Do Vapers Eat their Young? – Reacting to Realities of Regulation

Status
Not open for further replies.

VictorC

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 26, 2015
750
1,894
Toronto, Ontario

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,633
1
84,765
So-Cal
Not sure why there Wouldn't be Infighting and Separate Factions in Vapers and Advocacy Groups?

Because there is No Clear, Unified, Agreement on what Exactly is a "Reasonable" Regulation. Or what is the Best Way to obtain it.

Take the Predicate Date.

Moving it to May 5th, 2016 would be Great. But would the Majority of Vapers/Advocacy Groups go with a Mid 2014 Date if it had a Better Chance of Happening?
 

Steamix

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 21, 2013
1,586
3,212
Vapistan
Smoking ... hmm ... you are/were either viewed as a smoker or a non-smoker.
Mayhap a *little* differentation along pipes and cigars - that's pretty much it.
But whether smoked brand A or Brand B or C didn't matter much - except to you.

vaping is different - vaping allows for individuals finding their own individual way to go about it.
Ciga-likes, mech mods or anything in between, drippers, clearos, cartos. Build your own or get pre-built.
Chase clouds or stealth. Buy ready juice or DIY. All there. Good thing it is.

But yeah, I get it.

All of us are first and foremost vapers.

Divide and conquer.

If we fall for that - the cloudz bro scoffing at the tootle puffer and/or vice versa we'll end up having neither.
 

Lessifer

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 5, 2013
8,309
28,986
Sacramento, California
We need strong leadership to step up, and IMO the industry needs to step up more too. Yes, it would be fantastic if all 9 million vapers stood up and fought, but the industry needs to stand up and fight for itself too. Some of them are, more of them need to.
 

KODIAK (TM)

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 31, 2014
1,898
4,983
Dead Moose, AK
This is no surprise. It's a relatively young industry with a lot of equally young players. And of course there's the clueless "rest of us". Just look at the merriment and glee in the other forums over new RDA purchases and the first 0.0000001 ohm coil build.
 

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
IMHO.
Until the industry gets together and understands that vaping is so safe when compared to smoking that the FDA's deeming regs are the equivalent of shutting down adult Kool
Aid stands they will get no where. You got a ISO 7 certified lab. Big deal. Name one pathogen that has been spread by e-liquid made in someones kitchen. I am waiting. Has e.coli,salmonella, or listeria ever been found? How about the zika virus? Swine or bird flu? Monkey pox? Remember Monkey pox? The only thing better than vapings safety compared to smoking is its inherent safety and ease to make. Custom mixing at the counter is no more dangerous than having a bartender mix you a drink. How many of us blend our own Margarita's at home.Measure,mix and,pour. How hard can that be? Clean your equipment. Try not to get any on you.
:2c:
Regards
Mike
 

Tufur

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 7, 2014
87
79
San Jose, Ca. usa
IMHO.
Until the industry gets together and understands that vaping is so safe when compared to smoking that the FDA's deeming regs are the equivalent of shutting down adult Kool
Aid stands they will get no where. You got a ISO 7 certified lab. Big deal. Name one pathogen that has been spread by e-liquid made in someones kitchen. I am waiting. Has e.coli,salmonella, or listeria ever been found? How about the zika virus? Swine or bird flu? Monkey pox? Remember Monkey pox? The only thing better than vapings safety compared to smoking is its inherent safety and ease to make. Custom mixing at the counter is no more dangerous than having a bartender mix you a drink. How many of us blend our own Margarita's at home.Measure,mix and,pour. How hard can that be? Clean your equipment. Try not to get any on you.
:2c:
Regards
Mike
I remember not too long ago an e-liquid manufacturer put titanium dioxide in his Unicorn Milk for that opaque look. There have also been some people putting dyes in their e-liquids that are not certified for inhalation. A very small number are using 'natural' drug extracts. In 2013, a nicotine supplier in the US and a promoter of this site went and sold a batch of diluted oxidized nicotine. Another nicotine supplier here sold a poorly mixed batch that ranged from 8% to 15% nic between the bottles. These people lack basic food product manufacturing knowledge. They practice zero quality control on their ingredients for consistency and contamination and only practice, "It looks to me Jim." QA on their products. When you see something is 98% pure, you have to know what that other 2% is. People that are not invested in a proper ISO certified manufacturing facility are accidents waiting to happen. Dr. Farsalinos has been harping on this ingredient problem since the beginning. And it is the reason I have only bought one bottle of premade juice. I DIY so I can control my suppliers.
 

Lessifer

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 5, 2013
8,309
28,986
Sacramento, California
I remember not too long ago an e-liquid manufacturer put titanium dioxide in his Unicorn Milk for that opaque look. There have also been some people putting dyes in their e-liquids that are not certified for inhalation. A very small number are using 'natural' drug extracts. In 2013, a nicotine supplier in the US and a promoter of this site went and sold a batch of diluted oxidized nicotine. Another nicotine supplier here sold a poorly mixed batch that ranged from 8% to 15% nic between the bottles. These people lack basic food product manufacturing knowledge. They practice zero quality control on their ingredients for consistency and contamination and only practice, "It looks to me Jim." QA on their products. When you see something is 98% pure, you have to know what that other 2% is. People that are not invested in a proper ISO certified manufacturing facility are accidents waiting to happen. Dr. Farsalinos has been harping on this ingredient problem since the beginning. And it is the reason I have only bought one bottle of premade juice. I DIY so I can control my suppliers.
And yet we still don't have any credible health issues. Nothing we use is certified for inhalation. There is of course room for improvement. People do get food poisoning every day from restaurants. A new industry and a lot has been learned in a short time.
 

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
I remember not too long ago an e-liquid manufacturer put titanium dioxide in his Unicorn Milk for that opaque look. There have also been some people putting dyes in their e-liquids that are not certified for inhalation. A very small number are using 'natural' drug extracts. In 2013, a nicotine supplier in the US and a promoter of this site went and sold a batch of diluted oxidized nicotine. Another nicotine supplier here sold a poorly mixed batch that ranged from 8% to 15% nic between the bottles. These people lack basic food product manufacturing knowledge. They practice zero quality control on their ingredients for consistency and contamination and only practice, "It looks to me Jim." QA on their products. When you see something is 98% pure, you have to know what that other 2% is. People that are not invested in a proper ISO certified manufacturing facility are accidents waiting to happen. Dr. Farsalinos has been harping on this ingredient problem since the beginning. And it is the reason I have only bought one bottle of premade juice. I DIY so I can control my suppliers.
Titanium dioxide is found in virtually every paint and premixed texture. It's used for marking
athletic fields. It's used in foods for coloring. It is considered safe for human consumption.
However like asbestos,,acetyl and silica sand it is a occupational hazard and creates lung
related issues when used in large concentrated amounts.

The use of natural Drug extracts? Really.

-8% to +15% between bottles seems like a lot. Do you mean one bottle was
8mg pml and one 15mg pml?, or 100mg pml nic base that varied -8 to plus 15%
per ml? At either rate nothing remotely dangerous. False advertising. Violations
of weights and standards perhaps. One should always error to the plus side.
The point is variations such as these are common in the manufacturing of
consumable products and do not pose a health threat in and of themselves.
some people may notice a difference. Most do not.

Now lets address these mysterious contaminants. Name one.
When a bottle of PG/VG,flavors and nicotine says 98.5% pure that means
the 1.5% remaining is 99.99% water and may contain trace amounts of
things in such low quantities as not to be measurable and or not harmful
in any amounts found. I am willing to even say I do not believe anyone
is using street run off for base and parking lot sweepings for thickeners.
The companies making these raw products also supply the food,drug and
cosmetic industries to name a few. Whats on the bottle is what you get.
Anyone using raw materials not deemed fit for human consumption is
breaking the law. To my knowledge no one has been hospitalized from
buying poisoned juice. Unless the nic level gets outrageously high the
only possible bad outcome is bad tasting juice. I would not vape it if it
tasted bad. I would not eat spaghetti if it tasted bad. Wait, I have never
found bad tasting spaghetti. There's my spaghetti and all those second
place finishers.
:2c:
Regards
Mike
 

Tufur

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 7, 2014
87
79
San Jose, Ca. usa
And yet we still don't have any credible health issues. Nothing we use is certified for inhalation. There is of course room for improvement. People do get food poisoning every day from restaurants. A new industry and a lot has been learned in a short time.
I don't see where it is a matter of creditable health issues. I see it as a matter of clean and wholesome products. 'Good Manufacturing Practices'(GMP) are well known in the food industry, e-liquid is a food, UC Davis sells GMP books for wine, beer and other products that will save one time going to all the different resources. Someday, I expect a GMP book on e-liquid. Phil Busardo recently toured a well setup e-liquid manufacturer in Benicia, Calif. and he has the video posted on his youtube channel:
Not every e-liquid manufacturer needs that large of a facility, but they should meet pharmaceutical manufacturing facility standards.

Chemicals can be certified, profiled, registered, G.R.A.S. listed, etc. and each word has a different meaning under the law. I apologize for using certified in a general manner. But, propylene glycol actually is generally regarded as safe for inhalation. Here is an EPA registration of propylene glycol as a pesticide and air sanitation chem for four companies. It is also considered baby safe(see page 2; paragraph 4). And who knew it made a good animal flea, mite and lice controller.;) https://archive.epa.gov/pesticides/reregistration/web/pdf/propylene_glycol_red.pdf
 
Last edited:

Lessifer

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 5, 2013
8,309
28,986
Sacramento, California
I don't see where it is a matter of creditable health issues. I see it as a matter of clean and wholesome products. 'Good Manufacturing Practices'(GMP) are well known in the food industry, e-liquid is a food, UC Davis sells GMP books for wine, beer and other products that will save one time going to all the different resources. Someday, I expect a GMP book on e-liquid. Phil Busardo recently toured a well setup e-liquid manufacturer in Benicia, Calif. and he has the video posted on his youtube channel:
Not every e-liquid manufacturer needs that large of a facility, but they should meet pharmaceutical manufacturing facility standards.

Chemicals can be certified, profiled, registered, G.R.A.S. listed, etc. and each word has a different meaning under the law. I apologize for using certified in a general manner. But, propylene glycol actually is generally regarded as safe for inhalation. Here is an EPA registration of propylene glycol as a pesticide and air sanitation chem for four companies. It is also considered baby safe(see page 2; paragraph 4). And who knew it made a good animal flea, mite and lice controller.;) https://archive.epa.gov/pesticides/reregistration/web/pdf/propylene_glycol_red.pdf

Right... See, you did it too. "e-liquid is a food" but for some reason the facility "should meet pharmaceutical manufacturing facility standards." Most restaurant kitchens are not ISO certified. I'd be okay vaping something from a shop that received an A grade from the health department, using restaurant standards.
 

BuGlen

Divergent
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 6, 2012
1,952
3,976
Tampa, Florida
Right... See, you did it too. "e-liquid is a food" but for some reason the facility "should meet pharmaceutical manufacturing facility standards." Most restaurant kitchens are not ISO certified. I'd be okay vaping something from a shop that received an A grade from the health department, using restaurant standards.

Agreed, except for the fact that nicotine in high concentrations (higher than the 100mg standard DIY) requires additional ventilation and safety precautions. For the sake of the employees, I could see some additional OSHA standards for mixing rooms, but not necessary an ISO certification standard.
 

Lessifer

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 5, 2013
8,309
28,986
Sacramento, California
Agreed, except for the fact that nicotine in high concentrations (higher than the 100mg standard DIY) requires additional ventilation and safety precautions. For the sake of the employees, I could see some additional OSHA standards for mixing rooms, but not necessary an ISO certification standard.
Of course, proper safe handling procedures for whatever is being used. The point though, is that you don't need a million dollar facility to mix e-liquid, but I can see why those with the facilities might want people to think that you do.
 

Tufur

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 7, 2014
87
79
San Jose, Ca. usa
Of course, proper safe handling procedures for whatever is being used. The point though, is that you don't need a million dollar facility to mix e-liquid, but I can see why those with the facilities might want people to think that you do.
Pharmaceutical manufacturing facilities are not necessarily that clean and they do not have to cost a million dollars. They do create a manufacturing process standard and adhere to those manufacturing standards for each product they produce. I would think just certain ISO standards need to be implemented. I wouldn't want to inhale L.A. dust and smog along with my e-liquid. I also don't think we should have to trust a Malaysian vegetable glycerin manufacturer as to how pure his product is. It should be checked and recorded. I properly use 'food' as anything your body will metabolize into energy or nutrition. It doesn't have to down the gullet.
 
Last edited:

Lessifer

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 5, 2013
8,309
28,986
Sacramento, California
Pharmaceutical manufacturing facilities are not necessarily that clean and they do not have to cost a million dollars. They do create a manufacturing process standard and adhere to those manufacturing standards for each product they produce. I would think just certain ISO standards need to be implemented. I wouldn't want to inhale L.A. dust and smog along with my e-liquid. I also don't think we should have to trust a Malaysian vegetable glycerin manufacturer as to how pure his product is. It should be checked and recorded.
Many, if not most pharmaceuticals are actually manufactured in third world countries. USP is already a standard. Again though, this isn't medication, it's more like food. I've worked in kitchens, it's one reason why I cook most of my meals at home.
 

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
Not every e-liquid manufacturer needs that large of a facility, but they should meet pharmaceutical manufacturing facility standards.

Agreed, except for the fact that nicotine in high concentrations (higher than the 100mg standard DIY) requires additional ventilation and safety precautions. For the sake of the employees, I could see some additional OSHA standards for mixing rooms, but not necessary an ISO certification standard.

Pharmaceutical manufacturing facilities are not necessarily that clean and they do not have to cost a million dollars. They do create a manufacturing process standard and adhere to those manufacturing standards for each product they produce. I would think just certain ISO standards need to be implemented. I wouldn't want to inhale L.A. dust and smog along with my e-liquid. I also don't think we should have to trust a Malaysian vegetable glycerin manufacturer as to how pure his product is. It should be checked and recorded. I properly use 'food' as anything your body will metabolize into energy or nutrition. It doesn't have to down the gullet.
When one considers the processes one has to go through to make your basic Twinkie how
on Earth would one think that e-liquid is a pharmaceutical product? It's as safe,easy and as complicated to make as Kool-Ade.:confused:

On a side note the guy who invented the machine that injected the frosting into a Twinkie
lived here in Saint Paul,MN. A real local hero.
Regards
Mike
 

BuGlen

Divergent
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 6, 2012
1,952
3,976
Tampa, Florida
When one considers the processes one has to go through to make your basic Twinkie how
on Earth would one think that e-liquid is a pharmaceutical product? It's as safe,easy and as complicated to make as Kool-Ade.:confused:

On a side note the guy who invented the machine that injected the frosting into a Twinkie
lived here in Saint Paul,MN. A real local hero.
Regards
Mike

I would imagine that there are several chemicals in twinkies that I would not want to inhale for 8 to 10 hours a day in a poorly ventilated enclosed space either. :D
 

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
I would imagine that there are several chemicals in twinkies that I would not want to inhale for 8 to 10 hours a day in a poorly ventilated enclosed space either. :D
I would imagine so also. My point is in the process of manufacturing.
Taking something as easy and inherently safe to make do to the very nature
of the raw materials used and requiring pharmaceutical procedures and equipment
to make it is a waste of money. The raw materials are already made to exacting
standards to be what they are. Virtually no pre-processing is needed. Open some
containers,measure the amounts needed,put them in a large bowl and mix.
Every one keeps freaking out about nicotine. I have handled anhydrous ammonia
and chemicals containing mercury. The handling instructions are on the containers.
Required safety equipment is listed and available from any hardware store.
The only danger in the process is the bigger you get the more automation you
use. Running the automated machinery is more dangerous than the process of
actually making the product. Remember,don't get any on you and,wipe up your
spills.
Regards
Mike
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread