Rational thinking is not a characteristic of a smoker. A smoker has lost the ability to think things through when it comes to smoking. Otherwise they would not smoke in the first place. Quiting smoking is a decision that all of us have made. However IMHO many people in the forum still have the mind of a smoker. That inability to think rationally on any topic related to smoking.
I have to say, I try to stay out of these emotional topics, but I just have to reply to this. This post as well as your previous one really offended me, not just on my behalf, but on behalf of everyone who isn't you! lol Both this post and your previous one seem to indicate that no smokers are rational... Except for you. No scenario is possible.. Except for the ones that you posit. I can state and accept with full certainty that you and I are different people with different histories and experiences. You may well be a rational human being whose opinion just happens not to line up or coincide with mine, and you know what? I can respect that. YOU are entitled to your own opinion. I wish that you would grant the rest of us the same respect and entitlement. Any person who cannot at least attempt to see things from a point of view other than their own, and barring an agreement between two people who have different ideas at least grant that the other person is entitled to their own opinion seems to be rather guilty of closed-mindedness. In MY opinion.
And to the OP, MissAngelD, I'm so glad you spoke to them about it, and were able to be more comfortable with the situation. Regardless of whether people agree or disagree with what they're doing, it seems pretty clear to me that you guys care about each other and any concern was based out of that caring. Its great that you were able to discuss it, though. Nothing worse than having 'elephant in the room' with someone you love. Good luck!