What will you do?

Status
Not open for further replies.

gthompson

Free at last
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 28, 2011
9,814
22,104
Tennessee, USA
They cant ban ejuice,its impossible,but the will try too tax it higher,we need to stand up for our rights.

I agree that this is possible, but that wasn't your original premise. "BAN everything e-cig related!!" is not going to happen. People like to get panicked I guess.
 

Drael

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 29, 2012
359
229
48
New Zealand (Middle Earth, lol)
Regulation and taxation is almost certainly what they have in mind, and if people get panicked enough they'll be happy about getting regulated and taxed.

Taxation? very unlikely IMO. It's morally equivilant to taxing methadone for ...... junkies. The media would have alot of fun with that though :p

Regulation, most certainly. And quite possibly too much.
 

DC2

Tootie Puffer
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 21, 2009
24,161
40,974
San Diego
Nicotine is part of the nightshade family of plants. Nicotine is in eggplants you can buy at the store. I'll start jucing eggplants and vaping that. Nah....

Seriously, those who are leading the charge in this fight, should make the argument that nic juice can't be classified as a "tobacco" product, because it is naturally occurring in the nightshade family of plants/vegetables. Nicotine is not directly associated with tobacco only, period. If the idiots do ban nicotine juice, I see vapers growing nightshade plants in their back yard, and coming up with ways to extract nicotine from them, then adding that to their 0nic juice they buy.

CASAA? Are you reading this?
As far as I know, it is fairly well-known that it is financially unfeasible at this time to extract nicotine from anything other than tobacco.
And it is also financially unfeasible to make synthetic nicotine.
 

DC2

Tootie Puffer
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 21, 2009
24,161
40,974
San Diego

daw840

Full Member
Apr 27, 2010
35
13
Overland Park, KS
Meh, they'll never actually be able to ban the hardware. Sites will just sell it as a "novelty item not for use with nicotine" and that's that. The liquid is what I'm a little worried about. If anything they will just require that any new nicotine products be presented for inspection by the FDA and have to go through an approval process. This will put a strain on the small time mom and pop type stores but it will all be back eventually, just maybe not in the same form as we are used to.
 

Drael

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 29, 2012
359
229
48
New Zealand (Middle Earth, lol)
The European Union is in the process of attempting to do that right now.
And they are doing it through regulation.

Well, perhaps ban is the wrong word, as long as you don't mind being limited to 4mg strength liquid...
http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/fo...d-e-cigarettes-more-than-4mg-ml-nicotine.html

Maybe we will be smarter than them?

Well as draconian as that may be, its not a ban. Its a classification of things over 4mg/ml as a medicine (and thus requires an approval process). Stupid law, which will force people back into smoking, while companies jump through hopes, but its still not a ban.

I sincerely hope they don't pass that load of garbage.

As a related thought, nicotine products are regarded as medicines here, in nz, by default (they never changed it, it already was that way). We are however allowed to import 3 months worth of nicotine containing anything, without it being locally approved, and thats the loophole we use.

In australia nicotine is classified as a poison, and likewise you can import it, but not purchase locally.

Now both laws need updating to allow e-cigs, but will people in the EU, still be able to import nicotine products brought in outside markets, like we can?

I see nothing in there about importation, or personal possesion, only market regs.

If so, it may be not so bad.

As far as I know, it is fairly well-known that it is financially unfeasible at this time to extract nicotine from anything other than tobacco.

Theres an australian plant thats loaded with nicotine. It would be viable to extract from there, if its viable to farm (which is untried, because people currently use tobacco)
 
Last edited:

Underwhelmed

Account closed on request
ECF Veteran
May 22, 2012
6,071
1,260
Texas
They may have trouble banning nicotine base, since it's used for other applications such a pesticides.

Nicotine Sulfate is currently used as an acceptable organic pesticide, but that's not what we vape.

After Jan. 1 2014 it will no longer be sold as a pesticide per a request approved by the EPA in 2008.
 

Drael

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 29, 2012
359
229
48
New Zealand (Middle Earth, lol)
No, it's equivalent to taxing tobacco and alcohol.

Not even remotely!

E-cigs are a harm minimisation product, something that is a low harm alternative to a very addictive drug.

It is thus like methadone. No one would have a problem morally with taxing "junk" if it were legal, but taxing methadone would be actively encouraging use of "junk". Thats a morally quite difficult to defend position, and would create a crap storm.

Taxing booze and cigs is okay, because their presence as products creates measurable harm to society and individuals. E-cigs by comparison, remove existing harm from society. Even if it weren't for tobacco's popularity, e-cigs are basically equivilant to caffiene.

I personally do not see how you think these things are equivilant. You must at least be able to see that taxing a low harm alternative, actively encourages smoking, no?

If anything e-cigs should be _subsidized_.

And any government organisation, that is seen to be actively encouraging smoking, should to be prepared for some serious backlash IMO!

(That wont stop them from doing stupid things sometimes, but if any of these regulations go the wrong way, either in the US, or the EU, there will be a loud and definitive opposition voiced - there can't not be when, regardless of intention, a bad law will be causing tobacco smoking numbers to rise)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread