Hey andria, the downside is that im still co-dependent on some sort of chemical and the physical motion of smoking. Though vaping is much more safer it is still does not compare to quitting all inhalants.
I keep hearing a lot along these lines, from my parents, and some friends I've told the great news that I've switched completely to vaping rather than smoking: "well, you're still addicted to _____" (nicotine, the physical motion of smoking, whatever). That's true. Nicotine is a part of it, absolutely; even though my dependence is low enough that I mostly stay between 6-8 mg, and never more than 9mg, if it was entirely removed, there would definitely be *physical* symptoms: constipation (nicotine stimulates peristalsis, the motion of the intestines), "spaciness" (inability to focus - nicotine has a coordinating effect on neurotransmitters, much as ritalin does for ADD/ADHD), and perhaps other physical symptoms. But, of all the chemicals in cigarette smoke, nicotine is probably the less offensive, and the least toxic, in these small doses, so it's a great deal like trading hard drugs for bubble gum -- gum may rot your teeth, but it won't kill you.
There's also the fact that brains do change in response to external stimuli. If you were a smoker for a long or moderate time (say, more than 10 yrs), there may be nothing that can be done to change that addicted brain back to any kind of "default", non-addicted state. You've probably heard the phrase, "once an addict, always an addict," and that is absolutely true, at least with a number of substances -- I can never drink alcohol again, without the risk of completely losing my mind -- permanent "black-out drunk." Given the HIGH addiction-potential of all tobacco products, I believe this is almost certainly true of smoking -- if a former smoker ever smokes again, he may be unable to ever quit again, and perhaps even unwilling to try. This is just one reason that vaping is so valuable -- which would you prefer, to vape forever, and never again be tempted to smoke again... or stop vaping at some point, only to find, perhaps years down the road, that you are tempted to smoke again, or worse, do go back to smoking again? Vaping is, in that case, the very essence of Harm Reduction -- yes it may be an addiction in its own right, but given the LETHAL potential (a near certainty) of cigarettes, and the very low risk of harm from e-cigarettes, it just seems very obvious to me that it is and always will be preferable to use e-cigs rather than ever smoke another cigarette in my life, or even to RISK the POSSIBILITY of another cigarette. If your brain has changed to the point that it can't or won't ever change back to a non-addicted state, doesn't it seem like a complete no-brainer to use something as *relatively* harmless as e-cigs to satisfy that permanent addiction? Even if it means using it forever? It certainly does, to me.
I do agree with you on the physicality of vaping satisfying the actual physical motions of smoking the conventional cigarette. Your ideas of tricking the subconscious is interesting. It would be neat to see if the placebo effect would work. Changing the nicotine level to 0mg without the user knowing. Good post!!!!!!
I think it would work, to a limited degree, because I think e-cigs do utilize the placebo effect to satisfy our "need to smoke." As for secretly removing the nicotine... as I said, there ARE physical symptoms associated with nicotine withdrawal, and while they may not be immediately evident, I think a nicotine-habituated person would definitely notice within a fairly short time their inability to focus, and certainly their inability to have a BM. It would also be an extremely cruel trick, on the same order as spiking someone's drink with an unfamiliar substance -- or secretly removing all the nutrients in their food -- they'd get full, but their health would suffer dramatically. If you can't go to the bathroom, pretty soon they call it "intestinal obstruction" and it requires surgery.
Andria