You are all good. You are just misunderstanding what it is telling you. The PG% and VG% columns are telling you how much of the overall recipe
that ingredient is contributing to
that component (PG or VG) and should always add up to the percent you specified in the recipe.
Here are three examples based on your sample screen shot. I created a nic "ingredient" to match your 20mg/60P/40V so you can see the similarities in numbers. I am specifying a 60P/40V ratio for my example. I am not sure why your PG/VG ratio does not equal 100% (64%+35%=99) unless you are adding water or alcohol as an additional dilutant/carrier and just didn't include the ingredient. Anyhow; here is the first example:
Lets start with an Unflavored recipe to get a baseline. I am using the same recipe size (30mL) and target nicotine strength (18mg) as you used in your example:
View attachment 633867
Look at the nicotine line: though we are using a 60%P/40%V blend, because the nicotine is a little higher (20mg/mL) than our target (18mg/mL), we can only use 27mL (90%) and have to dilute it, or we will go over our target nicotine strength. Now we simply add 1.8mL (6%) of PG and 1.2mL (4%) of VG and we have our final 3mL of total volume and our nicotine is where we want it at 18mg/mL. All is good.
Let's add a flavor and see what changes:
View attachment 633869
Look at the nicotine line. Nothing has changed. What has? The PG we have to add is now down to 2% because it is getting 4% of the extra PG our recipe needs from the PG that is in our added flavor. But, if we add up all our PG percentages, we still get 60%. And, if we add up all our VG percentages, we still have 40%. All is still right with the world.
Now, just for giggles, let's add one more ingredient:
View attachment 633871
Now we have hit a wall. Notice the Notes Bar has turned red (previously blue) and the message in the Warning and Errors box? Because we are using a nicotine base that is too close to what we want our finished results to be, we do not have room for 7% of PG-based flavors. If we add up all our PG percentages, we get
61%. And, if we add up all our VG percentages, we have
39%. Now we can no longer reach our desired 60P/40V ratio. We have three ways we can fix this:
- Don't exceed 6% of PG-based flavoring (though we could still use up to 3% VG-based flavoring).
- Change the ratio to a higher PG percentage.
- Alter our nicotine base by either going to a higher starting nicotine percentage (which will then use less in our recipe and require a larger addition of PG and VG to get proper dilution); or altering the starting PG/VG ratio to 55P/45V or even 50P/50V.
Tip: Whenever you are unsure how much room for flavors you are going to have with a proposed mix; create a quick Unflavored recipe (like I did in the first example) and the amount of PG that is required will show you room available for PG flavors, and the amount of VG to be added indicates how much VG flavoring you can add (if you use VG flavor concentrates).
But, to wrap this up, if you look at all three examples; The nicotine line never changes.
I hope this helps!