Do you need a mosfet?

Status
Not open for further replies.

edyle

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 23, 2013
14,199
7,195
Port-of-Spain, Trinidad & Tobago
Don't know how to use the links properly. Been looking at this unregulated box. It is fully mechanical and doesn't have a mosfet. Is a mosfet necessary? Tube mechs don't have them. Why would I need one. Thanks
M-vapes Dual 18650 Beech Box Mod

1: is a mosfet necessary.
No.

2: tube mechs don't have them ;
The typical tube mech uses only 1 battery, and has a mechanical switch with no wires.
Many unregulated box mods have a pushbutton switch with wires running to it; those thin wire may get too hot if too much current is drawn.
 

MyMagicMist

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 28, 2014
1,159
2,465
53
Using a full mechanical like the one you link to, "Solid UK beech wood construction", as far as I'm aware you don't need one. The mosfet is useful for circuit boards & regulated mods. I found this out recently as someone examined a Ola X Hero I have. If the mosfet fries or shorts out the board will not fully fire. You get base current but it is not enough to fire the atty.

Companies tend to buy the lowest priced, lowest quality ones as per business. So, they can fritz out without having done anything "wrong". The mosfets from what I understood are not really circuit protection, merely an extra fuse to go bad. Then, you go track down that Murphy guy.

Using a mech, I would feel confident saying you likely do not need one. Granted I'm a bit new to using mechs. I'm sure others here may chime in with corrections if needed.
 

KentA

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 5, 2015
1,251
3,153
76
Adirondack Mountains
I was referring to the solid copper bars that are used instead of wires to transfer the current.
#1 from the negatives to the switch
#2 switch to the 510
#3 across the positives to the atomizer
That assembly does not appear to be jeopardized by a couple of 18650s.

P.S. The only thing that should connect the positive & negative is your atty's coil.
 

VHRB2014

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 16, 2014
2,593
4,587
Nic`d Up in Oklahoma!
A mosfet is used when you are using a low amp switch and wires to conduct the voltage, and the low amp switch and wires may melt if the amp drawn is higher then they can handle. Example is a parallel plastic box using two 18650`s but with a 20 (or less) amp rated switch and wires. While it may handle most .25 builds fine, it might struggle and get over heated once you drop below .25 or so and start pulling more then 20-21 amps. Its a simple circuit breaker that just opens the circuit creating a dead connection, If it gets too hot. IN this example, without the mosfet, the switch and wires could melt down and cause the battery to go into thermal runaway because of the resulting short the melt down would cause.

IN a fully mechanical set up, all metal contacts, including the switch, are much larger and are easily rated for the max amperage and so the only thing you have to worry about is pulling too many amps and your battery melting down, ie thermal runaway. You can use a Mosfet in a fully mechanical box, but you would be limiting it to the operating amperage of the mosfet instead of the max amperage available of the battery's.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread