hey tumbleweed, does it have a throat hit or is it like smoking air?
Not sure on the throat hit as only the Nic versions usually have this. My Zero Menthol from Jane is excellent though

hey tumbleweed, does it have a throat hit or is it like smoking air?
Windblown, I went back to bickfords website thinking maybe I was missing something but all I see are either water soluble or oil soluble not any choice for the propylene glycol. I know that you were looking for menthol flavor that would be strong enough. How is the pepermint flavor hit? Is it staisfying your menthol kick or no?
is there any carts or e-liquids that are a Strong menthol that will give me that feeling or am I just kidding myself?
You are misusing menthol. I have calculated safe menthol dose in e-liquid to be 1.5%. See http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/tips-tricks/2186-time-me-annoy-you-guys-another-way.html
How did you do that and what do you mean by safe? Menthol crystals melt at 115f so it should be no great shakes to get it to dissolve in e-juice. I plan to mix a batch super strong then add some to another bottle until the flavor is right.
By safe I mean as safe as food is. Now I'm not competent to actually tell it is as safe but at least you will be more safe than if you do not do these calculations. I'm certainly expecting to be relatively safe by following jecfa's recommendations. These are about food flavoring not inhaling vapor but nevertheless should give good guidelines when judging what is safe.
I wouldn't add menthol just by how it tastes, because, well it doesnt have a taste.
I am a menthol JUNKY and I too think that nicotine is the easy part to quit compared to the menthol. I can't guarantee that I know what you are specifically looking for, but I just ordered a bottle of "Minty Menthol" from PureSmoker and I think it is really quite good. It even makes my water feel slightly cooler if I drink while vaping.
Good luck!
Brian's idea really makes sense, since you don't have to worry about getting too much thin liquid in your mix. If you dilute with alcohol, you have to be careful about getting the final mixture too thin. It also decreases the nic level. Also, if you find a tobacco flavor you like, you don't have to mess around with adding tobacco flavoring/essences. Just be careful and don't add too much menthol crystal. A little goes a long way. And if you use too much menthol, that's all you'll be able taste/sense. Althouh your sinuses will be very well cleared out!![]()