I was avid Gizmodo reader until the Japan earthquake and tsunami. What really turned me off to Giz was how certain editors (Jesus in particular) would censor posts written by readers with dissenting views. I'm sure he has always done that, but it just appeared really blatant at the time. I may not always agree with someone, but just because your opinion differs doesn't mean I think you should be "silenced." I deleted my account after that, but still read on occasion.
It seems the quality of the articles really started going downhill after they posted all the info about the leaked iPhone 4. Now it just looks like sensational "journalism" (I use that term very loosely) to get page hits. The redesign didn't really help either.
On the plus side though, they posted an article about nanotube technology possibly being used in cigarette filters. A bunch of readers commented about eCigs and their potential benefits which is actually how I found this forum. So, thanks to the ECF members who also comment on Gizmodo!
About the article:
I agree that Blu's idea is silly, but Kat's "dicktard" response was downright childish. They were already losing a reader, but it pretty much seals the deal for me.