BT is NOT Trying to Kill Vaping

Status
Not open for further replies.

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,623
1
84,748
So-Cal
The contaminated THC cartridges sold were purportedly "closed system" as the end user was not supposed to be able to reuse those cartridges.


I have had chipped ink jet cartridges refilled. The chips can be reset, the printer can be reset to accept the cartridge, or you can replace the chip yourself. You can buy empty inkjet cartridges with chips to fill yourself on eBay.

Keurig attempted to set up a code system to prevent refillable pods that was easily defeated.

Just as those THC cartridges came prefilled, no closed system can be considered secure from refill or tampering.

I'm Not talking about some Wink-Wink Nod "Closed System" where all you have to do is go to the ECF or YouTube to find out how to Refill it.

I'm talking about Ultrasonic Welded, Jump thru the Highest Hoop like your PMTA Depends on it (because it Does), Satisfy Mitch Zeller type Unadaulterable Closed System.

Same with mod and Pod Chip pair. This Isn't going to be some Clear Text EPROM that has no Fall Pack if it isn't Paired with the mod. It's gunna be 256bit AES Government Grade, take IBM Watsom a Week to Crack it, type stuff.

Because Once Again, your PMTA is going to Depend on it.

LOL

I have 100% Confidence that when the Full Power of BT's Technology Army is exerted into making something Closed, it is Going to Stay Closed to 99.999% of those who used it.

:)
 

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,623
1
84,748
So-Cal
...

Didn't someone in leadership in the FDA back then specifically say they were expecting only a small number of manufacturers to make it through the application process?

I have heard it mentioned by the FDA a Couple of Times in that they Fully Expects a Reduction in "Stakeholders" due to Inability to Satisfy PMTA Cost/Requirements.
 

bombastinator

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 12, 2010
13,338
26,535
MN USA
The contaminated THC cartridges sold were purportedly "closed system" as the end user was not supposed to be able to reuse those cartridges.
heh. We all know how to refill an empty “one use” cartridge. It IS often a serious pain though. There are maybe only a few cartridges that actually can’t be refilled.
There’s also the super duper single use fountain pen style ones that have no opening at all and have to be pierced. Those generally aren’t used for e-cigarettes. China busted that one wide open though online with cartridge machines.
I have had chipped ink jet cartridges refilled. The chips can be reset, the printer can be reset to accept the cartridge, or you can replace the chip yourself. You can buy empty inkjet cartridges with chips to fill yourself on eBay.
yeah the whole “printer ink is three times more expensive than gold” thing got blown up years ago. Cannon was a big player. They started selling machines that took any ink. It mostly fell apart after that.
Keurig attempted to set up a code system to prevent refillable pods that was easily defeated.
I would go with “eventually” but yeah, they busted it. You can buy keurig compatible baskets now where the tops snap off
Just as those THC cartridges came prefilled, no closed system can be considered secure from refill or tampering.
Mmmmm.... depends. You can’t stop it, but you can make it visible if it’s been done. Takes serious tech though and it’s not cheap. You can also make cartridges that are really hard to fake. That one is even harder. More or less requires international cooperation.

Both are going to be a continuing battle. Like counterfeit money, and Neither one appears to have been accomplished yet in the case of cartridges though.

There was some serious “DERP!” going on when people though they could take a ten cent piece of plastic they got off alibaba and no one else would dare to turn it into a fake of a $50 one.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Blitzdonlife

Tabac man

Super Member
ECF Veteran
May 24, 2019
948
3,597
London
I have some experience printing counterfeit money.

counterfit-money-scam.jpg
 

Eskie

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 6, 2016
16,087
77,744
NY
heh. We all know how to refill an empty “one use” cartridge. It IS often a serious pain though. There are maybe only a few cartridges that actually can’t be refilled.
There’s also the super duper single use fountain pen style ones that have no opening at all and have to be pierced. Those generally aren’t used for e-cigarettes. China busted that one wide open though online with cartridge machines.
yeah the whole “printer ink is three times more expensive than gold” thing got blown up years ago. Cannon was a big player. They started selling machines that took any ink. It mostly fell apart after that.
I would go with “eventually” but yeah, they busted it. You can buy keurig compatible baskets now where the tops snap off

Mmmmm.... depends. You can’t stop it, but you can make it visible if it’s been done. Takes serious tech though and it’s not cheap. You can also make cartridges that are really hard to fake. That one is even harder. More or less requires international cooperation.

Both are going to be a continuing battle. Like counterfeit money, and Neither one appears to have been accomplished yet in the case of cartridges though.

There was some serious “DERP!” going on when people though they could take a ten cent piece of plastic they got off alibaba and no one else would dare to turn it into a fake of a $50 one.

Where do you think those THC "authentic" Dang Kang (or whatever that premium THC brand name is/was) came from? Do you really think there is no industrial base in China to turn out perfect clones of closed system pods that come empty all set for you to fill with whatever you want? Betcha the Juul plant can provide a whole bunch in after hours runs alone.

Picture what can really happen when teens start buying what they think are Juul pods, not the contaminated illegal drug ones, believing they're just nicotine and they're not. That's what is so damn upsetting about this attempt to regulate to win political points disregarding the consequences. Now there will be dead kids who just wanted a nic buzz. You shouldn't die from getting some THC stuff but we're kinda used to bad things happening with illegal drug use. Just look a fentanyl getting into everything, even drugs not supposed to be opiates. But when kids die from a Juul pod they got because all they wanted was mango is a travesty and will happen thanks to this insanity. And there is no tamper resistant system that exists to date that will prevent that.

At least one thing Trump got right is getting counterfeits off the street. Maybe if we stick with common sense stuff like that, even if it's only for the THC crowd, something positive might happen. But the black market that's going to pop up won't be for the e juice we use. It'll be those little pods the kids are already used to and still have easy access to the battery part because the tobacco ones will still be widely available. And those are the most likely to end up with contaminants in them.

This isn't just about follow the money. It's about following the money while those bought for turn a blind eye to the lesson that should have been learned with the THC outbreak. The next round will be a lot worse, and the blood will be on their hands.
 

Blitzdonlife

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 24, 2012
2,370
14,928
Central Texas
Where do you think those THC "authentic" Dang Kang (or whatever that premium THC brand name is/was) came from? Do you really think there is no industrial base in China to turn out perfect clones of closed system pods that come empty all set for you to fill with whatever you want? Betcha the Juul plant can provide a whole bunch in after hours runs alone.

Picture what can really happen when teens start buying what they think are Juul pods, not the contaminated illegal drug ones, believing they're just nicotine and they're not. That's what is so damn upsetting about this attempt to regulate to win political points disregarding the consequences. Now there will be dead kids who just wanted a nic buzz. You shouldn't die from getting some THC stuff but we're kinda used to bad things happening with illegal drug use. Just look a fentanyl getting into everything, even drugs not supposed to be opiates. But when kids die from a Juul pod they got because all they wanted was mango is a travesty and will happen thanks to this insanity. And there is no tamper resistant system that exists to date that will prevent that.

At least one thing Trump got right is getting counterfeits off the street. Maybe if we stick with common sense stuff like that, even if it's only for the THC crowd, something positive might happen. But the black market that's going to pop up won't be for the e juice we use. It'll be those little pods the kids are already used to and still have easy access to the battery part because the tobacco ones will still be widely available. And those are the most likely to end up with contaminants in them.

This isn't just about follow the money. It's about following the money while those bought for turn a blind eye to the lesson that should have been learned with the THC outbreak. The next round will be a lot worse, and the blood will be on their hands.
I agree with everything you said, but I just wanted to add one thing. Even though the blood will be on their hands, the blame will be placed on e-cigarettes. Don't expect the murderers to take credit for their victims.
 

Vapindave85

New Member
Sep 5, 2019
3
6
As screwed up as our government is I just can't buy into this conspiracy theory about the FDA being in cahoots with big tobacco.
If you look into how the FDA was created it was basically funded by BT to begin with. When the vaping industry started to boom around 2013 BT showed huge revenue and profit loss. “Coincidentally” the FDA also had the same problem and is following a very similar trend money wise as BT. Also no one is talking about the 300% tariff tax trump was going to instate on China, where the majority of vaping hardware products come from, you really think that these tariffs are not targeted at vaping and raising the cost so high it is no longer worth buying them. With those tariffs that high a Smok nord would be damn near dna chip mods prices currently. After Trump announced the proposed executive order to ban flavored e liquids within a couple days he stated he is willing to sit down and renegotiate the tariffs on China and there are plans for meeting and I would bet the they come to a new trade agreement. If those tariffs went through it would tank our economy, almost everything purchased from amazon and Walmart (2 of the biggest suppliers of products in the USA to consumers) they would lose so much business because people couldn’t afford to buy much extra if anything except the essentials. The info structure of country and economy is not equipped to do the industrial era again and our economy would tank. The unemployment rates would sky rocket and impoverished people would be the largest class of people in our country. Also the Commissioner of the FDA Gottlieb who was open minded to vaping and keeping it alive and researching and actually finding out if it was a safe alternative was pushed out the day or 2 after the executive order announcement. We are coming up in an election year I do not believe Trump will kill the vaping industry directly, but the new commissioner of the FDA will be testifying today or tomorrow about how bad vaping is and what an epidemic it is and that it needs to be stopped. If you believe this is all coincidence than you do. I Have been vaping for almost 10 years with Rebuildable devices and that is what got me away from smoking. I also worked in the vape industry and ran 12 stores, the warehouse that supplied those stores, ordered all of the products from China, ran the wholesale business for the company and also their online business for 4 years. I still have and communicate with friends I have made in China in the ecigs industry and they have told me that if the tariffs went that high it would be unrealistic to sell their devices in the States. Another sign pointing to this being the government and BT and all about the money is that they just announced today 9-25-19 that they are looking at and considering not only banning flavored juices but the sale of all vaping related products. They know if they take away juice people will make their own. I already do and have for years I have helped set up an ISO8 lab when the FDA rolled out the first set of regulations a few years back. If you don’t believe that the our wonderful government and BT would work together to kill the vaping industry I would i courage you to do some research. There are an estimate 10-15 million adult vapors in American and there have been less than 600 cases of health problems that they are claiming is vaping which is not true to start with. BT kills roughly 1300 people daily from smoking combustible cigarettes, my question is why is the FDA and our government not concerned more with killing BT with these band as well? Cigarettes are linked to more deaths daily than have been linked to proper vaping devices and juices in the past 5 years. I don’t believe this has anything to do with public health and saving our children. I started smoking cigarettes and chewing tobacco when I was 14 years old. I spent over 20 bucks a day a decade ago on BT products, that is why BT wants the vaping industry gone. They may have invested hundreds of millions on their own devices, but that is a drop in the bucket and worth losing and giving up to make the billions back a year that would come back to them from the vape industry being gone. In turn the FDA would them be receive a lot more money as well.
 
Last edited:

Opinionated

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 19, 2015
11,168
59,365
56
My Mountain
Where do you think those THC "authentic" Dang Kang (or whatever that premium THC brand name is/was) came from? Do you really think there is no industrial base in China to turn out perfect clones of closed system pods that come empty all set for you to fill with whatever you want? Betcha the Juul plant can provide a whole bunch in after hours runs alone.

Picture what can really happen when teens start buying what they think are Juul pods, not the contaminated illegal drug ones, believing they're just nicotine and they're not. That's what is so damn upsetting about this attempt to regulate to win political points disregarding the consequences. Now there will be dead kids who just wanted a nic buzz. You shouldn't die from getting some THC stuff but we're kinda used to bad things happening with illegal drug use. Just look a fentanyl getting into everything, even drugs not supposed to be opiates. But when kids die from a Juul pod they got because all they wanted was mango is a travesty and will happen thanks to this insanity. And there is no tamper resistant system that exists to date that will prevent that.

At least one thing Trump got right is getting counterfeits off the street. Maybe if we stick with common sense stuff like that, even if it's only for the THC crowd, something positive might happen. But the black market that's going to pop up won't be for the e juice we use. It'll be those little pods the kids are already used to and still have easy access to the battery part because the tobacco ones will still be widely available. And those are the most likely to end up with contaminants in them.

This isn't just about follow the money. It's about following the money while those bought for turn a blind eye to the lesson that should have been learned with the THC outbreak. The next round will be a lot worse, and the blood will be on their hands.

Did you hear Mississippi authorities found 3 of those pods to contain fentanyl?

I found that crazy.. seems they are putting crazy stuff in this CBD and THC pods..

Investigation finds illegal synthetic marijuana in vape and edible products sold as CBD
 

Eskie

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 6, 2016
16,087
77,744
NY
Did you hear Mississippi authorities found 3 of those pods to contain fentanyl?

I found that crazy.. seems they are putting crazy stuff in this CBD and THC pods..

Investigation finds illegal synthetic marijuana in vape and edible products sold as CBD

Spiking both CBD and THC with synthetics like K2 is well known, but these are among the first reports of fentanyl getting dumped in as well that I'm aware of. The street drug market has never been known for great quality control. You can find amphetamines sold as ........ And of course the opiate/fentanyl connection with overdoses on every street corner.

I think one of the problems the CDC and health departments face with the latest respiratory outbreak is that there may be far more contaminants/adulterants than just vitamin E showing up. While Vitamin E still tops my list, I'd be concerned if there are other chemicals in there that might cause similar lung problems and even specific interactions to get just the right mix to cause the inflammatory response. But calling it on the THC cartridges seems pretty fair at this point, but knowing exactly what's in them doing this may take a little more time.

This whole outbreak is a law enforcement problem. There was a recent spate of deaths among ....... users in the NY area. They still don't know what the ....... was contaminated with, but they at least know the substance and are looking for the dealers. I wish they were doing the same with the THC sellers.

(I wonder how much of the above will be dotted out by the potty mouth filter. OK, not terrible, the white stuff people like to sniff through $100 bills still seems to be on the list)
 

bombastinator

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 12, 2010
13,338
26,535
MN USA
If you look into how the FDA was created it was basically funded by BT to begin with.
does not imply a favor owed. Also the very beginnings of the FDA was the “poison squad” which was a long long time ago. There is then and there is now
When the vaping industry started to boom around 2013 BT showed huge revenue and profit loss.
implying they wouldn’t like vaping much
“Coincidentally” the FDA also had the same problem and is following a very similar trend money wise as BT.
Your quotes imply it is not a coincidence. I’m not sure that is true. that had to do not with BT but with tax cuts for the rich and subsequent underfunding of infrastructure. So far as I can see the two are not tied in reality
Also no one is talking about the 300% tariff tax trump was going to instate on China,
of course not. Like much of what he says it didn’t actually happen.
where the majority of vaping hardware products come from, you really think that these tariffs are not targeted at vaping and raising the cost so high it is no longer worth buying them.
tariffs that don’t even exist? Yes. Also they’re not an “are” I honestly don’t think vaping was a primary focus of foreign policy. I don’t think it is even now for government anyway. For BT though yes, and BT has money to influence various governments. Vaping may be the center of OUR world but it doesn’t make it the center of THE world.
With those tariffs that high a Smok nord would be damn near dna chip mods prices currently. After Trump announced the proposed executive order to ban flavored e liquids within a couple days he stated he is willing to sit down and renegotiate the tariffs on China and there are plans for meeting and I would bet the they come to a new trade agreement. If those tariffs went through it would tank our economy, almost everything purchased from amazon and Walmart (2 of the biggest suppliers of products in the USA to consumers) they would lose so much business because people couldn’t afford to buy much extra if anything except the essentials. The info structure of country and economy is not equipped to do the industrial era again and our economy would tank. The unemployment rates would sky rocket and impoverished people would be the largest class of people in our country.
I agree that Trumps proposed policies often have horrific future ramifications
Also the Commissioner of the FDA Gottlieb who was open minded to vaping and keeping it alive and researching and actually finding out if it was a safe alternative was pushed out the day or 2 after the executive order announcement.
pushed or not pushed. Also pushed by whom? No one knows. Enticed is a possibility as well.
We are coming up in an election year I do not believe Trump will kill the vaping industry directly, but the new commissioner of the FDA will be testifying today or tomorrow about how bad vaping is and what an epidemic it is and that it needs to be stopped.
a truly possible prediction. Not a hard guess either.
If you believe this is all coincidence than you do.
I don’t completely. Pieces may be, pieces may not be. Pointing to an actual culprit though is harder. BT is a prime candidate though.
I Have been vaping for almost 10 years with Rebuildable devices and that is what got me away from smoking. I also worked in the vape industry and ran 12 stores, the warehouse that supplied those stores, ordered all of the products from China, ran the wholesale business for the company and also their online business for 4 years. I still have and communicate with friends I have made in China in the ecigs industry and they have told me that if the tariffs went that high it would be unrealistic to sell their devices in the States. Another sign pointing to this being the government and BT and all about the money is that they just announced today 9-25-19 that they are looking at and considering not only banning flavored juices but the sale of all vaping related products.
I do agree it’s all about the money. Nothing can move without money except individuals and they have little power. Controlling the money controls all.
They know if they take away juice people will make their own.
a few will. Most wont, if for no other reason because they don’t know how. It’s common knowledge here, but here is here. This is a tiny fraction of a tiny fraction of people. Most people have lives to lead and have little time for such stuff. Smoking cigarettes is likely their only option.
I already do and have for years I have helped set up an ISO8 lab when the FDA rolled out the first set of regulations a few years back. If you don’t believe that the our wonderful government and BT would work together to kill the vaping industry I would i courage you to do some research. There are an estimate 10-15 million adult vapors in American and there have been less than 600 cases of health problems that they are claiming is vaping which is not true to start with. BT kills roughly 1300 people daily from smoking combustible cigarettes, my question is why is the FDA and our government not concerned more with killing BT with these band as well? Cigarettes are linked to more deaths daily than have been linked to proper vaping devices and juices in the past 5 years. I don’t believe this has anything to do with public health and saving our children. I started smoking cigarettes and chewing tobacco when I was 14 years old. I spent over 20 bucks a day a decade ago on BT products, that is why BT wants the vaping industry gone. They may have invested hundreds of millions on their own devices, but that is a drop in the bucket and worth losing and giving up to make the billions back a year that would come back to them from the vape industry being gone. In turn the FDA would them be receive a lot more money as well.

It does imply a lot of BS and a lack of true concern for public health.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Opinionated

wetclay

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 4, 2010
444
956
UAE
You're way out of the loop.

No flavored vapes means many vapers will go back to smoking.
Agreed.
Honestly speaking, I enjoyed smoking and never had any intention of quitting. But when a safer alternative came along, I made the switch. Was a no brainer.
I hate to admit it, but if I can't get my vape, I will probably go back to smoking. And I don't think I will be alone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Opinionated

440BB

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 19, 2011
9,227
34,009
The Motor City
Agreed.
Honestly speaking, I enjoyed smoking and never had any intention of quitting. But when a safer alternative came along, I made the switch. Was a no brainer.
I hate to admit it, but if I can't get my vape, I will probably go back to smoking. And I don't think I will be alone.
I'm sorry to hear that and I agree. There will be many US vapers reverting to cigarettes. Most know little about what we here on ECF consider common knowledge and won't have a game plan to take care of their supplies. Hopefully most of the rest of the world can continue to use vaping to keep off the smokes. We'll see how far the dishonest propaganda travels.
 

wetclay

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 4, 2010
444
956
UAE
I'm sorry to hear that and I agree. There will be many US vapers reverting to cigarettes. Most know little about what we here on ECF consider common knowledge and won't have a game plan to take care of their supplies. Hopefully most of the rest of the world can continue to use vaping to keep off the smokes. We'll see how far the dishonest propaganda travels.
Most likely this hysteria will spillover the rest of the world soon. Vaping was only legalized here few months ago only, new vendors are popping out every week and the number of vapers is growing exponentially. Would be sad if we need to go underground again.
Luckily, I'm well stocked and prepared for the worst. One more liter of nicotine won't harm though.
 

bombastinator

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 12, 2010
13,338
26,535
MN USA
Most likely this hysteria will spillover the rest of the world soon. Vaping was only legalized here few months ago only, new vendors are popping out every week and the number of vapers is growing exponentially. Would be sad if we need to go underground again.
Luckily, I'm well stocked and prepared for the worst. One more liter of nicotine won't harm though.
Truth will out eventually. The amount of time it takes to happen has been growing though. It was safe for 10 years then suddenly it’s not at the exact same time it got conflated with Other things people started putting stuff in it that it was long known should not be put in it.

The science is no surprise in retrospect. The lying is, though perhaps it shouldn’t have been. The trick is going to be getting good quality nic and making sure the product isn’t adulterated with stuff that can hurt people.
 

bombastinator

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 12, 2010
13,338
26,535
MN USA
Yes, they are. When this is over those who don't know any better will have two choices.

These...
cigarette.jpg


...and these.

IQOS_24P_Kit_Slt_400x400-sep.png
So horrible or somewhat but only a bit less horrible but prices even higher. And you still can’t smoke only a little and you still can’t titrate nicotine down. No thankyou. Both are worse than I can handle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ruet

Katcandoo

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 4, 2013
585
1,582
Georgia , USA
The government officials don't care about public health. It's about money, control, and graft. The US States sued big tobacco in the 90s and received multi millions in settlements to be used for smoking cessation programs. (It wasn't.) The millions that came into my state from the tobacco settlement were used for a now defunct program to rehab/renovate multiple homes in run down neighborhoods. Still not sure how that addresses smoking cessation. The catch was the homeowners could only choose a handful of state approved contractors (one contractor was the brother of a government employee involved in administering the program and had their home renovated), and a lien placed on the house so if/when the house sold, the state got back the $30k in repairs. We spent years settling shoddy contractor claims (and one alleged rape).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread