I have Woodvils with both finishes. I like both. On the oiled ones I use a hard paste furniture wax, with UV protection, after I do a cleaning/waxing/buffing with Howard's Sun and Feed UV which is liquid and doesn't give as hard a finish. I, also, put the hard wax on the Poly coated to give just a little extra protection from fine finish scratches (or to fill in micro scratches - ever noticed a poly coated wood floor that has had lots of sandy foot traffic?) and to help protect color from changing from UV exposure. I too think the oiled looks better on some woods even some that can take poly. I've purchased a couple of re-homed, off of classies, that had old finish that was worn off, in places, from use but otherwise in great condition. Instead of having them refinished I've very lightly sanded the areas feathering the edges and applied hard past wax to even out the finish. (The Howard's hard paste wax is so hard it's hard to get wax out of fine crevices and grooves in the wood. Using colored waxes keeps the grooves, where wax collects, from being the natural wax color that is unsightly to me especially on the dark wood.) One original Woody door finish was in rough shape. I sanded all that off, applied Howard's, and then used the hard paste wax in matching color. Looks pretty good and only took a few minutes.
Hugs, Feisty Alice
I, also, well oil inside wood, back and edges of doors, with Howard's. Many of the woods will soak up a lot of the oil/wax. As most of my REOs like to "swim", the oil helps to protect the wood. Most of my Woodvils go everywhere and are not just my "home" REOs. (Actually away from home is a lot safer most of the time. But a little safer now that Bubs don't steal them any more. They all still love to "swim.") (I do like to keep the woods that change color from UV out of our seering, extreme UV sun most of the time.)(Their storage cabinet doesn't get much light either.)