Cartomizer vs Atomizer

Status
Not open for further replies.

tj99959

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
  • Aug 13, 2011
    15,116
    39,600
    utah
    Ya, pretty much, except you will normally scorch the batting in a carto making it unvapable before you blow the coil.
    Don't know where you got the 1.8amp figure tho. They will both do fine between 2 & 3 amps. Unless dry burning for to long.
    I use 1.5ohm atties on a 650mAh bat a lot.

    Now all batteries have their own internal amp limit, that is why many like larger mAh batteries. A little 180mAh battery can't produce the amps necessary to drive a 1.7ohm carto, so fresh of the charger it would only be about 3.0v under that load.
     
    Last edited:

    AttyPops

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Jul 8, 2010
    8,708
    134,323
    Hc Svnt Dracones - USA EST
    They say not to go under 2 ohms on the egos because their MOSFET isn't rated for the current draw. I used 1.5ohm attys on my ego for a long time.

    Yeah, I used to say that too. Users complained a lot about fried eGo units with 1.5 LR stuff. Then, some vendors piped in and said that it isn't as much of a problem anymore (a design change?) and/or what really did the nasty trick was to have an atty/carto short out when if fried... killing the mosfet in the process. Who knows. I gave up on the whole discussion, for the most part. Hell, they're so cheap these days anyway (lots of sales) that if you have backups/spares you should just "vape happy" and do what works for you.... unless the manufacturer says otherwise.

    If the 2.0 ohm stuff works, or even 1.7, vs the 1.5 then I'd go with the higher ohms just knowing I wasn't stressing it as much. But that's me.

    As to the OP's question... really varies by device. Lots of coil designs and tolerances. An atty coil is often a completely different design than a carto coil. Although ohms are ohms from the battery's perspective, that not to say amps are amps from the coil's perspective. A 2.0 ohm atty coil may very well hold up better than a 2.0 ohm carto coil to the same amps. However, the device you use them on, and the ohm rating, are usually matched such that it is within tolerance for the coil. Design differences in the coil would count in theory. However, ohms plays a big part in determining the amps.

    I think it's more of a robustness of design issue for the particular atty/coil than anything else.
     
    Last edited:

    fray

    Unregistered Supplier
    ECF Veteran
    Jan 13, 2011
    1,555
    518
    arkansas
    www.ejoose.com
    Yeah, I used to say that too. Users complained a lot about fried eGo units with 1.5 LR stuff. Then, some vendors piped in and said that it isn't as much of a problem anymore (a design change?) and/or what really did the nasty trick was to have an atty/carto short out when if fried... killing the mosfet in the process. Who knows. I gave up on the whole discussion, for the most part. Hell, they're so cheap these days anyway (lots of sales) that if you have backups/spares you should just "vape happy" and do what works for you.... unless the manufacturer says otherwise.

    If the 2.0 ohm stuff works, or even 1.7, vs the 1.5 then I'd go with the higher ohms just knowing I wasn't stressing it as much. But that's me.

    As to the OP's question... really varies by device. Lots of coil designs and tolerances. An atty coil is often a completely different design than a carto coil. Although ohms are ohms from the battery's perspective, that not to say amps are amps from the coil's perspective. A 2.0 ohm atty coil may very well hold up better than a 2.0 ohm carto coil to the same amps. However, the device you use them on, and the ohm rating, are usually matched such that it is within tolerance for the coil. Design differences in the coil would count in theory. However, ohms plays a big part in determining the amps.

    I think it's more of a robustness of design issue for the particular atty/coil than anything else.

    Maybe the 2 ohm thing was to discourage people who fried their batteries on 1.5ohms for asking for a new replacement. idk
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Users who are viewing this thread