FDA to study "Why People Smoke" (by asking the wrong questions)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Vocalek

CASAA Activist
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Why Do People Use Tobacco? Looking for Answers

Much is known about the use of tobacco products, especially their effects on the health of those who smoke cigarettes. What’s known includes two grim facts: tobacco use is the leading cause of preventable, premature death in the United States. And thousands of kids start smoking every day in the United States, many starting a lifetime of addiction

I can give the FDA some hints as to why smokers continue smoking instead of quitting. When the government tells lies such as "tobacco use is the leading cause of preventable, premature death in the United States," they perpetuate smoking. What the smoker (and the rest of society as far as that goes) hears is "All tobacco use is equally harmful." But their statement is akin to claiming "In 2010, 10,228 people were killed in driving crashes caused by drinking beverages." Society knows that drinking beverages such as water, milk, soda, etc., does not cause these crashes. It is only the drinking of alcoholic beverages that impairs driving abilities.

But if the government were to run an enormous public information campaign implying that ALL beverages are causing fatalities, pretty soon people would be eating more oranges, watermelon, tomatoes and other foods that contain a high liquid content instead of drinking beverages.

The study participants will be interviewed annually by researchers from Westat, a company in Rockville, Md. that specializes in health surveys and public health research. These investigators will examine such issues as


  • susceptibility to tobacco use;
  • frequency of use patterns;
  • characteristics of smoking cessation and relapse;
  • effects of regulatory changes on the perception of risk and other tobacco-related attitudes;
  • differences in attitudes, behaviors and key health outcomes in racial-ethnic, gender, and age subgroups.
“Data we obtain from the PATH study will provide us with important information that will inform our future regulatory options to protect the public health, including setting tobacco product standards and communicating the risks of tobacco use,” says Cathy Backinger, Ph.D., M.P.H., deputy director for research in CTP’s Office of Science at FDA.
Well, they will certainly collect a lot of data, but they are not asking the right questions if the goal is to put a dent in the 43.8 million adult smokers statistic.

Oh, that's right. Apparently they don't really give a rodent's posterior about helping smokers who would like to reduce their health risks to find a way to stop inhaling smoke. What they care about appears to be stopping kids from taking up any form of nicotine, and to force smokers off nicotine by applying a variety of "sticks" such as the following:

  • impoverishing smokers through sky-high taxes,
  • treating any form of nicotine intake as if it were the same thing as smoking,
  • banning those who use any form of nicotine from employment (even pharmaceutical products),
  • and kicking them out of their residence if they are caught using any form of nicotine (except for pharmaceutical products) in their apartment, in the hallways and common areas, and even the great outdoors.

They are not bothering to ask what it is about using nicotine that consumers enjoy. They are not asking what things function as barriers to getting off nicotine. They are not bothering to find out the health effects on smokers that switch to smoke-free alternatives.

According to CTP, approximately 20 percent of U.S. high school students currently smoke. Additionally, data shows an increase in use of other tobacco products such as hookah (water pipes used to smoke tobacco), small cigars, and smokeless tobacco among teens. And the smoking rate among adults has been stalled since 2004, the center reports.

The number of youth smokers is inflated (which is how they justify putting all their attention on "the children.") The smoking rate has been stalled much longer than 8 years, when looked at as absolute numbers, instead of percent of the population. There were 43.8 million adult smokers in the U.S. in 1990, and by 2011, 21 years later, there were (wait for it....) 43.8 million adult smokers. Let's pat ourselves on the back and congratulate ourselves on all the progress we made. (<- sarcasm.) The numbers went up as high as 47.2 million 1998, and as low as 43.4 million in 2007, but jumped back up to 46 million the following year, finally settling back to the 1990 figure in 2011.

Smokers-1990-to-2011.jpg

The rest of the article goes back to the FDA patting itself on the back for all the actions the Agency has taken to reduce....
youth smoking initiation.
 
Last edited:

Vocalek

CASAA Activist
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
I'm thinking that it would be interesting to survey a large number of former smokers who became abstinent from nicotine and ask them to select from Worse, The Same, or Better in answering the questions below:

Since you stopped using nicotine, how would you describe the changes in your health (Worse, The Same, Better) related to the following:

Breathing
Wheezing
Stamina
Energy
Memory
Concentration
Physical strength
Calmness
Happiness
Sense of smell
Sense of taste

Then what would be really interesting is to ask the same questions of former smokers that switched to a smoke-free source of nicotine.
 

Stubby

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 22, 2009
2,104
1,992
Madison, WI USA
I'm thinking that it would be interesting to survey a large number of former smokers who became abstinent from nicotine and ask them to select from Worse, The Same, or Better in answering the questions below:

Since you stopped using nicotine, how would you describe the changes in your health (Worse, The Same, Better) related to the following:

Breathing
Wheezing
Stamina
Energy
Memory
Concentration
Physical strength
Calmness
Happiness
Sense of smell
Sense of taste

Then what would be really interesting is to ask the same questions of former smokers that switched to a smoke-free source of nicotine.

Especially

Memory
Concentration
Calmness
Happiness

I might add

Depression or sadness
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread