Who has the best (non cough syrup) DYI cherry flavor?

[Zelphie]

I am so sick of the medincine flavor to so many cherry liquids so I want to be able to make my own but I dont know who has a great/ non cough syrup tasting flavor concentrate.
PA, FA, Loranns, Loranns naturals, other??

Edit: I want to add to this post and ask who has a good strawberry flavor too, because a lot of times with premixed juice I get a weird flavor and aftertaste with strawberry that I cannot place...I want to avoid this.

 

[MaxUT]

PA Maraschino Cherry is pretty good. I find that 20% in a VG base gives a strong flavor, so I'd suggest trying about 15% to start with.

 

[Jynn]

The flavorart cherry and strawberry are both good.

 

[DaDuke]

The FA cherry tasted like most other fake candy cherry flavorings to me and a friend when we tested it as a single flavor. Will be mixing it with some chocolate to see if that alters the candy/fake quality of the cherry. Haven't received my FA strawberry so can't say. The FA apple is really good to me (just like fresh green apple) but pretty weak imo even at 20%. Right now i'm on a quest to try all the cherry, strawberry and choco flavs from the various manufacturers since those seem to be the hardest to get ones i like.