My husband really likes Rocky Mountain Haze from groov-e juice. It has a slight hint of hazelnut, personally I prefer fruit flavors.
How would you rate the sweetness? I can handle low to moderate sweetness, but not excessive.
Give this a try. River Bottom Fog Sauce. This juice to extracted from tobacco leaves. A little on the pricey side but well worth it.
If you are going to try halo, be prepared to steep.
With the exception of Tribeca (in my limited experience), they can taste pretty bad if you just crack open the bottle and plan to immediately vape.

Hi Thursdy,
I am new to ECF, and somewhat new to the ecig world (2mths). I have/had the same problem as you. I can't find anything that is equal. I did find a taste that is listed as a tobacco flavor and has a similar savoriness like analog smokes. Sinister Liquids ( out of Raleigh, NC) has a flavor called "The Duke" that I have used as my everyday. They also have "Marino Blend" that is similar but more sweet. There standard flavors are all 60/40 VG/PG. It is kinda hard to describe the flavor, I hate to use the association but I almost detect a popcorn taste in there. Which doesn't sound appealing to me, but it works for me(lol). It's a top seller in local shops here. Also, they sell 2ml samples ($2) on the site, so you can give it a try without having to sit on big expensive bottles you will never use. Just my 2cents. If you find anything else that replicates true cigs.. let me know!