4. Your iphone either had a defective battery, or a defective charging circuit. This is an EXTREMELY well known problem.
Your batts are your business, but every time you take them as low as they'll let you take them, you are risking destroying them permanently.
It's true there was a run of defective iPhone batteries - as in going completely dead or substantially less usable capacity within the 1 year warranty. It's also well documented that LiIon battery performance does degrade over time, and it correlates to usage, and not just on iPhones. I bought my iPhone 3g after they had that problem and the battery life tracked as expected. I classify myself as a medium to heavy phone user. After almost two years, the runtime on a full charge had decreased to about 60-70% of what it would do new. When it got inconvenient enough, I bought a new oem battery from MacPro and replaced it myself. It now works like it did when factory new, just in time to upgrade and give the 3g to my wife
Just about every LiIon powered device I've owned in the last 5 years behaves the same way. They're good for about a year or two, and time to replace when you finally see the run time shrink enough to become a hassle. Outside of some manufacturing/QA defects on these PV batteries, I'm expecting lifespan to be on the shorter side since mine are in nearly constant use and not on a charger while in use. Maybe a pass-thru setup will help with that? As-in reducing the amount of usage solely on battery power. Or maybe not, as the current draw from the atty might exceed the charge current enough to dip into the battery capacity a tiny bit on each pull. So many many very small charge cycles versus one day-long deep cycle. At twenty bucks each and no trouble so far, I'll take my chances as-is.
With a cell phone, I pick it up now and then to check email or news, and some days many hours of calls and others few. On battery power most of the time and charged at least every night. With a laptop, unless I'm totally mobile while traveling somewhere, my laptop is on a/c power. On the other hand, my PV is running non-stop and always on battery power until I recharge. Right now I'm rotating 3 batteries and will buy a couple more to spread that heavy usage out some more. I don't usually run them down to the shut off point, but I don't stress about it and they're back on a charger pretty quick.
Even with obsessive care, you're bound to get a bad one at some point that doesn't go the distance. Good reason to have a few spares.