Diacetyl Free - Does it Matter?

Status
Not open for further replies.

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
Yes $200 is nothing for those that are using a ISO certified lab....again, I personally don't really buy from "local" place b/c of the mentioned cases I talked about....Yes, if you have 200 "house blends" then testing them will be expensive....if you have 2 to 5 flavors, testing them shouldn't be that big of a deal
$200 dollars is something when you work hard for it. One would need a
lot of $200's to pay for that ISO certified lab. Which by the way they are
using to make a product that is as easy and safe to make as Kool Aid.
Regards
Mike
 

Jman8

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jan 15, 2013
6,419
12,928
Wisconsin
Yes $200 is nothing for those that are using a ISO certified lab....again, I personally don't really buy from "local" place b/c of the mentioned cases I talked about....Yes, if you have 200 "house blends" then testing them will be expensive....if you have 2 to 5 flavors, testing them shouldn't be that big of a deal

Wouldn't the same thing be true for personal testing? If you only have one flavor that you absolutely love and can't live without, and it only costs $200 for 'peace of mind' then please explain to me why you wouldn't do the test yourself?

But if you are on tight budget, and love about 50 flavors, then I can very much see why you wouldn't want to spend the $10,000 to do your own testing, even while it WOULD be in your best interest.

I don't think the vendor selling 3 flavors, unless they are considered best in the business, is making lots of money.

Even then, if testing requires all batches and variations to be paid for, then it isn't just $200. Already covered the PG-VG thing earlier, but say a vendor did test 6 months ago and it legitimately showed they are at ND levels for DA/AP. And they announce a new batch on same recipe and have only made minute adjustment. Then some scientific type person says that new ingredient has been linked to increased levels of DA. The vendor shows credible scientific study that says no it has not. Who's right? I'm guessing the concerned DA consumer will say test it again. And again if something else (regardless of how tiny that something else is) changes.

So the vendor that sells no variation in their liquid, never changes their recipe and offers 5 flavors is making lots of money and could afford the $1000 cost. And it is totally righteous for them to think they need to test for something that hasn't been correlated with harm to vapers. But also totally righteous for highly concerned vapers to never ever do their own testing and put all their faith in a vendor.

I'm sure somewhere that makes sense, in crazy-ville.
 

sparkky1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 8, 2014
3,429
2,686
Nashville
So are you anti-vaping, or.. What are you even saying here?

My argument is for harm reduction. Is your argument that we should go back to smoking, because at least the long-term effects are known?

Then how do "you" make inhaling artificial flavoring less harmful ? switch out one or two compounds for another and call it harm reduction ?
Would you not agree cutting out over 3000 compounds completely would be considered harm reduction ?
 

nyiddle

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 9, 2014
2,826
2,692
USA. State: Inebriated.
I vape unflavored (primarily). I do whatever I can towards harm reduction. That was why I got into vaping in the first place. Maybe other people did it for the clouds, or for the fun flavors, or whatever your prerogative is. Not me. Any potential risk, in regards to vaping, that can be avoided, I will take.

Do I still drink alcohol? Yes. Do I still breathe city air? Yes. Do I still drink tap water? Yes. Does any of that justify vaping diketones? Nope. We know the risks of those things. Diketones? Nope.

I'm done here, this thread is going in circles. If you care to be incensed by more of my "ANTZ" propaganda you can check the other diketones threads, virtually all of which I've voiced my opinion in. Numerous times. And so have most of you.
 

Gauntlgrym

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 25, 2013
420
682
OH
  • Like
Reactions: Rossum

Gauntlgrym

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 25, 2013
420
682
OH
I have no idea (still) what are the answers to some important questions about diacetyl

for example:
1: Is diacetyl something added in, like an option ?
YES! Diacetyl and AP don't NEED to be in liquid. it is an option.

I get the impression that it is no some additive, but instead either a part of some flavorings;

it is a part of SOME flavorings, but those flavorings with D/AP don't NEED to be used.

2: is diacetyl something produced in mixing ?? Sometimes it sounds like the juice makers don't actually put diacetyl in their juice, but it ends up being there

sometimes is can be produced when mixing different flavorings, but the chances of you getting detectable levels of D/AP while using nothing but D/AP free flavorings....is very rare.

The only thing that seems to be fairly certain is the diacetyl issue has something to do with flavorings, so for starters, anybody who wants to avoid it can just use unflavored

yes, vaping unflavored would avoid D/AP. if you like the taste of unflavored, then go for it. unflavored is SUPER CHEAP too.[/quote][/QUOTE]
 

AzPlumber

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 28, 2011
5,051
9,789
Arizona
Do I still drink alcohol? Yes. Do I still breathe city air? Yes. Do I still drink tap water? Yes. Does any of that justify vaping diketones? Nope. We know the risks of those things. Diketones? Nope.

So, you've decided that a certain amount of alcohol is okay even though it causes death by liver disease.
 

sparkky1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 8, 2014
3,429
2,686
Nashville
I vape unflavored (primarily). I do whatever I can towards harm reduction. That was why I got into vaping in the first place. Maybe other people did it for the clouds, or for the fun flavors, or whatever your prerogative is. Not me. Any potential risk, in regards to vaping, that can be avoided, I will take.

Do I still drink alcohol? Yes. Do I still breathe city air? Yes. Do I still drink tap water? Yes. Does any of that justify vaping diketones? Nope. We know the risks of those things. Diketones? Nope.

I'm done here, this thread is going in circles. If you care to be incensed by more of my "ANTZ" propaganda you can check the other diketones threads, virtually all of which I've voiced my opinion in. Numerous times. And so have most of you.

So your not to worried about the amount of formaldehyde coming from your cotton wick / metal coil ?
 

nyiddle

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 9, 2014
2,826
2,692
USA. State: Inebriated.
So, you've decided that a certain amount of alcohol is okay even though it causes death by liver disease.

Yes. At least I know the risks.

So your not to worried about the amount of formaldehyde coming from your cotton wick / metal coil ?

No, because I don't burn my juice/wick.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rossum

Gauntlgrym

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 25, 2013
420
682
OH
Wouldn't the same thing be true for personal testing? If you only have one flavor that you absolutely love and can't live without, and it only costs $200 for 'peace of mind' then please explain to me why you wouldn't do the test yourself?

it's the principle of the thing. i shouldn't have to.
should i have to test the meat i buy for mad cow? should i have to test my milk to make sure it is pasteurized?

I don't think the vendor selling 3 flavors, unless they are considered best in the business, is making lots of money.

wrong....
cyclops vapor only started with 2 flavors (they have 9 now) and they are one of the biggest most well know brands. didn't start out big though.
5 pawns is also super big (not endorsing though) and only started with 5 flavors
Suicide Bunny only started with 5 flavors
Cuttwood only started with 1 flavor
Cosmic fog only started with 5

i can go on and on.
point is, MANY of the most popular eliquid brands don't have more than 10 flavors or so, and only started off with 5 or less flavors.
just because a company is only selling 3 flavors doesn't mean it's not making money.
especially when most places have a 1000%+ mark up on the juice they sell. with a 1000% mark up, it's easy to make money.

Even then, if testing requires all batches and variations to be paid for,

it doesn't. its a one time test, unless they change the recipe. one test for every flavor they carry, and boom.

So the vendor that sells no variation in their liquid, never changes their recipe and offers 5 flavors is making lots of money and could afford the $1000 cost. And it is totally righteous for them to think they need to test for something that hasn't been correlated with harm to vapers. But also totally righteous for highly concerned vapers to never ever do their own testing and put all their faith in a vendor.

I'm sure somewhere that makes sense, in crazy-ville.

crazy-ville is where people have to do all their own testing for everything that they buy.

"oh, this car i just bought says it's safe, but the manufacturer doesn't want to pay for crash tests......guess i gotta go crash it myself and do my own testing" this seems to be what you think :lol:
 
Last edited:

nyiddle

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 9, 2014
2,826
2,692
USA. State: Inebriated.
Unlike diketones the risks of consuming alcohol is well known, should alcohol be removed from all products sold?

No. Because the risks are well-known, I can make an informed decision as to whether or not I want to put the substances in my body.

Diketones? The risks aren't well-known, or really, known at all. Nobody can make an informed decision.
 

sparkky1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 8, 2014
3,429
2,686
Nashville
it's the principle of the thing. i shouldn't have to.
should i have to test the meat i buy for mad cow? should i have to test my milk to make sure it is pasteurized?



wrong....
cyclops vapor only started with 2 flavors (they have 9 now) and they are one of the biggest most well know brands.
5 pawns is also super big (not endorsing though) and only started with 5 flavors
Suicide Bunny only started with 5 flavors
Cuttwood only started with 1 flavor
Cosmic fog only started with 5

i can go on and on.
point is MANY of the most popular eliquid brands don't have more than 10 flavors or so.



it doesn't. its a one time test, unless they change the recipe. one test for every flavor they carry, and boom.



crazy-ville is where people have to do all their own testing for everything that they buy.

"oh, this car i just bought says it's safe, but the manufacturer doesn't want to pay for crash tests......guess i gotta go crash it myself and do my own testing" this seems to be what you think :lol:

So if the juice manufactures would have just put a label on them stating not intended for inhalation would that be accurate ? because all the flavor manufacturing company's don't claim to be intended for inhalation but rather ingested for food or beverage consumption and FDA approved, so why the big rant to go after the mixologist to test ?
When your at the steakhouse do you ask the chef for the United States Department of Agriculture, Food Safety and Inspection results ?
That's why they made Chantix for people like yourself to take all the risk out, FDA approved also ..............
 

AzPlumber

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 28, 2011
5,051
9,789
Arizona
No. Because the risks are well-known, I can make an informed decision as to whether or not I want to put the substances in my body.

Diketones? The risks aren't well-known, or really, known at all. Nobody can make an informed decision.

This is going better than expected. So you think people should go back to smoking because the risks are well known. :)
 

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
it's the principle of the thing. i shouldn't have to.
should i have to test the meat i buy for mad cow? should i have to test my milk to make sure it is pasteurized?



wrong....
cyclops vapor only started with 2 flavors (they have 9 now) and they are one of the biggest most well know brands. didn't start out big though.
5 pawns is also super big (not endorsing though) and only started with 5 flavors
Suicide Bunny only started with 5 flavors
Cuttwood only started with 1 flavor
Cosmic fog only started with 5
N.
i can go on and on.
point is, MANY of the most popular eliquid brands don't have more than 10 flavors or so, and only started off with 5 or less flavors.
just because a company is only selling 3 flavors doesn't mean it's not making money.
especially when most places have a 1000%+ mark up on the juice they sell. with a 1000% mark up, it's easy to make money.



it doesn't. its a one time test, unless they change the recipe. one test for every flavor they carry, and boom.



crazy-ville is where people have to do all their own testing for everything that they buy.

"oh, this car i just bought says it's safe, but the manufacturer doesn't want to pay for crash tests......guess i gotta go crash it myself and do my own testing" this seems to be what you think :lol:
It's a mater of principal to me. Why should vapers be paying for unnecessary
testing which will be passed along in the cost? Who died and left you and
a few others in charge of the testing protocols? I have done a fare bit of
research on e-cigarettes. How there made and the materials and ingredients
used to make them. As of yet I have found no evidence that there is any
thing causing any harm if not abused. There is absolutely nothing about
vaping that merits the scrutiny and villany heaped on it by the FDA and
some vapors.
Regards
Mike
 
  • Like
Reactions: BrentMydland

nyiddle

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 9, 2014
2,826
2,692
USA. State: Inebriated.
This is going better than expected. So you think people should go back to smoking because the risks are well known. :)

Wow, you probably didn't get very far in debate club. You've been spouting logical fallacies this whole thread, and you've even contradicted yourself quite a few times.

I started vaping for harm reduction. I didn't vape because I wanted to blow clouds, or taste fancy flavors, or whatever you started vaping for. I know cigarettes are bad for me. I'm confident unflavored e-juice is safer than flavored e-juice. We all accept certain risks. I don't accept the risk of diketones, primarily because it may be far worse and far more apparent than the long-term effects of smoking cigarettes. Maybe not. It's all speculation. You're banking on diketones being fine, you're a risk-taker, probably a cloud-chaser, I get it. I'd rather err on the side of caution.

I should've stopped responding a page or so ago, but as a final note, everyone who responded to this thread should read this Wikipedia article and consider these very easy-to-avoid mistakes/comparisons/conclusions when trying to formulate a cohesive argument:

List of fallacies - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 

sparkky1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 8, 2014
3,429
2,686
Nashville
No. Because the risks are well-known, I can make an informed decision as to whether or not I want to put the substances in my body.

Diketones? The risks aren't well-known, or really, known at all. Nobody can make an informed decision.
very easy-to-avoid mistakes/comparisons/conclusions when trying to formulate a cohesive argument ?
You are a truly gifted vacillator, debate club ? ................
 

nyiddle

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 9, 2014
2,826
2,692
USA. State: Inebriated.
very easy-to-avoid mistakes/comparisons/conclusions when trying to formulate a cohesive argument ?
You are a truly gifted vacillator, debate club ? ................

So what is your argument? Hm? Diketones are A-okay? Keep 'em in e-juice?

All the power to you. Keep chucking your diketone clouds. Keep it out of my face. And learn to write without sounding like a dunce. Seeya bud.
 

sparkky1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 8, 2014
3,429
2,686
Nashville
So what is your argument? Hm? Diketones are A-okay? Keep 'em in e-juice?

All the power to you. Keep chucking your diketone clouds. Keep it out of my face. And learn to write without sounding like a dunce. Seeya bud.

And don't forget to call / email your inebriated state senator / white house and help
Support H.R. 2058
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread