So with all due respect, you need more experience and much more knowledge than what you currently have. Many of us have used 4 - 15 different models and can make a real comparative analysis.
Yes, and that is precisely why I am asking this forum for advice, as my (very positive) experience is only with the Cirrus at this time.
OK - looking at the SI Volt starter kits - to get the 'same' equipment as the Cirrus Weekender must add 1 battery and a carry case to Standard Starter kit for approximate total of $68. I watched a couple reviews, Steeljan says she thinks very little of the cigarette-type, she fully expected to hate the Volt, and now the Volt is her new fave vape. I noted that the Volt lasted about as long as she said in the review her eGo lasts, and the carts lasted her a very long time (for her) and required less juice than she expected to refill. The other review was from a 2 week vaper (deezycakesreviews), and he noted that he really likes it, but also noted that he had trouble with the carto's silicone caps, and his battery stuck on until auto cutoff a couple times. Steeljan addressed the burning issue - not a problem at all, and the voltage issue - steadily at 3.7, and checked the resistance of the cartos - about 2.6 avg. So, it appears that the state of the art has improved, and the shortcomings of the cigarette-type have been addressed. My experience with the Cirrus is very like what she says about the Volt.
It is good to know that those that will insist on a cigarette-type start now have affordable options. You know these people exist. You know there are those that despite being pointed at what you experienced vapers consider to be far better choices, will still go out and buy some inferior rip-off free trial or fleamarket version because it offers them what they think they want. One large plus I noted with the Volt or the Vapor4Life types is that they come in a variety of colors and led colors, not just white with red, and that 'prettiness' or 'coolness' is likely to entice beginners into choosing something that does NOT look JUST like a cigarette, thereby addressing the 'being mistaken for a smoker' issue - mostly.
I think it possible (based on Steeljan's review and comments, and her stated experience) that long time vapers familiar with the known shortcomings of the mini, or cigarette-mimic, PVs, were they to actually try the Volt or newest V4L or even, heaven forbid, a Cirrus, might be pleasantly surprised at what they got out of it; they might even find they like it. Having a
good JLAC (just like a cigarette) model to point stubborn people to might be a GOOD thing, no?
Remember that many smokers have learned great resistance to outside pressure to quit, and when presented with a PV as a way to
quit will find many reasons to resist. However, presented with a 'cigarette' that they can smoke where they can't now, then they can find good reasons to try it. Presented with a
good one, which they then
use, can persuade them that vaping is just as good as their beloved cigarettes, if not (perhaps) a bit better. The no-pressure, smoke all you want and vape all you want method. I know you know it works, and I know you know that some people will only respond to this approach. There are definitely a great many vapers who WANT to quit and who want to know what's better to begin with. But there are others who don't want anything strange or anything fiddly or even anything that sounds like any attempt to get them to quit. It is that class of potential future vaper that I am seeking advice on behalf of. There is a
reason there is a market for the ripoff (and legitimate) JLAC vendors. Denying that market need does not change the members of it into a different market able to be answered by a different product.
p.s. Based on what I saw in the reviews, I'd say my Cirrus is still a bit better in design, but not 4.1 times better, not hardly.