It kind-of depends on what kind of watermelon taste you are looking for... natural or candy? I spent a long time on the search for a great watermelon, and it's tough. The best I have found (for me), are the following: For a natural watermelon, I liked deejStuff. It's very fresh tasting and not overly sweet. The Cantamelon (cantalope/watermelon blend) is also very good. For a sweeter, more candy-like watermelon taste, I like The Vapor Room's Sweet Watermelon. I know the flavor description says that it ISN'T a candy-like flavor, but I think it is. I get it with extra flavor, because otherwise, it's pretty mild. Hope that helps!