I've been vaping for less than 2 weeks and - start to finish - I was able to get started and make my first purchases thanks to the members of this community holding my hand the whole way.
An explanation before I get started. Though most see the terms 'noob' and 'newb' as synonymous, I see them this way. A
newb is someone who is new to a place or an activity. They don't know the rules or how it works, but they research and learn and slowly leave their newbish days behind. A
noob can be someone who is new to a place or activity, but even older members can be noobish. It's a person who doesn't want to learn the rules, doesn't take the time to search for answers or do a bit of research. Or an experienced member who, despite their experience, expects everyone to act like them, newbs included.
That being said, I completely agree with most of what the OP said, kinda fuzzy on some of it. For the most part my feeling is this. All opinions are just that, opinions. They are not fact. If someone says "Tanks are the better than cartomizers" that may be true for them, but its is only their opinion. As a newb or someone new to vaping, one should ask for opinions and recommendations keeping in mind that they are just that. Even then, one should do their own research first, have in mind what they are looking for in a PV and be specific about what your looking for when asking for said recommendations.
IMHO, a noob comes in without doing any prior research (or is unwilling once they learn of their choices), and expects someone to tell them what to buy. Then they simply purchase the first thing recommended or whatever seems 'popular', followed by complaining because they don't like it. (This is not personally directed at OP but some threads I've seen or possible scenarios.)
A noob can also be any member, new or otherwise who insists that their way is best and everyone should follow suit. I've seen so many Vets in various threads (not all in the new members forum) putting down new members for not being as experienced (or whatever their problem is). Or as OP said, comments like:
"Real vapers use _____", or,"Only silly n00bs like ______".
Let's just say it takes one to know one. Only a complete noob would think that their awesome setup will work for everyone coming into the community. Like said many times before me, its is not one-size-fits-all, it's trial and error, its research and decisions. Everyone is different with different tastes and different needs. Insisting that a newb who's never used a PV in their life use some uber tricked out mod that, while may be awesome and works great, may be too complicated in its use is the best way to scare someone away from vaping.
For the most part, I am completely happy with how many helpful people are here who are willing to give recommendations but are careful to add the 'disclaimer' that this might not work for everyone or ask specific questions about what someone is looking for in New Member threads to insure that they have the best experience ever. I don't see many "buy this now or GDIAF", though there are a few, luckily most I've seen are in discussions between more experienced members and not aimed toward new members.
I am quite happy with my first purchase and will probably use it for some time to come. And it was not my first choice. My awesome experience so far has been entirely due to the recommendations (and encouragement) I've gotten from this community.
Guess the same goes for the experience; one size does not fit all. ^_^