you are in the UK, so it is a possibility given their politics...
 

e-pipeman

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 16, 2008
5,430
5,594
Brown Edge, England
You actually think e-cigarettes will be banned? That's never going to happen, at least not in the US, but I see you are in the UK, so it is a possibility given their politics...

The UK have adopted a fairly "hands-off" approach to vaping at present. We will see what happens when 2016 comes around.
 

stevegmu

Moved On
ECF Veteran
May 10, 2013
11,630
12,348
6992 kilometers from home...
No. There is no element of passive smoking when vaping. Most vape is barely detectable to bystanders. It is not the same as smoking.

If you go by this forum, most vapers on here put out far more vapor than any cigarette could smoke... Even a BLU PLUS tank puts out more vapor than any cigarette could put out smoke...
 

spartanstew

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 29, 2013
11,496
18,348
Wylie, Texas
No. There is no element of passive smoking when vaping. Most vape is barely detectable to bystanders. It is not the same as smoking.

Again, I didn't say it was. But it's an optional activity that can certainly be annoying. Most people can smell it. Many people are bothered visually (especially at theaters or someone sitting in front of you in the stands, for example).

I would not eat in a restaurant where vaping was allowed (and never ate in restaurants where smoking was allowed either - even though I was a smoker). I wouldn't go to a theater where vaping was allowed either and wouldn't want to watch a ball game where the person in front of me (or next to me) was vaping.

And I'm a vaper, I can imagine how it might bother non-vapers (the majority of the population). I don't like going to smoking areas (and usually don't, I just don't vape until I can do it somewhere else), but at least it can be an option.
 

e-pipeman

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 16, 2008
5,430
5,594
Brown Edge, England
If you go by this forum, most vapers on here put out far more vapor than any cigarette could smoke... Even a BLU PLUS tank puts out more vapor than any cigarette could put out smoke...

But it is not smoke. There are no issues re "passive vaping". A forum search will show you that all current research says that this is not an issue. Smoke is very different.
 

e-pipeman

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 16, 2008
5,430
5,594
Brown Edge, England
Again, I didn't say it was. But it's an optional activity that can certainly be annoying. Most people can smell it. Many people are bothered visually (especially at theaters or someone sitting in front of you in the stands, for example).

I would not eat in a restaurant where vaping was allowed (and never ate in restaurants where smoking was allowed either - even though I was a smoker). I wouldn't go to a theater where vaping was allowed either and wouldn't want to watch a ball game where the person in front of me (or next to me) was vaping.

And I'm a vaper, I can imagine how it might bother non-vapers (the majority of the population). I don't like going to smoking areas (and usually don't, I just don't vape until I can do it somewhere else), but at least it can be an option.

The main reason that vapers should not be put in smoking areas is that they are not smokers. Why should they inhale tobacco fumes?
 

spartanstew

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 29, 2013
11,496
18,348
Wylie, Texas
The main reason that vapers should not be put in smoking areas is that they are not smokers. Why should they inhale tobacco fumes?

I agree with that, and that's why I don't go to smoking areas, but what's the other option???

Have businesses put in a second area just for vaping? Clearly you're not a business person.

The options are either to allow them to go to the smoking area or don't allow it at all. Take you pick.
 

DC2

Tootie Puffer
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 21, 2009
24,161
40,974
San Diego
Given that it isn't there is no way on earth that we should expect vapers to be bound by the same regulations as smokers.
Same? No. Similar? Yes.
Leaving aside the discussion about whether or not similar regulations are valid...
The problem is that they ARE generally making them the same.

I would not eat in a restaurant where vaping was allowed (and never ate in restaurants where smoking was allowed either - even though I was a smoker). I wouldn't go to a theater where vaping was allowed either and wouldn't want to watch a ball game where the person in front of me (or next to me) was vaping.

And I'm a vaper, I can imagine how it might bother non-vapers (the majority of the population). I don't like going to smoking areas (and usually don't, I just don't vape until I can do it somewhere else), but at least it can be an option.
And all of this can be accomplished by allowing businesses to make their own rules.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread