Sorry but my caramel (RY4,Riskee) is absolutely dreamy and my flavor quest ended right there. While I have zero experience with pipe tobaccos no cigarette or cigar can touch the overall pleasant taste of a nice
juice dripped on a clean atomizer.
But your right about taste being subjective. Some are going to want and expect the taste of burnt leaves. But for something to offer so close a smoking experience without the harshness of inhaling actual smoke is a definite positive in my book.
I think it tastes better. I didn't think so back when I had dirty atomizers, burnt cartridges, and few flavors to try. But of course I never thought smoking tasted all that great.
Lorddrek