I experienced the same with PG-nic, turning very dark with a bad smell after 1 1/2 years of freezer storage so before I attempted it again and loaded up my freezer I went in search of answers. One thing was the type of freezer storage, kitchen refrigerator/freezer versus deep freezer that could account for issues and the other was PG versus VG. Did Kurt have a different answer for you on this and change his recommendation?
I was actually trying to remember exactly what he said. It has been a few years lol
Before RTS came along, we were very limited on the choices that we had on where to buy nicotine. The vendor that I bought from may not have had the "cleanest" nicotine. I certainly appreciated RTS nic when they came along. It was the first tasteless, odorless nicotine that I had ever had the opportunity to try. I have been buying my nic here ever since.
It may have been contaminants in the nicotine? I just don't remember. But, I bought a small deep freezer specifically for nicotine several years back. It is stocked with RTS PG based nicotine.
I keep a bottle of PG based from 2010 from a vendor that there was quite a scandal about back in 2010 or 2011. Don't think that I can even mention their name here anymore. But, I take it out every now and then just to test. So far, so good.
I have the utmost respect for Kurt though. He tought me everything that I know about nicotine and how to handle/store it. He is usually very kind and very helpful. If you have a question, you may want to PM him and ask. I know that he stays pretty busy and it may take a bit to get an answer but, I feel certain that he will.
I do understand wanting to do your research before investing in any to store though. I have no clue if I am scientifically right or wrong. I only know that the one bad experience with freezing VG nic was bad enough to turn me against it for long term storage for good.