DNA 40, NR, Nickel Builds

Status
Not open for further replies.

ukeman

PV Masher
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 22, 2010
7,718
5,129
Kauai, Hawaii
wow ... ^^^ I'd have thought 20 wraps AND on a 3mm ID coil would be plenty! It doesn't seem to jive with what others have posted and demo'ed though....?

i.e. I've seen 10wraps of Ni200 on a 1/16th ID coil and they got above .10 ohms and no problems. they were using 30g though.

doh...what am i thinking? yeah with a dual it will halve the resistance... you'd have to make 2x tons of wraps to get up to .10 ohms.
 

peraspera

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 2, 2012
2,808
6,184
midwest
..I did a single coil also, trying to get up around the >0.10 ohm range, and this one reads anywhere between 0.14 to 0.18ohms.
The resistance seems to bounce around as you vape?
...

The DNA 40 chip's programming uses the mathematical relationship between resistance and temperature for its temperature calculations so one would expect to see oHms go up and down as the coil heats and cools.
 

DejayRezme

Super Member
ECF Veteran
  • Mar 22, 2014
    910
    523
    Europe
    Hey all .... had my DNA40 Hana now for a couple of days, and I am not sure I am liking it. :unsure:

    I got Ni200 28g, did dual coils, 10 wraps on a 3mm mandrel each side, and it's reading at 0.05ohms on the Hana.
    I set the temp control at 400 degrees (for cotton?) and I keep getting the temp control kicking in at 23 watts. If I go higher it stutters kicking in the temp control.
    I have some 30g and 32g coming, guess I have to get the ohms a lot higher?

    If you're below 0.1 ohms you won't get the full 40 watts. But it's interesting to know that you don't need them and still can reach the temperature you've set! So besides the resistance jumping around (which is required) what else don't you like about it?

    I think generally we should strife to use thinner wire (30 or 32awg).

    Thanks for sharing your experience!
     

    finagle69

    Ultra Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Feb 11, 2013
    1,027
    1,311
    47
    Sacramento, CA
    I guess the scientist in me doesn't like the idea of the DNA assuming "room temp". Your room temp is going to be different from mine. As long as you adjust the temp setting to taste, the difference shouldn't be a big deal. But if I know cotton flashes at 410F and I set to 400F, then I could potentially burn the cotton depending on what room temp is when I screw everything together.
     

    Heespharm

    Ultra Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Sep 7, 2014
    1,190
    1,100
    Htown,tx
    I guess the scientist in me doesn't like the idea of the DNA assuming "room temp". Your room temp is going to be different from mine. As long as you adjust the temp setting to taste, the difference shouldn't be a big deal. But if I know cotton flashes at 410F and I set to 400F, then I could potentially burn the cotton depending on what room temp is when I screw everything together.

    It's gauging temp by reading the resistance of the ni200... At higher temp the resistance increases...


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     

    granolaboy

    Super Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    May 13, 2014
    416
    495
    Skidegate, BC, Canada
    granolaboy.net
    I don't think anyone has explained that as nickel wire increases in temperature, it increases in resistance. The dna40 is simply measuring the increase in resistance to calculate the temperature because they're directly related. X causes Y

    Likely not the Nickle wire we're talking about here, but just for reference:
    http://www.omega.com/temperature/pdf/ni60.pdf

    The key thing here is the "Temperature Coefficient of Resistance", which is 0.00015Ω/°C (20 to 500°C) for the wire in the pdf, and likely different for the Nickel wire Evolv says to use.

    The resistance-change factor per degree Celsius of temperature change is called the temperature coefficient of resistance. This factor is represented by the Greek lower-case letter "alpha" (α). A positive coefficient for a material means that its resistance increases with an increase in temperature.

    So, using this number, the dna40 can do the math and figure out the temperature based on the measured resistance, or rather, the measured current and voltage it uses to calculate the resistance.

    Neat idea...now I want to get some Nickel wire and try this out on my Arduino Raptor mod...

    *edit*

    So the dna40 is calibrated for Ni200 wire.

    Found this: http://www.hightempmetals.com/techdata/hitempNi200data.php

    So the temperature coefficient of Ni200 is 0.004/0.005 Ω/°C.
     
    Last edited:

    brickfollett

    Ultra Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Oct 25, 2013
    1,357
    1,167
    Washington
    Likely not the Nickle wire we're talking about here, but just for reference:
    http://www.omega.com/temperature/pdf/ni60.pdf

    The key thing here is the "Temperature Coefficient of Resistance", which is 0.00015Ω/Ω/°C (20 to 500°C) for the wire in the pdf, and likely different for the Nickel wire Evolv says to use.



    So, using this number, the dna40 can do the math and figure out the temperature based on the measured resistance, or rather, the measured current and voltage it uses to calculate the resistance.

    Neat idea...
    Haha that went over my head just a bit! Yeah the evolv chip is calibrated for ni200. I have 100 feet of 28, 30 and 32 on the way
     

    Kumatesh

    Full Member
    Jun 16, 2014
    65
    30
    TX
    Anyone else having a bit of a tough time getting these coils to cooperate? Wrapping the coil is easy but if I can't glow it, how am I supposed to know if it's heating evenly and, more importantly, how accurate its heat sensing is? Since the board detects average temperature across the coils, one spot will get real hot while the rest remains cooler, making it seem like your temperature is only X degrees when you could still be scorching cotton/juice.
     

    ukeman

    PV Masher
    Supporting Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Aug 22, 2010
    7,718
    5,129
    Kauai, Hawaii
    Anyone else having a bit of a tough time getting these coils to cooperate? Wrapping the coil is easy but if I can't glow it, how am I supposed to know if it's heating evenly and, more importantly, how accurate its heat sensing is? Since the board detects average temperature across the coils, one spot will get real hot while the rest remains cooler, making it seem like your temperature is only X degrees when you could still be scorching cotton/juice.

    The Ni200 coils will not glow like kanthal wire builds.
    From what I've seen on the few video's you will do some interactive regulating up or down in temp. to get the desired vape... so once you dial that in, you're not going to have scorching.
     

    Kumatesh

    Full Member
    Jun 16, 2014
    65
    30
    TX
    The Ni200 coils will not glow like kanthal wire builds.
    From what I've seen on the few video's you will do some interactive regulating up or down in temp. to get the desired vape... so once you dial that in, you're not going to have scorching.

    Well, they certainly will glow if you take off temperature control. What my main issue is, as with Kanthal, coils tend to heat unevenly unless fiddled with. Generally, you fire them and watch them glow and make sure that they heat from the center out and equally. The TC will read the average temperature of the coil and, if the coil is heating unevenly, some spots will be much hotter than others while the average temperature may be at or under your setpoint. Earlier, I had to fiddle around with a coil for a few minutes to get rid of a hot leg that was glowing even with TC -- and yet the device still measured <450f. Obviously that spot was much hotter than that
     

    Rossum

    Eleutheromaniac
    Supporting Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Dec 14, 2013
    16,081
    105,232
    SE PA
    Ten turns of 28 gauge on a 1/8" drill bit got me 0.17 ohms

    N2F4T50.jpg


    Note there's room for a second coil just like that!

    Atty is purpose-designed bottom-feeding Nuppin' by pdib.
     

    DejayRezme

    Super Member
    ECF Veteran
  • Mar 22, 2014
    910
    523
    Europe
    Anyone else having a bit of a tough time getting these coils to cooperate? Wrapping the coil is easy but if I can't glow it, how am I supposed to know if it's heating evenly and, more importantly, how accurate its heat sensing is? Since the board detects average temperature across the coils, one spot will get real hot while the rest remains cooler, making it seem like your temperature is only X degrees when you could still be scorching cotton/juice.

    Yeah I think people will have to experiment and share their findings and create a new "knowledge base" especially on the contact coil thingy. Since nickel doesn't form a protective isolating layer of oxide like kanthal / nichrome it seems to me that any kind of contact between wraps would create a short and a hot / cold spot with uneven resistance and temp sensing across the coil. You can just disable the temp (set the temp > 600°F) and have the coil glow to see what happens, if you can create / avoid hotspots with pinching.

    Will we now start wrapping non contact coils on screws? The main problem with non contact coils made on a screw is that the coils will even get bigger than they now need to be because of the low resistance.

    I wish evolv would create a FAQ or extensive guide from all the experiences the beta group gathered.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Users who are viewing this thread