Can we talk PG and VG ?

Status
Not open for further replies.

BrotherBob

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Dec 24, 2014
14,118
12,449
Sunnyvale,CA,USA
So, just want to ask a few questions. Maybe some will get better info than I pursued prior to "looking for best price".
How many PG and VG Manufacturers are there ? --------I suspect there are quite a few, most outside the US.
What Grade should you look for ? ----------------USP
Who makes a smoother base ? Or a sweeter base ? -------------- Might check into VG main veg. used (whether it be olives, palm trees,coconut oil, soy,etc. products). Would not be surprised that the USP grading may have taken the taste and/or sense of smoothness out of the equation.
Can you get Quality and Price ?
---------- I try to save on the shipping. WL used to have free shipping if you have an order of $xx or more.
 

PapawBrett

Retired
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 16, 2012
8,761
66,518
Monroe NC
Here is some reading material for you. Your talking about having coughing issues so all this is important.

First, the sticky:

Purity of PG, VG and PEG - The Short Version

And discussion of pharmaceutical grade:

Buying ingredients around town?

And I can't find the other link at the current moment.. Will post when I get to it.

One more link: PG/VG labeling and purity: Please read!


I have edited my first post and added back two of the three links. I cannot manage to find that third link, and I'm having tons of problems with my browser history. So those two will have to suffice for now..

To reiterate what I had said.. if your having breathing or coughing difficulties now, it might be because what your inhaling is food grade, and there is pharmaceutical grade.

The best grade is something that is difficult for anyone but a manufacturer to obtain, and that is a synthetic pharmaceutical grade. (Which is called Dow Optim)

I'll post those two links here too, so you don't have to look up again. :)

First, the sticky:

Purity of PG, VG and PEG - The Short Version

And discussion of pharmaceutical grade

Buying ingredients around town?

Now this is the information I was hoping you would put back in the thread !
As far as triple posts, we've all been there....
 

Opinionated

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 19, 2015
11,168
59,365
56
My Mountain
Now this is the information I was hoping you would put back in the thread !
As far as triple posts, we've all been there....

Ah.. your welcome. You know when sometimes you will post a thing and then others start posting in a different direction then you second guess your answer after reading the OP a second time? Yeah.. I do that sometimes.. :)
 

DaveP

PV Master & Musician
ECF Veteran
May 22, 2010
16,733
42,646
Central GA
After researching cost and finding out that I can get Essential Depot PG and VG in gallons from Amazon for around $28 vs a quart for $13 it's a no brainer. Both are Prime, so no shipping charge.

OTOH, Bulk Apothecary price is about $10 cheaper per gallon. The shipping for 2 gallons of PG and 1 gallon of VG is $13.55. It's still cheaper than Amazon by a long shot. $69 Bulk Apothecary including shipping vs $85 Amazon (w/ free 2 day shipping). That's for 2 gallons of PG and 1 gallon of VG.

One order would last me way over a year. I've been through several quarts each of PG and VG in almost a year and still have 2 PG and 1 VG left unopened.
 
Last edited:

JC Okie

REOnaut
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 2, 2010
6,511
17,814
Tulsa, OK
I've used Essential Depot (like it,) MFS (like it,) NOW brand from Akins health food store locally (like it but it's expensive,) and Walmart (like it fine but it's expensive.) I've been DIYing for years and years (6+) so I can't remember what store-bought juice even tastes like. I can't tell any difference it the taste of any of the different VGs. I have a gallon of PG that I got at Southern Agriculture (locally) that has lasted me for years since I use little to none in my mixes.
 

JCinFLA

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2015
9,392
44,575
OTOH, Bulk Apothecary price is about $10 cheaper per gallon. The shipping for 2 gallons of PG and 1 gallon of VG is $13.55. It's still cheaper than Amazon by a long shot. $69 Bulk Apothecary including shipping vs $85 Amazon (w/ free 2 day shipping). That's for 2 gallons of PG and 1 gallon of VG.

That $16 difference is why I've been talking about the cost savings realized by going with BA, compared to ED...for about the last year at least. I wouldn't have been doing that though, if the quality wasn't great IMO, but it is!

With that $16 saved...you could buy another tank or 2, or some more boxes of coils, or several roles of wire, or 2 4oz. bottles of some flavorings, etc.!
:thumbs:
 

DaveP

PV Master & Musician
ECF Veteran
May 22, 2010
16,733
42,646
Central GA
I hadn't checked out BA before, always was with ED. May just have to give BA a shot next order, hey 16 bucks is 16 bucks!

$16 is about 3 rolls of coil wire or 3 new 18650's if you shop right. ( Carrying on JC's analysis).
 

Andromendous

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 12, 2014
406
405
Oklahoma, USA
I have edited my first post and added back two of the three links. I cannot manage to find that third link, and I'm having tons of problems with my browser history. So those two will have to suffice for now..

To reiterate what I had said.. if your having breathing or coughing difficulties now, it might be because what your inhaling is food grade, and there is pharmaceutical grade.

The best grade is something that is difficult for anyone but a manufacturer to obtain, and that is a synthetic pharmaceutical grade. (Which is called Dow Optim)

I'll post those two links here too, so you don't have to look up again. :)

First, the sticky:

Purity of PG, VG and PEG - The Short Version

And discussion of pharmaceutical grade

Buying ingredients around town?

Interesting information, This made me curious about the VG/PG I use, I order from wizard labs, this is posted on their VG page

Minimum 99.7% purity USP grade Kosher certified Vegetable Glycerin suitable for use as a carrier base and dilutant for Wizard Labs organic Nicotine solutions. The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued a warning concerning glycerin produced from the Jatropha plant which can contain toxins, including phorbol esters, that naturally occur in the plant. All of our vegetable-derived glycerin is 100% sourced from palm fruit, and does not contain any Jatropha plant or derivatives.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread