I've been reading Dr. F and you know, his research his excellent, but I have to admit, this letter almost had me in *tears*
"A decision to ban electronic cigarettes will represent nothing more than a great opportunity missed": letter to Hong Kong officials
Especially this part: Instead of punishing smokers for the inability of medicine to develop effective smoking-cessation medications, it seems reasonable, and is also our ethical responsibility, to provide them with less harmful alternative products. This is not just an issue of personal choice; it is also about protecting their human right of being properly informed and making decisions that will protect
personal health from the consequences derived from a harmful addictive habit. Smokers should be treated with sympathy and compassion. It is true that nicotine addictiveness may not be resolved by switching from tobacco cigarettes to electronic cigarette use. However, the main purpose of public health is to reduce harm and death. It is not our responsibility or right to dictate people not to use nicotine, considering that nicotine has minimal effects on smoking-related morbidity and mortality.
I mean, how many researchers have this mindset? Not that many. I can't tell you the number of times I've been lectured and harried over my smoking habit by family members, doctors, and others. Not even deliberately, but you can see it in their face(s) sometimes. I have really great docs that have treated me over the past 12 years and I know so many of them really care about me, and were dismayed to see my rapid downhill trajectory. Not one of them felt as if they could "recommend" vaping. So many people view smoking as a moral failing instead of THE MOST deadly addiction on earth and it's either all moralizing about willpower and personal choice, when addiction is quite often NOT a personal choice. I started at 18, I was really DUMB. If vaping hadn't happened along, I wouldn't have been able to cold turkey smoking, I'm certain. And, I've been ashamed of this addiction for such a long time, personally, that to run into someone objective in the Public Health field with this mindset, and who encourages it in others, is a beautiful thing. Also, not to boast or anything but I found smoking harder to manage than ANY other addiction, and I've battled and resolved a few in my day. I'd take ANY other detox than smoking, even using vape. It's HARD.
When I got to this letter, DeAnna, I understood why you are so devoted to Dr. F. He sounds like an incredible researcher and *person* whose interest is in nothing more than improving Public Health, which we
should do for smokers really more than anyone else. Highest morbidity of all addictions, though the OD rate in Baltimore is getting so bad, they are handing out free Naltrexone injections to anyone who wants one, in order to reduce the OD mortality rate.
No one handed me a free ecig with instructions on how to use it the WHOLE time I was smoking. And I can honestly say I'd prefer an OD on ANY substance than dying of COPD and smoking has the highest morbidity of all if you can't stop. And I can genuinely say I have TRIED, countless times, and failed.
Anna