Flavor Musings

Status
Not open for further replies.

Briar

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 28, 2009
2,350
2,558
64
A fool on the hill in Deposit, NY
Kinda of a sideways topic, but considering that Bad had once declared that he'll get rid of stuffed cartos if it's the last thing he does, I thought it was just a tad appropriate.

I've only used your run-of-the-mill Boges a few times, and all those have been with "naturally macerated" tobacco flavors - only because those seem to leach stuff from plastic. I pretty much re-started my vaping journey with Clearos - got fascinated by the GV site. :D

As we all know, strong tobacco flavor hides a multitude of sins. Today I tried Kona Coffee Milkshake (this juice has an almost cult-like following) in a Boge. Reason being that I can't ever seem to get full flavor out of it, so I figured what the heck, I'll try it, people swear they get stronger taste out of them than with clearos... OH, YUCK!!!

If there are Boge-folk out there, I totally apologize - this is just the opinion of my personal taste-buds. Really, no offense.

But, OMG. All I could taste was the filler. And it was *much* harsher than any clearo I've ever used. BTW, I was very careful about filling the Boge, syringe method, shook it, let it sit for several hours, etc - in other words, what I was tasting was *not* a "burnt" Boge but a Boge in its natural state...

Harsher. *Not* tastier. In other words, the overall flavor was stronger, yes, but it was the flavor of the juice mixed up about half and half with the "flavor" of the filler. I had to drink two glasses of Coke (universal cleaner :p) to get the taste out of my mouth - and it's still hanging around.

So now I'm thinking that those folks who state that for them the flavor of all clearos is "muted", are actually missing that part of the flavor that is the filler, and the harshness that goes with it.

But, wait, there is more. (Isn't there always?)

Flavor, just like odor, just like music for that matter, has a spectrum - from higher/sharper notes to lower/rounder notes. For instance, a lemon has a high/sharp flavor, while a good quality chocolate has a deep/round flavor.

A good e-juice flavor, just like a good perfume, will have at least three "levels": a top note, a middle note, and a deep note. It's a "chord" of flavor. For instance, orange (high), strawberry (middle) and chocolate (low) taste great separately, but if you put them together in the right proportion - wow! Ditto for lemon, peach and tea. Etc.

So what am I getting at?

It seems to me that, just like with sound, higher notes in flavor seem "louder". More noticeable. And from what I'm tasting here, in a Boge one tastes the high note and, maybe, the middle note - but the low note is eaten up but the filler taste, which is a low note in and of itself, but much stronger than any natural low note in the juice. The result is a stronger, harsher taste - but it's a distorted taste.

But even the clearos, depending on the physical configuration, will emphasize different aspects of the spectrum. Which brings me to the last point. It's been amazing me, for quite some time, that some folks complain about the flavor of the Stardusts being "muted". It occurred to me, finally, that what is happening is that the Stardust does a truly fantastic job of presenting the entire spectrum of the flavor evenly. Meaning that one tastes *all* the nuances of the juice, from top to bottom (which is why I love it so much) - but because of this, those who are used to the predominance of the higher notes, which are naturally stronger, will find the flavor more "spread out".

How you like it is, of course, the matter of personal preference. Some tune their music equalizer to boost highs, some - lows, and some normalize the volume so that the "loudness" is spread out evenly.

Point is, it's not that the flavor is "muted", necessarily, in the sense that there is less flavor - it's that the flavor is accented differently.

Not to say that there are no cartos that genuinely lessen the flavor intensity, but I really don't think that's the case with the Stardust. Or with clearos in general as compared to the Boges.

Just an observation... And, btw, all joking about aesthetics aside, that's the main reason why I hope the Stardust tube shape doesn't change - the shape *greatly* influences the flavor profile.

Anyway, just saying... vaping my KCM in a reg. Stardust at 3.9 V. I swear, this juice is over-rated... But, maybe, I just don't dig coffee juices, much as I like real coffee... :vapor:
 

tinajfreeman

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 27, 2010
747
508
Jacksonville, FL
The boges have a very loyal following, but I don't get it either. I have tried them and the filler seems to distort the flavor to me also. I have tried 5 different types of clearos, and would choose any of them over a carto with filler. And I really like my Stardusts. So easy and effective.

I guess taste is subjective. But I am with you on this one.
 

badkolo

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Oct 17, 2009
11,274
21,917
Whitestone , New York USA
i dont like filler cartos and im not shy about, this is not to ay that some are not good, exact opposite, there are some great filler cartos out their but i dont like burning filler and i hate the sock taste and im very sensitive to this as i know many who are as well. i can taste it instantly and only the strongest flavored juices cover this slightly and then i have my other issues with them, filling and refilling and they dry out etc...

But many people still like them and for those people we have something special, we waited once again until they made all improvements on them and will be releasing new stlyed top horizontal coiled filler cartos that contain 90% less filler, or a i call them 90% less sock taste and much more flavor overall, lol. i think youll get a kick out of these babies once released and they will come prefilled and empty
 

harleydiva

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 9, 2012
1,492
3,006
Southern Michigan
I'm with you guys.....I have one carto tank with a Boge in it.....the filler taste just overwhelms everything else. I keep trying to use it, just because I paid $$ for it.........but the carto taste is just yucky. I gave up on using cartos by themselves as soon as I got my hands on my first Stardust. Right now...Stardusts and Vivi Nova are my favorites.
 

antfuzz

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 19, 2010
563
347
Delaware
f20288f32544ab26_sockinit.jpg
 

Mikey3

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 4, 2011
623
196
Monmouth County NJ
I guess as both a Boge and a ce2 user i will throw my 2cents in. People want to us a reliable product without having to mod it 1st (exception of punching holes if using a tank). I have been using boge's and ce2's for a while now and yes theres a pretty significant difference in flavor but I would prefer a boge carto over any of the clearo's, ce2 tanks any day. Reason being: You buy a boge or any filler carto, fill it, vape it. No break in no modding required. You buy a ce2 for example, the old fluxomizers. When you buy it you have to take off the cap, take off the flat seal, take off the cup seal, cut the notches bigger line it back up and place it back on (or dont use the big cup seal and stick with the small flat one). Then you have to fill it, and "break it in". granted once broken in the flavor and production is great. But I and many others dont want to do all that. I like how ce2's are pretty much rebuildable but they are too inconsistant. Out of all the carto's including the DC's, boge has been the best so far. I can deal with a little distorted flavor if it's going to work right out of the box for me.

people swear by the stardust...I dont get it, i had 8 of them and had 0 luck with any of them. The vivi nova, very little luck with that.

For me, carto's are the way to go. Until i find a ce2 that works out of box and doesn't require any type of modding or messing around for it to work.
 

Mikey3

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 4, 2011
623
196
Monmouth County NJ
i dont like filler cartos and im not shy about, this is not to ay that some are not good, exact opposite, there are some great filler cartos out their but i dont like burning filler and i hate the sock taste and im very sensitive to this as i know many who are as well. i can taste it instantly and only the strongest flavored juices cover this slightly and then i have my other issues with them, filling and refilling and they dry out etc...

But many people still like them and for those people we have something special, we waited once again until they made all improvements on them and will be releasing new stlyed top horizontal coiled filler cartos that contain 90% less filler, or a i call them 90% less sock taste and much more flavor overall, lol. i think youll get a kick out of these babies once released and they will come prefilled and empty


see now these would be awesome. Would they be able to go in a tank and punched? cuz ill buy out your entire stock if thats the case
 

Briar

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 28, 2009
2,350
2,558
64
A fool on the hill in Deposit, NY
I guess as both a Boge and a ce2 user i will throw my 2cents in. People want to us a reliable product without having to mod it 1st (exception of punching holes if using a tank). ...

Oh, I get that - absolutely! :) I'm curious, though: what flavors do you normally use?

The reason I'm asking is that the only juices I actually used in the Boges are the macerated tobacco juices - and I actually liked those a lot in a Boge. I stopped using those juices because I am currently on a "no-tobacco" streak, but one or two times I tried a different tobacco juice (one that didn't leach from the plastic) in a Fluxo, it tasted kinda "watery" to me.

My theory, for many tobacco juices, is that the... ahem... "sock" taste actually does a decent job simulating the burning cigarette flavor. Just to test that theory, I lit up an analog just now - and wouldn't you know it, to me, at least, the theory seems to hold up, the burning tobacco+paper taste is similar to the filler taste.

I'm wondering what the proportion of Boge-lovers to tobacco-juice-lovers is...

Plus, a taste is something pretty easy to get used to. When I stared vaping, everyone used those little carts that came with the original 510. Those had filler, and I can't say they really put me off, flavor-wise. They drove me nuts because they didn't wick well for me, and I was fiddling more than I was vaping. I stopped vaping for a bit, and when I came back I jumped right into clearos - they just looked so damn cool on the GV site! And though they gave me conniptions at first, the coolness factor prevailed, ultimately. I just now really had a chance to compare flavor between a clearo and a Boge with a non-tobacco juice.
 

Mikey3

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 4, 2011
623
196
Monmouth County NJ
Oh, I get that - absolutely! :) I'm curious, though: what flavors do you normally use?

The reason I'm asking is that the only juices I actually used in the Boges are the macerated tobacco juices - and I actually liked those a lot in a Boge. I stopped using those juices because I am currently on a "no-tobacco" streak, but one or two times I tried a different tobacco juice (one that didn't leach from the plastic) in a Fluxo, it tasted kinda "watery" to me.

My theory, for many tobacco juices, is that the... ahem... "sock" taste actually does a decent job simulating the burning cigarette flavor. Just to test that theory, I lit up an analog just now - and wouldn't you know it, to me, at least, the theory seems to hold up, the burning tobacco+paper taste is similar to the filler taste.

I'm wondering what the proportion of Boge-lovers to tobacco-juice-lovers is...

Plus, a taste is something pretty easy to get used to. When I stared vaping, everyone used those little carts that came with the original 510. Those had filler, and I can't say they really put me off, flavor-wise. They drove me nuts because they didn't wick well for me, and I was fiddling more than I was vaping. I stopped vaping for a bit, and when I came back I jumped right into clearos - they just looked so damn cool on the GV site! And though they gave me conniptions at first, the coolness factor prevailed, ultimately. I just now really had a chance to compare flavor between a clearo and a Boge with a non-tobacco juice.

I vape mostly fruit flavors, and some tobacco. Never had any flavor issues with a filler carto until the carto was pretty much at it's end. But i do agree the ce2's give a more natural flavor of your liquid. I've been vaping gorilla juice non stop for 3 weeks now in boges but have yet to try it in a ce2. Might actually go fill up a clearo i have and see the difference.
 

Barefoot

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 21, 2011
326
220
Xianning, Hubei Province, China
I got a GoTank from Discount vapers - having got a GoGo from GV - and really liking it. Carto's work best for me with Tobacco juice and the GoCarts do seem better than most for Flavour. I can discern more subtly if i put the same juice in a stardust or DD, but for Vapour Production and TH the GoTank wins - on an eGo-C Twist, with a Janty Kuwako - i'm getting a very 'Pipe-a-like' experience and a good texture to the Vape which i'm really enjoying.

Kuwako + Twist + GoTank.jpg

For subtly tho i'd have to agree, there are better options out there, the Stardust and VVN (at 2.8) for starters.
 

dannoman

Unregistered Supplier
ECF Veteran
Oct 22, 2010
6,896
12,330
Sugar Land, Texas USA
I respect your experience but for the life of me I don't really know what the fuss is over the CE2. I have crusaded often that you don't HAVE to mod these. I made a video recently that shows me using Supremes right out of the box and enjoying with no modding whatsoever and I have done this on almost all Fluxomizers since I started vaping.

Some mod possibly as they are using these on box mods or some such trying to push the voltage envelope possibly. I will say I vape exclusively on eGo style batteries and maybe toss in a unregulated 3.7v eGo or some such here and there. When you fully charge a 3.7v battery and it is unregulated you will get 4.1-4.2v on a full charge and yes, possibly you may need to loosen things up a bit as you are drying out the wicks much faster.




I guess as both a Boge and a ce2 user i will throw my 2cents in. People want to us a reliable product without having to mod it 1st (exception of punching holes if using a tank). I have been using boge's and ce2's for a while now and yes theres a pretty significant difference in flavor but I would prefer a boge carto over any of the clearo's, ce2 tanks any day. Reason being: You buy a boge or any filler carto, fill it, vape it. No break in no modding required. You buy a ce2 for example, the old fluxomizers. When you buy it you have to take off the cap, take off the flat seal, take off the cup seal, cut the notches bigger line it back up and place it back on (or dont use the big cup seal and stick with the small flat one). Then you have to fill it, and "break it in". granted once broken in the flavor and production is great. But I and many others dont want to do all that. I like how ce2's are pretty much rebuildable but they are too inconsistant. Out of all the carto's including the DC's, boge has been the best so far. I can deal with a little distorted flavor if it's going to work right out of the box for me.

people swear by the stardust...I dont get it, i had 8 of them and had 0 luck with any of them. The vivi nova, very little luck with that.

For me, carto's are the way to go. Until i find a ce2 that works out of box and doesn't require any type of modding or messing around for it to work.
 
Last edited:

dannoman

Unregistered Supplier
ECF Veteran
Oct 22, 2010
6,896
12,330
Sugar Land, Texas USA
For fillered cartos the GoGo, is in my opinion, the best out there, which is why we carry them.


I got a GoTank from Discount vapers - having got a GoGo from GV - and really liking it. Carto's work best for me with Tobacco juice and the GoCarts do seem better than most for Flavour. I can discern more subtly if i put the same juice in a stardust or DD, but for Vapour Production and TH the GoTank wins - on an eGo-C Twist, with a Janty Kuwako - i'm getting a very 'Pipe-a-like' experience and a good texture to the Vape which i'm really enjoying.

View attachment 100362

For subtly tho i'd have to agree, there are better options out there, the Stardust and VVN (at 2.8) for starters.
 

Mikey3

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 4, 2011
623
196
Monmouth County NJ
8 stardust and no luck meaning i get barely any flavor or TH. and yes i did break them in. Tried on various volts. Nothing. So I PIF'd them. Danno i watched your video when you first posted it. It was great. I even tried just filling and vaping without playing around but after a few vapes all i got was burning. It could be just me but like I said i have the worst luck with them. The Grande was the only one that worked really well from the start (when it wasnt leaking).

Dont get me wring im not bashing the ce2 in any way at all. They are awesome products when they do work but the cartos are just easier right out of box.

And as for gorilla juice in both carto and fluxo. Flavor was exactly the same. Finished off 2 fills in a fluxo and didnt notice a difference.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

melloyello

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 21, 2011
1,830
497
59
usa
i use both boge and ce2's including the phoenix xl and 3ml....oh and also used vivi novas, vision tanks and stardust.

ive been using boges for 14 months straight.

the fiddle factor on ce 2 type cartos comes in especially when you use a thicker juice. i have had very limited success with wicking on above mentioned carto style with thicker liquids (above 70pg/30vg).

i have never had a taste distortion with boge cartos (maybe im not sensitive enough).
the first phoenix xl i had put out more vapor than any carto i have ever tried, i rinsed and refilled it about 20 times...but now i cant make it work like it did in the beginning...and thats a pretty darn good life span of a carto, i have NEVER gone through 30mls of liquid in one single carto before, regardless of liquid.
that being said, no other ce2 i have tried has worked out-of-the-box, always had to mod them one way or another for it to work right for me. most of them spit liquid in your mouth, which i havent experienced with a boge (i know it goes somewhere but it doesnt give me a liquid backwash when its condensing).

i love the idea of a ce2 but if i had to have a fool proof vaping experience, i would grab a pack of unopened boges for the trip instead of a pack of ce2 type cartos. ive bought maybe 200 boges and havent had one bad carto....cant say that about clearos.

i will continue to try a new product from time to time but until proven otherwise, boge will be the ones i "trust" the best...at this point.

oh and the "filler taste" is much more pleasant than a dry hit:)
 

Briar

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 28, 2009
2,350
2,558
64
A fool on the hill in Deposit, NY
...
oh and the "filler taste" is much more pleasant than a dry hit:)

You got me there, for sure... :D

Though, in defense, I have to say that for all the Stardusts I have used, I only had dry hits with my fist one - learning curve. Usually they give plenty of warning that it's time to "dip the wick" :p before a full-blown dry hit.

Right now I have 10 of them going at the same time, juices varying from Boba's and VV's "juice from hell" all the way to GV's CA which wicks wonderfully in anything - no dry hits in site! :)

P.S.: yes, I know I sound like a rah-rah squad - but it's *true*, I swear! :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread